Sonos’ New Voice Assistant Is Fine for Music but Bad at Spelling (and More)

Sonos’ New Voice Assistant Is Fine for Music but Bad at Spelling (and More)

Sonos, like just about every tech company on the planet, wants to see where AI can bring its ecosystem of audio products, and it’s carrying out that exploratory mission in a few ways. One of the biggest testbeds is Sonos 27voice, which is the company’s regular voice assistant, now imbued with more AI. Sonos 27voice is what Alexa+ is to Amazon and Gemini for Home is for Google—it promises to make the Sonos voice assistant experience smarter, more refined, and useful for more things. While it’s not rolled out to the general public, I’ve had the chance to try it at home in early access, and just like those other voice assistants I mentioned, it’s got some quirks. What’s that song? The one with the notes and the music? Sonos is pitching its new AI voice assistant in a few ways. Here’s how it describes the assistant: “Sonos 27voice can start music, move it around your house, group and ungroup speakers, and help manage your library on supported music services. It can also handle non-music related queries such as setting timers, getting the weather forecast, controlling supported smart home products, and answering general knowledge questions.” One of the main differences here between the new Sonos voice assistant and the old one is that Sonos 27voice can understand more context. That means, as Sonos has pointed out, you can query it in a more vague way. Instead of saying, “Hey Sonos, play the Beastie Boys album ‘License to Ill,'” you could say, “Hey Sonos, play that Beastie Boys album with a jet on the album cover.” © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo I tried this out, and it seemed to work well. It even got a bit of a curveball that I threw at it by asking it to play The Strokes’ album with a woman on the cover. That album, “Is This It,” notably had two album covers—one was the profile of a woman, and the other was a map. The map became the predominant cover for retail in the U.S. because the woman was considered to be too explicit. Clearly, Sonos 27voice was aware of both. Another way that Sonos 27voice plans to be a practical upgrade is in grouping speakers and in more specific playback commands, and on that end, 27voice does fairly well. I was able to, for example, tell Sonos 27voice to “play on every speaker except the soundbar,” which is something that I hadn’t been able to do previously. It also felt generally sharper at zeroing in on which speakers I wanted to play from, accurately pinpointing two different play speakers in my apartment. Likewise, I was also able to successfully group and ungroup the Sonos Beam Ultra with the rest of my speakers using my voice, which I hadn’t been able to do before. This probably isn’t something you’re going to be doing all the time, but if it prevents you from having to pull open the app and tap around, it’s definitely an upgrade. How many Rs are in “strawberry”? So there are some practical features I find Sonos 27voice is better at right now. They aren’t really groundbreaking, but they’re nice to have. Those perks, unfortunately, are just part of the picture—there are quite a few pain points, too. One area where I frequently encountered friction is asking Sonos 27voice to recommend songs for a mood, which is something that Sonos says it should theoretically be good at. I kept it simple and asked things like, “I’m working right now; can you play something calm?” While Sonos obliged, playing Kurt Vile (decidedly a calm choice for the most part), it seemed to fail to carry the prompt further. When followed up with, “This is fine, but I prefer something with no lyrics,” the voice assistant said, “I can’t access Spotify right now; you have to re-authorize it in the Sonos app,” which turned out not to be true—the music was still playing, and the Sonos app showed I was still logged in. When I asked the same thing again, Sonos tried to play Henry Mancini’s “The Pink Panther Theme,” but couldn’t get it to start playing—I had to manually pull open the app and press play. Similar attempts at follow-ups went the same way; Sonos 27voice either didn’t understand my specification or just kept playing the first thing it had queued up. The “general knowledge” part of Sonos 27voice was a bit better, but not great. Admittedly, I started with the really hard stuff like, “How many times does the letter ‘r’ appear in the word ‘strawberry‘?” and it was, of course, all kinds of wrong. © James Pero / Gizmodo The first three times I asked, Sonos 27voice just told me that a strawberry is a fruit and that there are no rupees in it, seemingly misunderstanding what I was saying completely, even though I was speaking clearly with no background noise. It was only after specifying that “r” is a letter and that I was referring to the word “strawberry,” not the fruit, that it finally answered me with: “The letter ‘r’ appears two times in the word ‘strawberry.'” The voice assistant did fine with answering questions about the weather (woo-hoo) but couldn’t answer other basic questions about what Sonos’ new voice assistant even does compared to the old one and just told me to go check the Sonos product page. It did manage to handle some time-sensitive queries like when the Buffalo Sabres play next, but it tended to be a bit brief. I asked Sonos 27voice whether I should brine pork when I’m making katsu at home, and it told me that “yes, it will make it more juicy and flavorful,” which is fine, but it didn’t offer up any real knowledge. For comparison, when I ask Gemini for Home the same thing on my Google Home Speaker, it gives me pros and cons and more nuance depending on what I’m looking for. Was Gemini for Home a bit verbose? Yes. But it was also a better answer. A tepid start It’s clear that Sonos is still ironing out some kinks in Sonos 27voice, which makes sense, as the feature is still in early access. Whether or not the company will be able to refine it into a sharper state is anyone’s guess, but the idea makes sense. As rough as Gemini for Home was at first, I’ve found myself taking advantage of its unique abilities more and more since adopting it. It’s better at context, and it can handle complex queries in a way that first-gen voice assistants couldn’t handle. There’s room for that type of sophistication in an audio setup, though it’s not guaranteed that adding AI will automatically better it. For now, Sonos 27voice is a finicky proof of concept of what Sonos could do with an AI injection.

Original Source

Read the full article at Gizmodo →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.