The Untapped Keg of Overturnable Pitches

The Untapped Keg of Overturnable Pitches

Benny Sieu-Imagn Images In the first season of MLB’s ABS era, the most visible and discussed growing pains associated with the challenge system were attached to challenges that actually happened. Fans and analysts collectively screamed as calls were upheld and inhaled through gritted teeth as challenges were deployed a bit too early in the game on pitches that, in a prior season, would have been referred to as borderline calls. And while a burned challenge is certainly more glaring and potentially more impactful (depending on the situation), missed opportunities to challenge can carry a high cost as well. On August 8, Dodgers reliever Tanner Scott was brought in to face Ryan Waldschmidt with two outs and the bases loaded in the bottom of the eighth. With Los Angeles clinging to a 1-0 lead, Scott threw an 0-0 fastball to Waldschmidt for a called strike. Except the pitch missed the outer edge of the zone by about an inch. The call wasn’t egregious, but given the game situation, it warranted a helmet tap, and Arizona still had one challenge remaining. Granted, with just one (incorrect) challenge left, it’s understandable to want to hold onto it to make sure ball four is called correctly or to prevent a miscalled strike three. However, after Scott was gifted strike one, he followed up with a slider in the dirt and a four-seamer below the zone. If Waldschmidt had challenged the 0-0 pitch, there’s a chance he would have wound up in a 3-0 count against a pitcher with nowhere to put him. Of course, if Scott had fallen behind 1-0, there’s no way to know if he still would’ve risked overthrowing his slider or stuck with the more controllable fastball. But even then, Waldschmidt would have had better odds of getting a pitch to hit. Instead, he got under a fastball on the inner black for a routine fly ball to center and Scott escaped the jam. The Diamondbacks came back to tie the game in the ninth against Edwin Díaz, but the Dodgers won it in the 10th on an RBI-single from Shohei Ohtani. Had Arizona scratched a run or two across in the eighth, it may have been able to secure the win before facing the top of the Los Angeles lineup in a zombie-runner scenario. Still, not all of the pitches left unchallenged are quite so consequential, such as in the May 13 meeting between the Rays and the Blue Jays, which finished regulation tied at one. By the time Blue Jays center fielder Daulton Varsho stepped to the plate in the bottom of the 10th, the bases were loaded with just one out and Toronto trailed 3-1. Rays reliever Aaron Brooks started Varsho with two fastballs just above the zone. He fouled off the first and took the second for a called strike even though it missed the zone by over an inch. Since teams are allotted one challenge to work with at the start of each extra inning, Varsho did have a challenge available to him that would have flipped the count from 0-2 to 1-1. Instead, he was forced into defensive mode with two strikes. It all worked out fine, though. He took two balls to get back into the count, then fouled off another high heater. On the sixth pitch of the plate appearance, Brooks went back to the same spot with a fastball, and this time Varsho made clean contact. He pulled the pitch over the left field wall for a walk-off grand slam and probably hasn’t thought about that 0-1 strike-that-should-have-been-a-ball since. Zooming out, in the league’s first season under the ABS challenge system, batters took 356,590 pitches. Those takes represent the potential opportunities available to challenge the umpire’s ball/strike call. Of those 356,590 calls, 24,123 were incorrect. Of the incorrect calls, 5,686 (23.6%) were challenged and overturned, meaning 18,437 (76.4%) missed calls went unchallenged. As the Varsho example demonstrates, leaving a pitch unchallenged, even in a high-leverage moment, can work out just fine. It’s unnecessary and unreasonable to expect players to challenge 100% of incorrect calls, but 23.6% feels too high. In addition to the 5,686 calls overturned, 4,872 calls were challenged and upheld. Based on some napkin math that ignores the additional challenges granted in extras, at least 9,716 total challenges were available across the league’s 2,429 games. After subtracting the failed challenges, an estimated 4,844 challenges were left unused, suggesting there’s definitely some untapped value here. But since challenging does come with the risk of eventually losing the ability to challenge, players and teams still need to prioritize calling for a challenge only when the game context makes a flipped call most meaningful, or when a player is extremely confident the call was incorrect. As such, I went looking for the most obvious missed opportunities among the unchallenged pitches. I measured the obviousness of the missed opportunity a few different ways: The pitch’s distance from the edge of the zone: Pitches located further from the boundary between balls and strikes should instill more confidence in a player contemplating a challenge. The leverage index (LI) of the plate appearance when the pitch occurs: The potential of that plate appearance to trigger a dramatic swing in win probability. LI uses base-out state, inning, and game score to measure the importance of a situation based on its likelihood to impact the outcome of the game. The run value of a successful challenge: The change in that inning’s expected runs scored as a result of the flipped call. Since we’re talking about individual ball/strike calls, I calculated the change in run expectancy using RE288, which considers both the current base-out state and count to measure the importance of a situation strictly based on how it impacts run scoring over the remainder of the inning, while ignoring the broader game context. You’ll notice the numbers below are slightly lower than those cited above, which come directly from the Baseball Savant search tool. For the remaining analysis, I filtered out pitches thrown by position players, because I refuse to do serious analysis once the teams are no longer being serious. This is also a decent place to note that Savant provides a “% Opp. Taken” metric, which is a sort of inverse to the opportunities not taken that are central to this discussion. However, Savant’s metric defines opportunity as, “Any pitch where a player is allowed, by the rulebook, to make a challenge. This ignores whether it’s a good idea, whether the umpire missed the call, if he’s permitted by his team to challenge, or any other strategic considerations.” This analysis is very much interested in strategic considerations and as such, defines opportunity as pitches where the umpire’s call was incorrect and does not require an available challenge, since making sure challenges are available as needed is part of the strategy too. The pitches are split based on the umpire’s call, since challenging balls is a task for catchers (and sometimes pitchers, but they don’t do it very often and they’re not very good at it, so we’re going to ignore them from here on out), while challenging called strikes is up to hitters; the two decisions require slightly different skill sets since they’re done from different perspectives. Leaguewide trends reinforce that hitters were more passive than catchers, leaving more missed calls unchallenged. Both groups had a challenge available to use around 90% of the time. Reassuringly, the number of unchallenged pitches dwindled the further they drifted from the edge of the zone, and a smaller proportion of those pitches were allowed to pass with a challenge still available. Unchallenged Incorrect Calls by Distance From the Edge of the Zone Total Incorrect 2 in. Call Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Ball 7443 90.3% 5206 91.4% 2158 87.9% 78 85.9% Strike 10422 91.4% 6502 91.6% 3671 91.5% 249 84.7% “Available %” indicates the percentage of incorrect calls where the team had a challenge available. With the overall totals still shown for reference, the rest of the table below splits those totals by LI (using the standard definitions for low, medium, and high leverage). Given the relatively small numbers in the “High Leverage” columns, it might appear that both catchers and batters are doing a really good job of minimizing the number of incorrect calls that go unchallenged during the game’s key moments. But in 2026, high-leverage pitches made up just 9.1% of all called pitches. If players were truly excelling at overturning calls on high-leverage pitches, we’d expect those pitches to make up a lower share of missed overturns when compared to called pitches on the whole, but high-leverage pitches made up 8.3% of incorrect unchallenged calls. Players challenged high-leverage pitches at a 14% clip (about 5 percentage points above expectation), but the fact that those additional challenges didn’t do much to improve their hit rate on overturnable pitches suggests that some of those challenges may have been desperation plays near the end of game, when there was nothing to lose because challenges don’t roll over. Unchallenged Incorrect Calls by Leverage Index Total Incorrect Low Leverage Medium Leverage High Leverage Call Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Ball 7443 90.3% 3742 89.4% 3025 93.5% 676 80.3% Strike 10422 91.4% 5803 90.7% 3797 94.0% 822 84.1% “Available %” indicates the percentage of incorrect calls where the team had a challenge available. As for the estimated value of the runs lost as a result of timid challenge tendencies, looking at the leaguewide total isn’t particularly informative, but as we get into team- and player-level breakdowns, it’s useful to know that flipping the call on over 1,600 of the miscalled pitches would swing the inning’s expected run scoring by more than a quarter of a run, which is more than the run value of a stolen base. So with that and the league numbers above acting as a guidepost, we can take an educated look at how individual teams measured up. Overall, the data suggests that there’s still plenty of opportunity to seize in the most obvious places — pitches more than an inch away from the edge of the zone, pitches thrown in high-leverage situations, and pitches where the run value of a correct challenge is over 0.25. The table below focuses on the unchallenged calls that fall into one of those three categories. Unchallenged Incorrect Calls by Team – Catchers Total Incorrect Over 1 Inch From Edge of Zone High Leverage Run Value > 0.25 Team Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Angels 301 90.7% 85 94.1% 25 88.0% 27 87.1% Reds 299 95.0% 102 91.2% 28 82.1% 29 93.5% Athletics 289 93.4% 92 88.0% 33 78.8% 24 92.3% Orioles 289 92.4% 88 84.1% 26 80.8% 23 82.1% Pirates 273 90.1% 83 83.1% 19 78.9% 25 92.6% Red Sox 272 92.6% 90 95.6% 40 87.5% 20 90.9% Royals 270 93.0% 99 96.0% 22 95.5% 17 85.0% Nationals 266 87.2% 73 89.0% 23 73.9% 18 72.0% Astros 265 87.2% 84 88.1% 15 73.3% 13 65.0% Rangers 263 92.8% 82 92.7% 21 85.7% 15 93.8% Cardinals 254 94.1% 74 95.9% 17 70.6% 27 90.0% Padres 254 90.2% 84 81.0% 26 76.9% 24 85.7% Brewers 253 85.8% 77 80.5% 19 73.7% 20 90.9% Giants 253 89.3% 77 83.1% 26 69.2% 10 76.9% Mariners 249 89.2% 66 87.9% 29 86.2% 18 90.0% Phillies 245 96.7% 60 95.0% 23 100.0% 14 100.0% White Sox 244 78.3% 69 84.1% 25 68.0% 20 64.5% Tigers 242 94.2% 72 95.8% 19 94.7% 15 83.3% Cubs 239 95.0% 56 91.1% 17 94.1% 21 95.5% Twins 239 82.8% 71 70.4% 28 75.0% 19 82.6% Guardians 238 83.6% 74 81.1% 29 72.4% 19 90.5% Dodgers 234 93.6% 76 92.1% 14 78.6% 24 100.0% Mets 232 90.1% 70 91.4% 21 85.7% 25 86.2% Rockies 229 90.0% 64 78.1% 13 76.9% 13 81.3% Diamondbacks 219 96.3% 60 93.3% 14 78.6% 20 95.2% Braves 216 88.0% 63 84.1% 19 63.2% 23 82.1% Marlins 206 86.9% 60 81.7% 17 94.1% 15 78.9% Rays 205 87.8% 53 88.7% 20 90.0% 14 66.7% Blue Jays 204 90.2% 75 86.7% 24 66.7% 20 83.3% Yankees 201 88.6% 57 84.2% 24 70.8% 14 82.4% “Available %” indicates the percentage of incorrect calls where the team had a challenge available. The catchers for the Reds, A’s, and Red Sox rank near the top (where first is worst) of all three categories in terms of missed opportunities, while the backstops for the Yankees, Rays, and Rockies pretty consistently left the fewest key overturns on the table. Unchallenged Incorrect Calls by Team – Batters Total Incorrect Over 1 Inch From Edge of Zone High Leverage Run Value > 0.25 Team Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Quantity Available % Brewers 442 91.9% 162 90.7% 47 85.1% 33 89.2% Marlins 398 91.5% 151 93.4% 31 87.1% 27 87.1% Nationals 391 89.5% 154 89.6% 26 76.9% 36 90.0% Orioles 381 93.2% 147 94.6% 31 87.1% 34 87.2% Guardians 376 90.4% 151 88.1% 31 74.2% 27 84.4% Diamondbacks 374 96.8% 154 98.1% 43 100.0% 33 94.3% Rays 374 89.6% 141 90.8% 28 85.7% 26 81.3% Reds 374 94.4% 156 93.6% 23 82.6% 33 94.3% Tigers 360 92.8% 134 94.0% 28 78.6% 27 96.4% Mariners 358 90.8% 129 90.7% 32 78.1% 31 88.6% Mets 358 86.3% 137 85.4% 23 78.3% 25 80.6% Angels 355 91.8% 124 88.7% 26 84.6% 23 85.2% Cardinals 350 93.4% 130 93.8% 29 86.2% 24 82.8% Pirates 349 89.7% 148 89.2% 19 89.5% 28 82.4% Dodgers 346 96.5% 120 98.3% 21 85.7% 27 96.4% Red Sox 346 93.9% 135 93.3% 29 86.2% 32 91.4% White Sox 345 83.8% 128 85.9% 22 77.3% 34 89.5% Rangers 343 96.2% 117 94.0% 27 92.6% 35 92.1% Giants 342 90.9% 129 87.6% 27 81.5% 26 89.7% Royals 338 91.7% 109 91.7% 23 73.9% 17 81.0% Cubs 330 94.8% 108 97.2% 24 87.5% 28 93.3% Athletics 329 91.5% 128 92.2% 29 89.7% 27 81.8% Blue Jays 328 93.0% 136 93.4% 34 79.4% 17 94.4% Twins 320 85.3% 127 85.8% 25 88.0% 23 74.2% Padres 316 90.8% 122 88.5% 31 90.3% 26 96.3% Astros 304 86.5% 100 83.0% 25 60.0% 23 82.1% Phillies 303 95.7% 100 95.0% 28 82.1% 24 88.9% Yankees 302 86.8% 118 84.7% 25 84.0% 24 85.7% Braves 296 91.6% 111 88.3% 20 100.0% 20 95.2% Rockies 294 88.8% 114 89.5% 15 80.0% 21 84.0% “Available %” indicates the percentage of incorrect calls where the team had a challenge available. Batters for the Brewers led the league in bypassing meaningful opportunities to challenge. Not only that, there was a wide gap between Milwaukee and the next worst team in total unchallenged calls, pitches that were at least an inch from the edge of the zone, and blown calls in high-leverage situations. The Nationals accruing more missed challenges with high run values saved the Brewers from a clean sweep. But surely, Milwaukee’s hitters were just saving as many challenges as possible for catcher William Contreras? The Brewers backstop demonstrated his uncanny ability to wield a challenge during postseason, so it would be understandable to place as many challenges as possible under his purview. But scrolling back up to the team-catcher table reveals the Brewers were firmly in the middle of the pack on defensive challenges, at least with respect to maximizing overturns. So are the broadly held beliefs that Contreras is a dominant ABS challenger and the Brewers are masters of extracting value from every available nook and cranny not entirely accurate? Let’s come back to that in a minute. I don’t want to move on to Contreras and individual player performance before acknowledging the Rockies. The first team table highlighted how Colorado’s catchers (mostly Hunter Goodman) managed to avoid letting many pitches in the zone stand as anything other than called strikes, and in the second table, the Rockies again ranked highly in all categories. If it feels weird reading praise for the Rockies, you’re not alone; I felt weird typing it. But this could be a sign of a positive sea change in, admittedly, landlocked Denver. Colorado’s new front office has a lot of internal infrastructure to install and overhaul, and it’ll be years before we know for sure if anything the organization implemented is truly working. Still, there are other small, strategic changes that can be implemented relatively quickly, with effects that pay off almost instantly. A thorough strategy for ABS challenges falls under that category. The catch is that this kind of thing requires not only getting the specific optimizations right, but communicating the end result in a way that is simple to understand and put into practice. A lot of organizations can do one or the other, but not both. If the Rockies have pulled off a uniform, roster-wide adoption of a math-based strategy, that bodes well for whatever other plans they have in motion. Now, back to Contreras and the Brewers. The table below shows individual catcher performance in the context of incorrect calls left unchallenged. Since players have varying workloads (unlike teams who mostly play the same number of games), and most of the metrics considered here are counting stats, I had to control for the number of called pitches the catcher was behind the plate for. As a result, the last three columns of the table all represent a prorated estimate of what the number would have been if the player caught 8,000 called pitches (which serves as a rough estimate for a full-season workload). And because I had to draw the line somewhere, only the top 30 catchers by called pitches are shown below. Unchallenged Incorrect Calls by Player – Catchers The last three columns are prorated to represent a full season’s workload. As with the team-catcher metrics, Contreras slots in right around the middle, which makes sense considering he caught 128 games for the Brewers. What’s harder to understand is how we reconcile this depiction of Contreras with the more recent image we have of him in the postseason. The problem with looking at a player’s top-line stats for the season is they mask the shape and evolution of that player’s production. And in this particular case, players were tasked with honing a somewhat new skill on the fly, opening up a larger potential for evolution and change than we typically observe at the big league level. Going month-by-month through the season reveals the evolution of Contreras and his challenge acumen. It’s not perfectly linear, and it shows that he did backslide in September, but it’s clear that he trended up as the season progressed, making it easier to accept that what we saw from him in October was not entirely small-sample flukiness. William Contreras Month-Over-Month Evolution Month Incorrect Calls Availability % RV Lost Over 1 Inch From Edge of Zone High Leverage Mar/Apr 48 72.9% 4.13 13 3 May 36 100.0% 4.70 8 3 June 36 88.9% 3.72 12 2 July 17 94.1% 2.34 5 2 Aug 28 78.6% 2.62 6 1 Sept 24 83.3% 4.42 11 5 All numbers prorated slightly to control for monthly variation in workload On the hitting side the numbers are less dramatic. While a team’s catchers might be leaving a full win or two worth of runs on the table with their reluctance to tap the helmet, an individual batter is at worst accumulating 10 runs of lost value (or about one win), and Curtis Mead’s 10.31 runs is a full run worse than Paul Goldschmidt in second place. The table below only shows the 30 worst offenders by prorated run value lost, and they comprise an interesting collection of old heads like Goldschmidt and Mike Trout, who may be feeling too set in their ways to adapt to a new system, and younger players like Dylan Crews and Dylan Beavers, who may still be feeling their focus pulled in too many directions while in the batter’s box to worry about challenging. For others, the decision to remain passive is an active choice to defer to their teammates, whether that means letting their catchers deploy them to support the pitching staff, or in the case of Masyn Winn, letting other hitters in the lineup use them to play to their strengths. “There are too many pitches that are 50/50 — that I think are balls, and then I go back and look at them and they’re strikes — for me to be super confident around the edges,” Winn told Matt Martell back in June. “So, I’d rather save them for guys like Noot[baar] in big situations, guys like [Jordan Walker] that can really do some damage with that extra strike. I like to save them for the defense, too. There are so many times where I feel like our catchers do a great job and they don’t get the call, so I want them to be able to have the luxury if we do have one to burn.” Unchallenged Incorrect Calls by Player – Batters The last three columns are prorated to represent a full season’s workload. Obviously, the challengeable pitches that got away are just one component of the overall ABS challenge strategy, and maybe not even the most important one. But it’s nice to have a component of the game where strategies and skills are still evolving in real time right before our very eyes.

Original Source

Read the full article at Blogs →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.