Life Or anytime someone you’re talking to is a little offensive. Photo illustration by Slate. Photos by Getty Images Plus. Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. When I was in college, someone I considered a friend did something I would now deem to be mansplaining. He was a guy I’d done a bunch of theater with, and while I don’t remember the context, he started saying that women should wear high heels because they elongate the line of the leg, giving the appearance of height and slimness. “They make women more beautiful,” he helpfully told me. I’ve disliked him since. But looking back, I wish I had asked him a question I ask almost daily now: What do you mean by that? I have a sense of what I think this guy meant by his statement. But that’s the problem with so many conversations. I’m sure I know what the other person is saying. Do I, really? This one question opens up conversations like a flower. It has changed personal relationships for the better and improved my work as a professor. It defuses tension, forces consideration, and challenges assumptions. I’d like to say I invented it or discovered it myself, but it came, as many good things do, from my mother. I’ve found the deceptively uncomplicated What do you mean by that? to be wildly useful for me, and for the person to whom I’m asking it. When you’re hit with a confusing jumble of words, of course it’s a natural go-to. But it is also the most useful question I have when I’m bothered by something someone says, when I’m tempted to believe I know exactly what is being said to me (and what it means about the person who said it). It can challenge whoever I’m talking to to become clearer and more articulate. It can challenge me to be more open-minded as well, to jump to fewer conclusions and draw fewer assumptions about the person in front of me. Maybe if I’d asked my college friend what he meant, he would have realized he’d blurted out something kind of weird with the high-heels thing and said so. Or maybe he would have told me how trying on heels made him feel, and how he’d had to wear them one time for a role. What do you mean by that? would have given us both time and space to think, consider, elaborate, and take a breath. Instead, I’m left, years later, with a lingering grudge. There is nothing I have found more dangerous or more likely to stoke conflict, or to breed distrust and judgment, than assuming I know who a person is based on one thing that they say. And yet I find myself, and most people I know, consciously or unconsciously reading epic-length notions of identity, morality, and values into a sentence or two. A simple question helps me gain clarity as much as it overturns some of those assumptions, always for the good. Sometimes asking this question confirms where my brain is turning. (Once, a male student told me he didn’t find a story relatable. What do you mean by that? was met with I’m not interested in the experiences of these women; they aren’t relevant to me.) Sometimes it shows me something revelatory, teaches me that my understanding and their intention were worlds apart. Most often, it forces both the responder and me to clarify, to communicate more strongly, to work harder to make ourselves understood. No matter how confident you are about the other person, what do you have to lose by asking? What do you mean by that? is a question that costs little and can gain all a lot. Especially if we’re actually willing to listen to the response. Dating and Relationships Family
The Simple Question to Ask When a Relative Says Something out of Pocket at Thanksgiving
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Slate →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.