‘The Rookie’ Season 9 Has One Major Obstacle It Still Needs To Overcome

‘The Rookie’ Season 9 Has One Major Obstacle It Still Needs To Overcome

Published Nov 20, 2026, 8:09 PM EST Jeffrey is a freelance features writer at Collider. He is an MPA-accredited entertainment journalist and a Tomatometer-approved critic based in the LA area. He graduated from the University of Texas at Austin with a Bachelor of Science in Radio, TV, & Film and a Bachelor of Arts in Theater. Over its last eight seasons, The Rookie has depicted many entertaining and enjoyable recurring villains, some better than others. However, none have come close to the best villain in the show's history: the deranged serial killer Rosalind Dyer. Expertly portrayed by the late, great Annie Wersching, Dyer might be gone, but she leaves an undeniable legacy that still hasn't been beat as The Rookie gears up for its return with Season 9. Rosalind Dyer Played an Important Role Across Multiple Seasons Rosalind Dyer makes her impactful debut in the Season 2 episode, "The Dark Side," where she first meets John Nolan (Nathan Fillion) and other members of the Mid-Wilshire Division. After making a deal with the district attorney, Dyer agrees to reveal the burial sites of her victims whose bodies were never recovered. That sets off a chain of events, exposing another killer following in her footsteps. The killer is later revealed to be Caleb Wright (Michael Cassidy), Rosalind’s protégé and acolyte. Caleb later drugs and kidnaps Lucy Chen (Melissa O'Neil), burying her alive before she's eventually found and saved by Tim Bradford (Eric Winter) in "Day of Death." Interestingly, it's Rosalind who first hints at the corrupt nature of Nolan's then-friend and mentor Nick Armstrong (Harold Perrineau). Collider Exclusive · 8 Questions · 2 Minutes Which The Rookie Character Are You? Nolan · Chen · Bradford · Lopez Answer eight quick questions and we will tell you which one you are. Eight seasons in, the Mid-Wilshire shift has turned into one of the best ensembles on network television, and these four are the ones everybody argues about. 🚔John Nolan(Nathan Fillion) 🎭Lucy Chen(Melissa O'Neil) 🏅Tim Bradford(Eric Winter) 🕵Angela Lopez(Alyssa Diaz) FIND YOUR CHARACTER → 01 Why would you join up in the first place? Pick the one that sounds most like you. AA complete change of career. BTo be the best at something. CBecause the job needs doing properly. DTo work the cases that matter. NEXT QUESTION → 02 How would your friends describe you? Be honest. AOptimistic and a bit too nice. BDriven and very capable. CStrict, and softer than I look. DBlunt and completely reliable. NEXT QUESTION → 03 What would you be like as a training officer? One answer only. AEncouraging, possibly too encouraging. BI remember what it felt like. CHard on you, and for a reason. DStraight to the point. NEXT QUESTION → 04 How do you handle authority? Pick the closest answer. AI ask a lot of questions. BI work with it until I outrank it. CI am the authority. DI say my piece, then do the job. NEXT QUESTION → 05 Pick a shift. No wrong answers here. ADays, with a proper lunch. BWhatever gets me the most experience. CEarly. I will be there first. DWhatever gets the case closed. NEXT QUESTION → 06 What is your relationship with the rules? Pick the closest answer. AThere is usually a kinder way. BLearn them, then use them. CThe rules are there for a reason. DI bend them when people need it. NEXT QUESTION → 07 How do you handle a bad day at work? Think about the last one. ATalk it through with somebody. BGo again tomorrow, better. CTrain until it goes away. DGo home to my family. NEXT QUESTION → 08 What do you want out of the job? Last one. This is the one that decides it. ATo prove it is never too late. BTo go as far as I possibly can. CTo make everybody around me better. DTo get the right result. REVEAL MY CHARACTER → Roll Call, Mid-Wilshire You Are…The Rookie started as a show about a man starting over at forty-five and turned into a proper ensemble drama somewhere around season three. Here is which of them you are, and the case for yours being the best of the four. John NolanYou started late and you are not embarrassed about it. Nolan walks into the academy at forty-five surrounded by people half his age, and the show is honest that this is both his biggest disadvantage and the only reason he is any good at the job. You are relentlessly decent, and people keep underestimating how far that gets you. The series was inspired by William Norcross, who really did join the LAPD in his forties. Nathan Fillion has played him for eight seasons and the show has outlasted most of what ABC launched alongside it. Your flaw is wanting to solve the human problem when somebody just needs you to do the police work. Lucy ChenYou are better at this than people expect and you intend to keep proving it. Chen goes from rookie to the best undercover officer in the division, which works because she is genuinely good at becoming somebody else and genuinely bad at pretending she does not care. You are ambitious in a way that lifts the people around you rather than stepping over them. Her undercover episodes are the ones the fandom rewatches, and the show knows it. Chenford has carried more internet discourse than any other relationship on network television this decade. Your risk is taking on the hardest version of every assignment just to see if you can. Tim BradfordYou are hard on people because you have decided that is what caring looks like. Bradford is introduced as the worst training officer in the building and slowly revealed as the one who takes the job most seriously, which are the same fact seen from two angles. You hold a high standard and the people who meet it would follow you anywhere. The shop talk and the tests he sets his rookies became the show's most imitated running bit. Eric Winter has said the character works because the audience is allowed to find him annoying first. Your weakness is that discipline is easier to give people than warmth, and you know which one they need. Angela LopezYou said what you wanted and then you went and got it. Lopez wanted detective from the first episode, said so out loud, and got there by being better at the work than the people who were quieter about wanting it. You are direct, which some people find abrupt and the rest find enormously restful. She is the character the show most often trusts with the actual detective plotting. Her storyline with Wesley gave the series its best running argument about what the job costs at home. Your flaw is that being right quickly is not the same as bringing everybody with you. ↻ RETAKE THE QUIZ Rosalind was a sociopath who delighted in the suffering of others, as well as an expert manipulator. Rosalind would recruit or brainwash various "acolytes" to commit horrendous acts or murders in her name. During the Season 5 episode, "Double Down," Rosalind proves her extreme cunning and manipulative skills, brainwashing her lawyer into her newest acolyte, aiding in her daring escape from police custody. Rosalind meets her climactic end later in the season, but not through the actions of John Nolan or anyone in the Mid-Wilshire unit. Rosalind Dyer Meets Her End in 'The Choice' Ever since her first appearance, Rosalind developed a sick and twisted fixation for John Nolan. Their dynamic somewhat resembles Batman and The Joker of DC Comics. She became obsessed with Nolan’s righteous nobility and altruistic nature, wanting to transform the boy scout into a stone-cold killer, just like her. She nearly pulls it off in her final appearance in "The Choice," setting up a death trap for Nolan's girlfriend and future wife, Bailey Nune (Jenna Dewan). Rosalind offers Nolan a choice: execute her, or Bailey will die. Ultimately, Nolan refuses Rosalind's choice, and Bailey is thankfully saved by Nolan's colleagues. Strangely, Rosalind still succeeds in the end despite her failure to push Nolan over the edge. She escaped from prison and evaded capture, only meeting Nolan for one last game through her own machinations. Rosalind voluntarily gave up because she was too famous and knew it was only a matter of time before she would get caught again. Although Nolan refused to kill Rosalind, her accomplice executed her instead. Ultimately, she got what she wanted: a quick execution instead of returning to prison. Rosalind's death endures as one of the series' most shocking and impactful moments across all eight seasons. Was Rosalind Dyer 'Larger than Life?' Image Via ABC Rosalind's death was utterly surprising. Lucy is in total disbelief when she observes Rosalind's dead body, but Tim puts it best when the team looks upon Rosalind's corpse: "She only seemed larger than life." Rosalind, indeed, exuded an undeniable aura and charisma that made her appear as a force of nature, which is part of what made her such a dangerous, formidable, and terrifying character. She played a role in Lucy's kidnapping and the deaths of many innocent lives, and she nearly drove Nolan to compromise his ideals as well. Wersching was always a highly versatile and underrated thespian, but her portrayal of a remorseless serial killer clinched her skills as an actor. Wersching imbued Rosalind with an ominous sense of dread, yet she always radiated confidence and assuredness. Rosalind never looked panicked in any situation, which is another reason she was so frightening: her eerie calmness. Wersching portrayed Rosalind Dyer as if she had literal ice in her veins. It's no coincidence that some of the show's best episodes or storylines involve Rosalind Dyer. The Rookie has depicted other recurring notable villains, such as Monica Stevens (Bridget Regan) and Oscar Hutchinson (Matthew Glave). However, none of them have ever come close to matching Rosalind in her sheer cunning. Additionally, none of the other villains have managed to fill Rosalind's void following the character’s exit. Wersching delivered a memorable performance that will not be forgotten, as her character left an indelible mark on the show's legacy. After so many seasons, The Rookie still hasn't found a worthy replacement for such a compelling character.

Original Source

Read the full article at Collider →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.