The Airport Meltdown Has a Familiar Villain. The Real Story Is Messier.

The Airport Meltdown Has a Familiar Villain. The Real Story Is Messier.

Metropolis We don’t know what caused the FAA ground stop. Why were so many ready to blame it? By Enter your email to receive alerts for this author. Sign in or create an account to better manage your email preferences. Unsubscribe from email alerts Are you sure you want to unsubscribe from email alerts for Nitish Pahwa? Nov 17, 20261:30 PM Mario Tama/Getty Images Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. We still don’t really know what caused this weekend’s air travel ground stop, the longest nationwide flight pause to be called by the federal government since 9/11. But we did get a hint, from Trump administration officials who hastily briefed the country on Friday, that this was a massive technological screwup, the likely fallout of air traffic control updates that overloaded a long-underfunded and -outdated system, thus instigating the communications and radar outages that necessitated this dramatic halt. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin initially claimed not to be “ruling out anything”—including the insinuation, from a reporter, that this may have had something to do with a recently implemented A.I.-powered Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes and Trajectories tool from the Federal Aviation Administration, which was announced as an assistive program for … air traffic controllers. To be clear, everyone involved with SMART has since come to fervently deny that the introduction of new artificial intelligence had anything to do with the exact glitches behind the plane groundings. (Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy is now asking Congress for $50 billion of emergency funds for hardware overhauls.) Remarkably, this didn’t convince a lot of Americans at first. Sure, there’s broad-based distrust of these Cabinet members who have rather unorthodox résumés—a stint on The Real World, a viral threat to fistfight a union boss—but there was a lot of other technological chaos that led up to the FAA’s pretty unprecedented scramble, naturally leading passive observers to wonder whether it was all related. Was it a vicious cyberattack of the type we’ve been seeing in Europe? (Nope.) Or was this linked to the Microsoft outage? (Also nope.) Or to the bank services outage that landed Monday? (Definitely not.) Or to the United Airlines outage that occurred the same evening?? (No, probably not, but what timing!) Most fascinating was that the A.I. blame game in particular did not subside, and still hasn’t. Multiple tech websites spent Friday through Monday publishing explainers in the hope of debunking the A.I. talking point—to little effect, it appears. Just scroll through your social network of choice (yes, even the techie safe space of X) and you’ll see how widely, and intractably, the A.I. narrative has taken hold of a populace that increasingly deploys generative tools in their everyday lives and doesn’t want any of these tools to have unchecked authority on essential tasks like air traffic control. The willingness of suspicious Americans, of all ideologies, to immediately leap to this conclusion is highly indicative of where the zeitgeist stands on the most consequential technology of the decade. They resisted data centers and Flock cameras; they voted for politicians who promised to hold A.I. companies to account; now they’re all but screaming that they cannot, will not, trust any sort of automated government administration. No matter how much Silicon Valley may try to insist otherwise, the techlash is very real. It probably hasn’t helped the case that the SMART system engendered broader suspicion prior to the FAA’s lost weekend. Last month, congressional Democrats sent multiple letters to Trump Cabinet officials requesting that they either audit or temporarily pause SMART’s rollout, citing the lack of transparency around how the program worked and what it was intended to fix. The CEO of the company that built SMART for the government, Air Space Intelligence, has been confronted over the utility of A.I. in a sphere that has for a while been disadvantaged by a shortage of well-trained, highly capable human professionals who can handle the spontaneity and complexity of air traffic management. “I totally understand that there is fear about, like, ‘This is A.I. for air traffic control.’ But it’s not,” the chief executive told NPR last month. “The machine never makes a decision. It’s a human operator, the air traffic manager. And we want them to have the very best technology. We don’t want them to run on 1980s software.” (He’s not wrong that A.I.-advanced predictive software could help traffic controllers better handle our airspace—and he’s also right that it’s no substitute for needed staffing.) Even an eminently reasonable statement like this is no match for the skeptics of an industry that, as critics rightfully point out, is just a bit too cozy with this government and not entirely operating in the public interest. This tendency very much extends to Air Space Intelligence, of which the FAA has been actively pursuing an equity stake. Also worthy of a raised eyebrow: the fact that ASI’s corporate PAC donated to an ultimately successful congressional bid by Sean Duffy’s son-in-law, Michael Alfonso, just months before inking the SMART contract. (No crypto.) Again, ASI may not be directly responsible for the nationwide ground stop, but no matter how you spin it, the FAA’s favorite A.I. startup is not helping an agency that really needs to regain public trust and ensure that its taxpayer-funded mandates are serving the people. But by now, Americans have been primed to believe, time and again, that the government—and especially this government—will always prioritize A.I. over their concerns. There’s a reason the party in power and its tech-world supporters saw such a shellacking in these midterms, even though President Donald Trump himself appears to have taken away no lessons from that drubbing. Unless the government finally gets back to the work of fixing things, instead of just promising more shiny tech gadgets, you can expect that Americans will continue to blame A.I. for their problems, again and again. Airlines Artificial Intelligence Transportation Travel Air Safety

Original Source

Read the full article at Slate →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.