We Threw a “Gender Reveal” for Our New Puppy. Now Our Family Is Seeing Red.

We Threw a “Gender Reveal” for Our New Puppy. Now Our Family Is Seeing Red.

Care and Feeding It was harmless. Advice by Enter your email to sign up for Advice. Sign in or create an account to better manage your email preferences. Unsubscribe from email alerts Are you sure you want to unsubscribe from email alerts for Michelle Herman? Being a novelist requires making up problems for your made-up people, then solving them. After writing fiction for decades, I've made up and solved it all. Nov 22, 20268:00 AM Photo illustration by Slate. Photo by Anna Zakurakina/Getty Images Plus and diane39/iStock/Getty Images Plus. Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. Care and Feeding is Slate’s parenting advice column. Have a question for Care and Feeding? Submit it here. Dear Care and Feeding, My husband was never allowed to have a pet growing up because his mother said they were unhygienic. He always wanted a certain dog breed, and we finally were able to afford a space to make it a reality. We were on a waitlist with an ethical breeder and got a dog at last. To celebrate, we had a “gender-reveal” party: We decorated our home, got a cake, and invited friends over. We made a silly video where we opened up a box to announce that it was a girl and pulled out the puppy. We put the video on social media for all our friends and family to see. My sister-in-law saw the post and publicly berated us for being an embarrassment and “stealing” a tradition meant for real babies, not fur ones. She said we were making a mockery of gender-reveals. I called my brother, and he didn’t apologize. He said the video was tone-deaf and insensitive since they were having difficulty conceiving. But I didn’t even know they were trying! Both of them have teenagers from previous marriages. My brother said it didn’t matter that I didn’t know, that I should have put more thought into how doing this would affect other people. I bit my tongue, but the entire conversation makes me bristle every time I think about it. My husband and I made a silly, harmless video to celebrate a milestone dream of his. We weren’t making a mockery of anything or anybody. My brother is much older than I am, so we have never been close. My sister-in-law is someone who loves to hold a grudge. She will not shut up about how and why she was wronged. My husband wants to skip Thanksgiving at my parents’ house because he knows the video is going to come up. Now we’ve been invited to visit friends for Thanksgiving and bring the puppy. My parents will be upset since Thanksgiving has always been their big holiday. Do I even bother to try to explain things? —Fur-Ious Dear Fur, I am trying very hard not to let my distaste for the “tradition” of gender-reveal parties color my answer to your question. But making such a big deal about boy versus girl has always struck me as absurd, and the assigning of pink for girls and blue for boys is just stupid. I am amazed that anyone still does it. So, from my point of view, the idea that anyone would be outraged by someone making a mockery of this nonsense is baffling. But—to be fair—you were (kind of) mocking the human baby gender-reveal, weren’t you? And it’s a real head-scratcher to me why you thought revealing the longed-for puppy through a fake gender-reveal was a cute thing to do. So while I think your brother and sister-in-law are being ridiculous, I also think your digging your heels in about how you were in the right is silly. And I don’t know what kind of “explanation” you would offer your parents about this rift between you and your brother. Honestly, it seems pretty clear to me that you don’t like each other, and that you are seizing upon his overreaction—or his loyal defense of his overreacting, obnoxious wife—as an excuse to skip Thanksgiving with your family. The truth is, you don’t need an excuse. If you prefer to spend Thanksgiving with friends, especially friends who have invited your beloved puppy, just tell your parents you’ve made other plans this year. Holidays are not—or should not be—occasions for mandatory attendance. They are supposed to be fun. Please keep questions short (<150 words), and don’t submit the same question to multiple columns. We are unable to edit or remove questions after publication. Use pseudonyms to maintain anonymity. Your submission may be used in other Slate advice columns and may be edited for publication. Dear Care and Feeding, I just turned 60 and have been thinking a lot about my childhood best friend. “Audrey” and I were best friends from age 3, culminating in living together for our first year post-college. She is as much a part of my childhood memories as my own family. Audrey’s father died when we were 19, and, as you can imagine, it was life-changing and traumatic for her. I feel pretty certain that I was not there for her the way she needed me to be after we lived together, but I did my best at the time. When I got married, she agreed to be a bridesmaid, but it was clear she felt uncomfortable, and we have barely spoken in the years since. Recently, I remembered something that I had blocked: At my wedding, I seated her at a table with her sister (thinking she’d like that) but clearly at a table of people I didn’t know what to do with. We never spoke about it, but I believe that this was the final straw for her. I am mortified that I did that and feel like I need to apologize, but how and to what end? Our mothers, now in their late 80s, are still friends, and I think part of me wants to reach out before anything happens to either of them. I welcome any advice you have. —Audrey’s Former Best Friend Dear Former, I don’t think there’s any harm in reaching out and telling her everything you’ve just told me. But I do want you to think about a couple of the things you’ve said here: that you feel like you need to apologize (rather than: I feel truly regretful, and I’d like to make amends) and that, in addition to asking how you might go about apologizing, you ask “to what end?” So before you contact your old friend, make sure you know what you want from her. Do you want to be forgiven for seating her with the strays at your wedding, or for being unable, at 19, to be the kind of friend to her you wish you’d been? Do you want to reconnect and renew the friendship? Or is there something else altogether you hope to accomplish? Once you’re clear on your own intentions—even if you come to the conclusion that the “to what end” is strictly about future funerals and possible awkwardness—why not write her a letter or an email? You can let her know that she’s been on your mind, tell her how much she meant to you for so long, and apologize for the ways you believe you let her down. If you do apologize, be sure that you are sincerely regretful. (An apology that isn’t heartfelt, or that is intended only to let oneself off the hook, isn’t really an apology at all and is rarely welcomed.) If your soul-searching has led you to realizing that all you want is “closure” or that it’s your mothers’ deaths you’re thinking of, and not your relationship with each other, there’s no need to propose a meeting or a conversation: The letter is an end in itself. She can choose whether or not to respond, and you can leave it there. If, however, you miss her friendship and would like to see if it’s possible to rekindle it, say so. You’ve got nothing to lose. Ever Gotten a Call From Human Resources? Laura Helmuth and Doree Shafrir want to hear about it—and help you navigate your problems at work. Does your colleague constantly bug you after hours? Has an ill-advised work romance gone awry? Ask us your question here! Dear Care and Feeding, I am sorely tempted to skip Thanksgiving this year. We’re a small family—just my husband, “Felix,” and our two kids—and this year both kids, away at colleges in out-of-the-way East Coast locales that require connecting flights for a trip back to the Midwest, have decided not to make the trip home. My daughter said, “I’ll be home in a month for Christmas anyway, so what’s the point? It’s a waste of time and money to do it twice in such a short time.” My son said, “Honestly, Mom, I have never liked anything about Thanksgiving but the mashed potatoes, and I have so much work to do for school, I’d rather not take a break right now.” Both of them have been invited to roommates’ and friends’ families who live nearby for Thanksgiving (daughter accepted one of the invites; son says he politely declined all and is looking forward to some alone time and also to “not have to pretend to enjoy eating turkey” or think up something he’s thankful for “for public consumption”). I’m sad that I won’t see them until next month, of course. But I’m not going to make a big deal out of it. In fact, since it’ll just be my husband and me, I’d like to forego the turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, pies, etc., of it all and either treat it like any other day or, if Felix wants a Thanksgiving dinner, have it at a restaurant. He sees the whole situation differently. He says the kids are being disrespectful, and he’s shocked that I’m “allowing” it, and he wants me to make Thanksgiving dinner even if it’s just the two of us! He hates the idea of going out to eat on Thanksgiving, and he refuses to ignore the holiday. What do I do? —Seriously? Turkey for Two? Dear Seriously, First of all: Kudos on not giving your college-age kids a hard time about not coming home. (Extra points for raising them in such a way that they feel OK about telling you they’re not coming home!) As to skipping Thanksgiving, you have my permission. Full disclosure: I have done Thanksgiving just for two a couple of times and enjoyed it—but unlike your son, I love Thanksgiving food, and I like fixing it, no matter how many people will be eating it. I’ve also, some years, invited an assortment of friends who had nowhere else to go to join us. And this year, since we are in the middle of packing up and moving houses long distance, I’m considering skipping it myself—I’ve already packed up the kitchen, after all. If your husband is so adamant about turkey and all the trimmings at home, he should be the one to provide it. Tell him I said so. —Michelle More Advice From Slate My 8-year-old son invariably needs to come home from sleepovers in the middle of the night. He gets homesick. I did as well, so I understand that horrible nauseating feeling. The problem is he keeps wanting to attend sleepovers just the same. Advice Family Kids

Original Source

Read the full article at Slate →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.