US builds up forces around Iran, but can it sustain another war?

US builds up forces around Iran, but can it sustain another war?

A third US aircraft carrier and its escorts arrived in the Middle East on Sunday, further bolstering Washington's military presence around Iran. The deployment of the USS Theodore Roosevelt carrier strike group comes even as the US maintains it has no intention of resuming large-scale combat operations and will continue seeking to pressure Iran through a blockade. “We don’t need to conduct military strikes if we’re achieving the same objective through economic means and economic pressure,” US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said on 10 November. The US military build-up suggests however that the economic blockade Washington has enforced against Iran since 14 July is unlikely to push Tehran into capitulation any time soon. Attacks in the Gulf in recent days have highlighted Iran's capacity to respond to perceived US threats and its willingness to do so. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Meanwhile, media reports suggest that the US Navy is approaching breaking point, with sailors facing shortages of fresh food. Navy Secretary Hung Cao told sailors and their families to prepare for deployments lasting at least 11 months, up from the standard six, US media outlet MS NOW reported on Wednesday. 'With military means, the American administration is capable of achieving tactical victories, but no tactical victory can make up for strategic mistakes' – Omer Ozkizilcik, Atlantic Council The extended deployments are further draining morale among the navy’s rank and file, with growing resentment over the prospect of another open-ended war in the Middle East. The navy has deployed at least 17 destroyers to enforce the US blockade of Iranian ports, Cao reportedly said. The US has a fleet of 77 destroyers, with almost 30 currently undergoing maintenance. “The Trump administration is in a very difficult position in which it tries to flex its muscles and to strong-arm Iran into a deal,” Omer Ozkizilcik, a non-resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, told Middle East Eye. “But unfortunately for [the administration], its strategic miscalculation from day one of this war is the main obstacle for Trump to achieve what he wants in Iran.” The USS Theodore Roosevelt (right) alongside Australia's HMAS Stalwart on 4 November 2026 (US Navy/AFP) In addition to its sea blockade of Iran, Washington is now pursuing a land campaign. The US military has set up what it calls Task Force Iron Gate to blockade Iran’s land crossings. President Trump declared the task force in “full force and effect” on 8 November and insisted that the war was “militarily... effectively over” and that the US was satisfied with the status quo. “We don’t need a deal with Iran,” he said on 12 November. Not everyone agrees with that assessment. “With military means, the American administration is capable of achieving tactical victories, but no tactical victory can make up for strategic mistakes,” said Ozkizilcik. One of the most consequential strategic miscalculations was Trump's decision to place greater faith in intelligence provided by the Israeli leadership than in the assessments of his own advisers, before assuming that a short air campaign alone would force Iran to capitulate. Another round of the conflict is unlikely to produce different results, according to most analysts. The Gulf states also understand that renewed fighting could hit them hardest. Qatar is still seeking to mediate. “However, there is not much manoeuvre room for the Gulf states present, except in the diplomatic sphere and their sway with the Trump administration,” noted Ozkizilcik. Economic cost of the war The Israeli-US war on Iran has already damaged the world economy. The German chancellor, an early proponent of the war, recently complained that higher energy costs alone had cost European Union businesses and consumers more than $112bn. Moody’s estimated in October that the war had cost about $2,000 per US household on average, due to higher inflation and energy costs. American consumers have paid more than $161bn in additional energy costs, according to Brown University’s Iran War Energy Tracker. The economic costs have spread far beyond the Gulf, Europe and the US. ‘Loss of confidence’: US Navy fires commanders of warships deployed against Iran Read More » Researchers estimate that east Asia paid an additional $49bn in net fossil-fuel costs between March and August, and the United Nations Development Programme’s April assessment projected up to $300bn in lost economic output across the Asia-Pacific region. Meanwhile, 32 African economies have faced a combined $21.9bn increase in energy costs, pushing millions more into poverty. Iran, too, has suffered significant damage. “The blockade and sanctions are already imposing substantial costs on Iran, and Washington appears to believe that time is working in its favour,” Hamidreza Azizi, a senior Iran analyst at Crisis Group, told MEE. “But there is an important distinction between weakening Iran economically and forcing its leadership to make political concessions,” he said. There is no reason to believe that Tehran is “prepared to accept American demands simply because economic conditions are deteriorating,” he added. According to Azizi, the military build-up against Iran could reinforce “Washington's coercive diplomacy by maintaining a credible threat of further strikes, while also preparing for the possibility that Iran may escalate militarily to break the blockade”. But it also reflects the “limitations and uncertainties of the economic pressure strategy”, he added. Shortage of munitions While Washington's political leadership is expanding its military presence, there is less appetite for escalation within the armed forces. Furthermore, reports in the US media are increasingly at odds with the Trump administration's efforts to project readiness for renewed conflict. The Wall Street Journal reported on 17 November that the Pentagon was struggling to secure the critical materials needed to replenish its stocks of Patriot missile interceptors, as key parts of the supply chain fail to keep pace with military demand. 'Renewed military action risks prolonging the conflict rather than resolving it' – Hamidreza Azizi, Iran analyst at Crisis Group A munitions update by the International Institute for Strategic Studies on 10 November warned that US munitions stocks remained depleted. It added that while the US had enough munitions to resume fighting with Iran, it remained vulnerable after expending two-thirds of its pre-war inventory of critical weapons systems. Moreover, having enough weapons to fight another war is different from having a strategy capable of achieving a political settlement. While previous US and Israeli attacks inflicted considerable damage on Iran’s military infrastructure and political leadership, they “failed to dismantle the Islamic Republic's command structure or deprive Tehran of its ability to impose costs on the United States and its regional partners”, Azizi said. “Further strikes could certainly destroy more military assets and weaken specific Iranian capabilities, but there is little evidence that they would produce a decisive political outcome,” he added. Critics accuse The New York Times of promoting Iran war propaganda Read More » The Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) estimated that during the 39-day campaign before the April ceasefire, US forces expended between 1,060 and 1,430 Patriot interceptors, or about 45 to 61 percent of a pre-war inventory estimated at 2,330, as well as between 190 and 290 THAAD interceptors from a stockpile of around 360. “While it only takes a few minutes to launch a missile, it can take years to manufacture replacement missiles for missile-defence systems,” the CSIS report warned. “Another round of strikes could therefore strengthen Tehran's determination to retaliate, potentially expanding the confrontation across the region and beyond,” said Azizi. “This is the central dilemma for Washington: it has the military capability to inflict enormous damage on Iran, but that does not necessarily translate into an ability to compel Tehran to accept its terms,” he added. “Without a realistic political objective and a credible diplomatic exit strategy, renewed military action risks prolonging the conflict rather than resolving it.”

Original Source

Read the full article at Middleeasteye →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.