The Bronx Is Worm-Burning: Yankees Bring Back Jonathan Loáisiga, Tim Hill

The Bronx Is Worm-Burning: Yankees Bring Back Jonathan Loáisiga, Tim Hill

Brad Penner-Imagn Images After one year in the desert, Jonathan Loáisiga is returning to the Bronx. On Friday morning, ESPN’s Jorge Castillo reported that the right-handed reliever has signed a two-year deal with a club option for 2029. MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand reported that the deal is worth $18 million. Although it’s been four years since the Yankees’ relievers ranked better than 13th in WAR, their 3.18 ERA in 2026 was the second-best in baseball. The Yankees also re-signed lefty reliever Tim Hill to a one-year deal (with an option for a second) on Sunday. Between these two moves and David Bednar accepting the team’s qualifying offer, it’s starting to feel like Brian Cashman’s plan is simply to get the bullpen band back together. Paul Blackburn, Michael Fulmer, and John Schreiber better make sure their phones aren’t on Do Not Disturb. We’ll get into Hill a bit later, because the 32-year-old Loáisiga is the headliner here. He ranked 23rd among our Top 50 Free Agents list. This total is not quite the two years and $24 million that Ben Clemens predicted, but it’s much closer than our crowdsourced estimates, which fell right between one and two years, and predicted an AAV of $6.1 million. Loáisiga debuted with the Yankees in 2018 and spent eight years with the team, running a 3.54 ERA and 3.86 FIP across 193 appearances and 249 1/3 innings. He became a full-time reliever in 2021, and from that point on, posted a 3.12 ERA and 3.63 FIP. However, repeated elbow injuries marred his last three seasons in pinstripes. Loáisiga had surgery to remove a bone spur early in 2023, then missed time with elbow inflammation later that year. In 2024, he made just three appearances before missing the rest of the season due to UCL internal brace surgery. The Yankees signed Loáisiga to a one-year, $5 million deal for the 2025 season, with a $5 million club option for 2026. He returned in May 2025, but went on the IL with back tightness in August, and then suffered a season-ending flexor strain during a rehab assignment. The lesson? A major league elbow is a terrifying place to be. From 2023 to 2025, Loáisiga made just 50 appearances, his average fastball velocity dropped by 1.3 mph, and although he ran a 3.51 ERA, he also ran a 5.13 FIP and put up -0.4 WAR. The Yankees declined his 2026 option. The Diamondbacks took a chance on Loáisiga, signing him to a minor league deal this past January. He made the Opening Day roster and gained back most of the velo he’d lost, averaging 97.9 mph on his sinker. Most importantly, he stayed healthy all year. He made a career-high 67 appearances, running a 2.41 ERA and 2.88 ERA, both of which were his best marks since his breakout 2021 season. He and the Diamondbacks also seemed to make some adjustments. Loáisiga’s fastball velocity rose by just under a tick, which was likely the result of being healthier, but he also added nearly four ticks to both his cutter and his curveball, which seems like a more intentional decision as he tried to make them play better off his heater. Loáisiga is a sinkerballer who gets his outs on the ground rather than by missing bats. In previous seasons, he threw the sinker as much at 70% of the time, but in 2026, he dialed it back to 35%, increasing his changeup rate, working in the cutter more often, and against lefties, bringing back the four-seamer that he’d never used even 6% of the time since he effectively ditched it in 2021. After spending much of his career as a essentially three-pitch pitcher, Loáisaga utilized the five-pitch mix to keep hitters off balance. He continued racking up chases and ran the second-lowest walk rate of his career. The four-seamer was Loáisiga’s second-best pitch, allowing a wOBA of just .184. Despite throwing the pitch more often, among pitchers with at least 50 innings pitched, Loáisiga ran the 12th-highest groundball rate, 27th-lowest hard-hit rate, and 12th-lowest barrel rate in baseball. That approach surely got better results in spacious Chase Field than it will in Yankee Stadium, but those numbers should play anywhere. Still, Loáisiga’s sinker and changeup are the fun pitches. Coming from an arm slot that’s a bit higher than average, the nearly pure horizontal movement he gets on them can be jarring. In 2026, he threw those two pitches 62% of the time, leading with the sinker against righties and the change against lefties. Loáisiga’s problem was never really about his performance, and after a full, healthy season in which he looked like himself, the Yankees clearly regretted the decision to decline his option. It probably didn’t help that Hill, whose 2026 option they did pick up, made 67 appearances of his own, but with a 4.60 ERA and 5.93 FIP. His -1.1 WAR was the third-worst mark of any pitcher, regardless of role. The Yankees re-signed the 36-year-old Hill for one year and $2.25 million, with a $2.5 million club option for 2028, and despite his 2026 numbers, it’s not absurd to want another crack at the left-hander. From 2024 to 2025, he ran a combined 3.22 ERA, and his disastrous 2026 season was one of the weirdest you’ll ever see. Hill ran the highest groundball rate in baseball at an absurd 68.8%, but nearly 31% of his fly balls left the park. That’s the second-highest mark since Sports Info Solutions started tracking these things in 2002. To be clear, the 29 fly balls that Hill allowed were absolutely crushed. He allowed a 55% hard-hit rate on them, a mark that put him in the 96th percentile among pitchers with at least 29 fly balls. The thing is, Hill’s fly balls have always tended to get crushed, because the way he pitches, any fly ball is a mistake. Even so, the only time his HR/FB had exceeded 20% before this year was in the short 2020 season. There’s just no way that he could be that homer-prone again. As a side-arm groundball machine, Hill is never going to impress our FIP-based version of WAR — Baseball-Reference’s RA9-based rWAR generously had him at 0.0 in 2026 — but it’s not likely to think he’s one of the worst pitchers in baseball again either. As I mentioned at the top, the Yankees had the second-best bullpen in baseball by ERA this season. The returning Bednar was the second-ranked reliever on our Top 50 Free Agents, and Loáisaga ranked third. Brent Headrick was excellent this year, and he’ll be back too. Kervin Castro was borderline unhittable both in the minors and during a brief stint in the majors. If Fernando Cruz doesn’t need surgery to repair a partially-torn UCL (and at this point, you’d think we probably would have heard about it if he were getting the surgery), then we’re already more than halfway to a great bullpen. The Yankees also have so much starting pitching firepower that they’re sure to shift some capable starters to relief; RosterResource currently projects Ryan Weathers and Clarke Schmidt in the ‘pen. And we haven’t even talked about major-league ready arms like Carlos Lagrange and Elmer Rodríguez. This already looks like a strong group, and bringing back Loáisaga and Hill also keeps it stylistically consistent. The Yankees bullpen has a 47.5% groundball rate this decade, the highest mark in baseball. Over the past four seasons, their infielders have combined for a fielding run value of 53, which ranks sixth in baseball. That doesn’t happen by accident, and it seems safe to assume that we can pencil them in for another heaping helping of groundballs in the 2027 season, provided there is a 2027 season.

Original Source

Read the full article at Blogs →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.