‘The media’s love affair with Trump is over’: The Democrats’ victory rewrites the rules for Washington’s press

‘The media’s love affair with Trump is over’: The Democrats’ victory rewrites the rules for Washington’s press

For over a decade, the Washington press has been hooked on a drug. On the black market, it’s known as the “Trump bump.”The U.S. president has long had immediate effects on media audiences. Covering him boosts (or boosted) the relevance of these outlets in the eternal battle for attention. Incessantly talking about Trump is cheap, produced in industrial quantities, and addictive. It also leads to that very particular feeling of remorse that comes with instant gratification.But for some time now, the effect of the Trump bump hasn’t been as powerful as it used to be. Almost two years after Trump’s return to power, his lies, attacks on decorum and eye-rubbing antics have weakened the drawing power of the most unorthodox U.S. president the country has ever had. After the historic Republican defeat in the midterm elections on November 3, the question in the mainstream U.S. press is whether voters — in addition to delivering a blow to the president — wanted to send the message that they’ve had enough of this drug.“The media’s love affair with Trump is over,” says Margaret Sullivan, a journalism professor at Columbia University, in a telephone interview with EL PAÍS. “Even Fox News, his biggest supporter, has reduced its constant coverage of him,” adds Sullivan, the former public editor at The New York Times and the former media columnist at The Washington Post. Sullivan is referring to a drop in viewership acknowledged by Lachlan Murdoch, Rupert Murdoch’s son. The heir to his father’s media empire, he made the comments in a conference call with investors on November 2, the day before the midterm elections. Murdoch attributed the poor ratings for the most-watched U.S. news network to “viewer fatigue.”The comments made by Lachlan Murdoch could mean that (for once) the head of Fox News agrees with Jeff Jarvis, one of the most critical voices in U.S. journalism, on something. “People have been exhausted for too long. [Trump’s] return to the White House may have rekindled some interest in him, but it only revealed the extent of how fed up we are. The withdrawal symptoms have already passed,” explains Jarvis, professor emeritus at the City University of New York (CUNY), in a video call. Attacks on the press have been a constant since Trump returned to power in January 2025. The U.S. president has sued both The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal, and has threatened television networks with the loss of their broadcast licenses in retaliation for what he claims is unfair coverage. He has barred certain news outlets from the White House and, above all, helped push the media landscape to the right with the assistance of allies such as Elon Musk, owner of X; Jeff Bezos, owner of a diminished Washington Post; and Larry Ellison and David Ellison.The administration also approved the merger of Paramount and Skydance, a deal that strengthened the position of the Ellisons, father and son, whose fortune is deeply tied to Hollywood. Larry Ellison, the founder of Oracle, is also a personal friend of Trump.That deal brought the news division of the venerable CBS into the orbit of Donald Trump’s MAGA movement. The network is now overseen by anti-woke journalist Bari Weiss, who has sought to steer it to the right, so far with poor ratings and at the cost of journalistic prestige.Midterms post-mortemsThe fact that Donald Trump chose one of the programs most heavily reshaped by Weiss, 60 Minutes, as the venue for his first post-election post-mortem interview says a great deal about how much things have changed. It was the same program that Trump, then a presidential candidate, declined to appear on during the 2024 campaign.Following the November 3 election, the U.S. president has sat down with the press twice more for in-depth interviews: with the ever-loyal conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt and with sports commentator Stephen A. Smith from ESPN.Also among the Ellisons’ holdings, thanks once again to a merger greenlit by the White House, is CNN, which they acquired last month. The cable news network has been in crisis for years, but despite its shrinking audience, it remains influential in Washington.Before the midterms, CNN’s journalists — who, like those at the more left-leaning MS NOW, enthusiastically reported on the Republican electoral debacle — feared a shift similar to that of CBS News. Now that the U.S. capital has welcomed a new era of Democratic majorities into Congress, the question is whether the Ellisons will be driven by ideological motivations or by what makes the most business sense in a political landscape where the aura of invincibility surrounding Donald Trump and the MAGA movement is no longer what it once was.The decline is evident even among Trump’s most loyal supporters. A Wall Street Journal investigation found in September, using AI to analyze 70,000 hours of MAGA podcasts, that mentions of the president per hour had fallen sharply in recent months, particularly since the start of the war with Iran.For now, CNN’s new owners have indicated that they will retain chief executive Mark Thompson, the widely respected media executive. But, as one CNN employee who requested anonymity noted, that decision may also reflect the fact that Thompson, at 69, is nearing retirement.Fox News is showing tentative signs of distancing itself from Trump — a move Rupert Murdoch already attempted in 2021, after the assault on the U.S. Capitol, before conveniently returning to the MAGA fold. But legacy media — struggling with falling traffic driven by the decline of social media and by the changes artificial intelligence has brought to search engines and online consumption habits — will find it hard to redefine their relationship with a president with whom they remain locked in mutual dependence.Trump hates the press, yet is obsessed with it. The press, meanwhile, has yet to find a formula that reconciles the challenge of covering what many regard as the most mendacious U.S. president in recent history with the obligation to report on what he says because, after all, he is the president of the United States.Neither Sullivan nor Jarvis has much faith that the media in Washington will change its strategy in light of the “blue tsunami” that swept through the polls. “The mainstream press will continue doing what it’s been doing: trying to maintain a neutral stance, trying not to offend anyone too much,” Sullivan affirms. Jarvis goes further: “Media outlets like the Post or the Times [which the professor is a harsh critic of on X, using the hashtag #BrokenTimes] will continue reporting without acknowledging that fascism isn’t just at the doorstep; it’s already inside. Their editors will tell you it’s just an adjective, when it’s actually a noun with a history. They’ll stick with euphemisms and a neutral stance. When you treat both sides equally — but one of them, the right, has gone to the extreme — the result is that the entire discussion shifts toward that side,” he warns. Both experts also agree that Trump’s moves after the defeat — from appointing the radical Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff, to closing ranks around Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth — indicate that the president has no intention of easing his confrontation with those he sees as his enemies. Topping that list are Democrats and the mainstream press, which Trump has spent more than a decade portraying (with apparent success) as the “enemy of the people.” Only 32% of Americans trust the media, according to Gallup, a figure that at least marks a slight improvement on last year, when it hit a low of 28%.Democrats have pledged to use their historic victory and the sweeping majorities they are about to enjoy in both chambers of Congress to take down Miller, remove Hegseth through impeachment proceedings — the first attempt of which failed last week — and investigate alleged corruption involving Trump’s family and administration. They will also have the option of pushing back against the government’s dismantling of public media.In the case of NPR and PBS — whose funding Trump cut by $1.1 billion — it will be difficult. The Democrats need a two-thirds majority in both houses of Congress to override the presidential veto and restore the funding, a majority they do not have.There’s also the case of Voice of America (VoA), the government’s foreign news service. Musk and his Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) targeted the outlet at the beginning of the current legislative session, amid accusations of bias. The dismissal of around 1,000 VoA staffers remains in limbo: these federal employees continue to receive their salaries while awaiting a final resolution to their lawsuit against the Trump administration. One judge after another has ruled in their favor.The latest court to do so was the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. On November 10, it unanimously upheld a lower court’s decision from this past March that deemed the dismissal of these workers to be illegal and ordered VoA Director Michael Abramowitz to be reinstated. Congress could also renew funding for the news service, which was founded in 1942 to combat Nazism.The next episode in this saga unfolded on Wednesday in the Senate, with a vote on the confirmation of Sarah Rogers, Trump’s nominee to lead the dismantling of VOA. Meanwhile, seven of the outlet’s subsidiaries — which broadcast news in languages such as Farsi, Urdu and Ukrainian — have resumed operations, while some employees have been reinstated. The rest are still waiting to decide whether it’s worth returning to the news service, or if they will accept permanent dismissal. Three of these employees spoke with EL PAÍS earlier this month, on the condition of anonymity. One of them noted that everything will depend on whether they’re rehired “to do their job, or to produce propaganda,” the kind of journalism that Trump is most comfortable with.Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition

Original Source

Read the full article at English →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.