Climate crisis more visible in film and TV but solutions remain rare, study finds

Climate crisis more visible in film and TV but solutions remain rare, study finds

Climate change and its causes are appearing more frequently in film and television, but entertainment continues to focus more on the consequences of the crisis and individual actions than large-scale solutions, according to a new report.Released Tuesday and just weeks after Digger, the latest high-profile climate movie that features Tom Cruise as an oil tycoon, the report from the USC Annenberg School for Communications and Journalism and Good Energy, a nonprofit story consultancy, examines climate change in scripted entertainment. The report analyzes 35,120 scripts from 2021 to 2024, building on a 2022 report that found climate-related keywords in just 2.8% of scripts.The latest findings show a modest increase, with climate-related keywords appearing in 3.2% of scripts from 2021 to 2024, a 14% rise. References to “climate change” specifically increased by 33%, from 0.6% to 0.8% of scripts.“Disasters dominate, but nearly two-thirds of the climate storylines we studied also include causes, now bringing the human choices and systems behind the crisis into view,” Good Energy CEO Anna Jane Joyner said. “What thrills me is the rich creative territory artists are already exploring, and all that still lies ahead as they examine what it means to be human in the age of climate change.”Researchers also examined 100 climate-focused storylines to understand how the issue is portrayed. Climate impacts, including rising sea levels, air pollution, food insecurity and biodiversity loss, appeared in 87% of the stories. Disasters, particularly floods, extreme heat and hurricanes, featured in 72%, while 66% addressed causes of the climate crisis, including oil, plastics, deforestation and industrial agriculture.Despite the range of climate-related causes depicted, fossil fuel terms such as oil, coal, fracking, methane and offshore drilling appeared in just 1.1% of all scripts analyzed. Researchers identified the Paramount+ drama Landman, which centers on the west Texas oil industry and has been accused by climate activists of disinformation, as the clearest example of a show featuring fossil fuels. They noted that the series included “prominent discouragement of climate concern and action”, as well as “explicit discouragement of renewable energy”.While climate solutions appeared in 10% of all scripts analyzed, individual consumer behaviors were featured nearly three times as often as systemic solutions. The report found that 7.8% of all scripts referenced consumer actions such as recycling, eating plant-based foods or driving electric vehicles. In contrast, just 2.7% mentioned broader solutions, including renewable energy, carbon capture, net zero emissions or green jobs.Climate-related storylines also appeared across a variety of genres, including medical dramas, romance, comedy, family programming and science fiction. Medical scripts had the highest frequency of climate-related keywords, at 17.4%, followed by romance at 17.1% and comedy at 16.8%.Procedural shows such as FBI, Elsbeth and Grey’s Anatomy also contributed roughly 20 climate-inclusive scripts per year, the report noted, adding that comedy, while only making up 34.4% of all scripts, accounted for 39.3% of scripts that mentioned climate.The report also found that climate narratives frequently shift from fear toward empowerment. Nearly two-thirds, or 63%, of 100 climate-inclusive storylines began with threat as their dominant emotional tone. By the end, however, agency – including courage, optimism and determination – became the leading tone in 44% of stories. Wonder also increased, from 7% at the beginning to 26% by the conclusion, while threat fell to 25%.“We found nearly three in four portrayed or mentioned disasters, but over the course of these stories, the dominant tone shifted from threat toward human agency,” said Erica Rosenthal, director of research at the USC Norman Lear Center.Between 2021 and 2024, climate-inclusive films generated $2.26bn in US box office revenue, while related TV episodes mentioning climate keywords amassed 12.4bn hours of Netflix viewing. Climate-related language appeared more frequently in films (19%) than TV episodes (12.2%), with Apple TV leading streamers at 19.5%, followed by Prime Video at 15.4%, Netflix at 12.6%, Hulu at 12.3% and Paramount+ at 12%.Among broadcasters, Fox had the highest share of climate-related scripts at 16.7%, narrowly followed by ABC at 16.6%, The CW at 13.5%, NBC at 11.1% and CBS at 10.6%.Joyner also stressed the importance of portraying systemic solutions, saying they are “the ones that are really transformative”. She is also particularly interested in the emotional impact of film and television and how stories can move audiences on a personal level.“There’s lots of neuroscience that shows we don’t make decisions based on facts … For the most part, we make decisions based on emotions, and so I’m really interested in the emotional journey that stories bring their characters on, and therefore their audience on,” Joyner said.

Original Source

Read the full article at Theguardian →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.