AdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENTlettersReaders respond to an editorial, “Democrats, Take the Energy Deal.”Nov. 17, 2026, 12:51 p.m. ET Credit...Illustration by Rebecca Chew/The New York TimesTo the Editor:“Democrats, Take the Energy Deal” (editorial, Nov. 13) misreads our political moment.Democrats ran and won in the midterms on reining in President Trump. The Bipartisan Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, which you urge Democrats in Congress to pass, would give the president more freedom, and he’s already told us how he’d use it — rubber-stamping oil and gas pipelines and mines and continuing to suppress “loser” wind turbines. He won’t use it to jump-start renewable energy (an actual, durable path to long-term affordability), but to give more favors to big fossil fuel interests.Another election lesson: Americans are wary of data centers. While the editorial mentioned data centers’ energy consumption, it ignored how the bill removes necessary public participation in reviewing potential damage to historic places, and how it enables data centers (and other projects, including drilling and mining) to be permanently locked in on valuable public lands.The editorial also overlooked the objections of tribal nations; even with recent amendments, the bill’s assault on tribal sovereignty narrows which projects, places and harms agencies must consider, leaving sacred places vulnerable to harmful development.Widespread opposition to the permitting bill isn’t “misplaced.” It reflects serious threats to public participation, tribal rights and our nation’s conservation heritage that lawmakers must address before moving forward.Ryan GellertTracy Stone-ManningIra L. MattThe writers are, respectively, the chief executive of Patagonia, the president of the Wilderness Society and the executive director of the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers.To the Editor:As a former federal judge who spent 30 years hearing cases under the statutes that this permitting bill would gut, I find your cavalier dismissal of concerns about the dismantling of environmental reviews disconnected from the harmful consequences that would flow from this legislation.The question is not what projects we need, but how those projects are built. Can we make sure a new pipeline route limits the destruction to wetlands or waterways? Should the government consider the impacts of clear cutting a national forest — or a park in our nation’s capital — before the trees are felled?This bill, which is being jammed through the Senate, would severely limit courts of jurisdiction to do anything other than return an insufficient environmental review to the agency. The agency could be asked to correct its paperwork, but the project — and the harm it creates — would continue unabated.As I wrote in Bloomberg Law Insight, that would leave the National Environmental Policy Act as a hollow husk. We can and should make environmental reviews more efficient, but we should not leave behind the places and people they are meant to protect.David S. TatelWashingtonThe writer is the author of “Vision: A Memoir of Blindness and Justice.”To the Editor:The passage of the bill that this editorial supports would reverse more than 50 years of federal policy requiring government agencies to make informed decisions when approving development projects.The victims of this ruinous act will inevitably be rural tribal communities in Western states and other communities of color. Tribes and other disadvantaged populations have long suffered the disproportionate adverse impacts of large projects. This became clear 10 years ago, when the Army Corps of Engineers summarily approved the enormous Dakota Access Pipeline at the doorstep of the Standing Rock Indian Reservation in North Dakota.The bill would eliminate the crucial review processes that inform the public about the impacts of large gas and oil projects and helps protect public health and the environment. They are especially important to tribes, whose sacred sites and historical burials dot the Western landscape and have long been protected under federal law.This bill is a giveaway to oil and gas and big tech at the expense of the powerless. Its passage would be a startling betrayal of the tribes and communities of color that recently voted the Democrats back into power.Peter CaposselaKeystone, S.D.To the Editor:I am a volunteer for Citizens’ Climate Lobby, a nonprofit, nonpartisan climate organization. I was one of many who lobbied in Washington in favor of this bill.While I don’t support everything in the bill, not passing it and leaving the status quo could be a costly mistake. The Trump administration is running roughshod over our climate and environment by supporting fossil fuels at every turn, while slowing or stopping less expensive clean energy projects wherever it can. This bill can reverse this ugly course. It can allow us to meet our increasing energy demands with improvements to our grid and transmission systems.It’s important to understand that in the last four congressional sessions only 4 percent of introduced legislation got a vote and less than 2 percent was enacted. So the more favorable conditions some seek might very well lose the votes needed to pass a good permitting bill. Legislation is more durable when bipartisan, which means that both sides need to accept compromises. Congress should take this deal.Jonathan LightLaguna Niguel, Calif.To the Editor:The editorial board dismisses opposition to the current permitting reform bill as merely the complaint of “some environmental groups,” including the Sierra Club, whose concerns are “misplaced.” That characterization diminishes the hundreds of thousands of people who have contacted Congress to oppose this legislation, along with the tribal nations and Tribal Historic Preservation Officers fighting to protect sacred sites, public lands and our shared history.There is no doubt that our permitting system needs updates, and lowering energy costs is urgent. Tribes support energy progress. However, streamlining development should not come at the expense of tribal sovereignty, public participation and the environmental protection that prevents irreversible harm to our communities and planet.Mayane BarudinAlbuquerqueThe writer is the founder and executive director of Sovereign Energy.To the Editor:Your editorial counts the cost of slow energy permitting. Who counts the cost to neighboring families?Our family cherishes our third-generation working farm in Barron County, Wis. Since my father died, I’ve managed it from out of state. MN8 Energy, based in New York, proposes a 100-megawatt, 1039-acre project surrounding our homestead with solar panels, battery storage and a four-acre substation beside our property. In addition, several homes and a community cemetery where veterans going back to the Civil War are buried would be bordered on two sides by the project.At this size, Wisconsin law bypasses local zoning: Approval rests with the governor-appointed Public Service Commission. We can keep farming. We cannot preserve our home’s rural setting as the landscape becomes industrial.MN8 offered a “good neighbor agreement,” including money so we could “have an interest in the success of the project.” We already have an interest: our home.“Take the deal” is easy advice when your home isn’t at stake.Greg WhitmoreAgoura Hills, Calif.The writer is the president of Save Barron County Farms.To the Editor:This isn’t just a debate over clean energy or affordability. This mining and energy bill would fundamentally rewrite some of our country’s most vital bedrock environmental laws and jeopardize our ability to protect the future of our national parks.The risks are real. This bill could fast-track more than 100 mining claims in Bears Ears and Grand Staircase National Monuments, a 210-mile industrial road through Gates of the Arctic National Preserve and America’s largest park landscape, and oil and gas leasing next to Chaco Culture National Historical Park. Not to mention data centers and the infrastructure that power them, threatening parks from Lake Mead to Harpers Ferry.The bill weakens opportunities for tribes, the broader public and experts to have a voice in decisions that affect their communities and public lands. A bill that shifts the balance of power from communities to companies and threatens our most cherished places and resources is a loss, not a “deal,” for America’s national parks.Ed StierliAnnapolis, Md.The writer is the vice president for government affairs at the National Parks Conservation Association.To the Editor:While endangered species may not have been top of mind for voters this election, 84 percent of Americans support the most important law protecting them, the Endangered Species Act. This editorial suggests that laws protecting water, air, land and endangered species are worth sacrificing to meet future needs.This permitting bill decimates the E.S.A. If it becomes law, states could assume authority to conduct critical endangered species reviews, even though they often lack the budget or equivalent authority to protect habitats under existing state laws. While this may clear the way for some clean energy projects, it will also lock in oil and gas leases, timber sales, beach dredging and space exploration.Species like piping plovers, for instance, migrate across several states. We need a consistent application of the law across all ecosystems wherever and whenever the these species are found.Both Senator Chuck Schumer and Senator Kirsten Gillibrand voted on Nov. 9 to advance the vote on this bill. We didn’t expect that in the first days after the supposed blue tsunami our two Democratic New York senators would join the architects of Project 2025, Big Oil and President Trump to champion a bill that would dismantle the E.S.A.There is a way to build a clean energy future. This is not it.Chris AllieriBrooklynThe writer is the executive director of NYC Plover Project.Related ContentAdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENT
Alarm Over an Energy Bill’s Threat to America’s Environment
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Nytimes →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.