Parks and Rec's Spiritual Sequel Reveals a Dark Truth About Sitcoms and Streaming

Parks and Rec's Spiritual Sequel Reveals a Dark Truth About Sitcoms and Streaming

Published Nov 19, 2026, 12:01 PM EST Not even sitcom genius Mike Schur can make it work in the streaming era Amy Poehler’s new sitcom is a brutal reminder that there will never be another Parks and Rec Image: Peacock Parks and Recreation wouldn’t have succeeded in the streaming era. While the beloved sitcom is now considered one of the best in TV history, its first season is mostly an uneven slog with ill-defined characters and a bizarre romance subplot that ultimately goes nowhere. Back in 2009, NBC was willing to give the show another shot by soft-rebooting it with Adam Scott and Rob Lowe. In the 2020s, Netflix probably would have pulled the plug after six episodes like it was Blockbuster. So when Peacock announced a new comedy series from Parks and Rec creator Mike Schur and its star, Amy Poehler, my initial response was unbridled optimism. If anyone could prove the genre still works, it's the team behind one of the best sitcoms ever, right? Unfortunately, Schur and Poehler had other ideas. Their new eight-episode serialized comedy, Dig, couldn't be more different from Parks and Rec. In fact, the only thing the two shows have in common is that, like Parks and Rec in its first season, Dig is desperately trying to figure itself out — and mostly failing. Image: Peacock Adapted from Kate Myers' 2023 novel Excavations, Dig takes place over the course of one summer at an archaeological site in Greece. An overworked staff that includes Poehler, Geraldine Viswanathan (Thunderbolts, Blockers), and Hugh Laurie (Veep, House) manages a team of horny undergrads who help excavate ancient artifacts under the hot Mediterranean sun. That sounds like a decent enough premise for a Mike Schur workplace comedy, but watching Dig, it's hard to believe this was created by the same guy who made The Good Place and worked on The Office. Dig's biggest sin is simply that it's serialized, not episodic. The charm of settling into a 20-minute story that resolves when the credits roll is gone, replaced by a series of cliffhanger endings designed to keep you clicking "Next Episode" in the Peacock app. To be fair, eight episodes isn't exactly enough to establish a large cast of characters and send them off on a series of self-contained adventures. Then again, FX's Adults pulled it off, so my expectations were high. Image: Peacock It doesn’t help that Dig’s story isn't particularly interesting. The plot revolves around Poehler's character, Elise, a grumpy archeologist who's sick of being second-in-command. (Extremely important side note: Who decided it was a good idea to make Leslie freaking Knope play an unlikable protagonist?!) After her boss Neville (Laurie) refuses to retire yet again at the start of the summer, Elise storms off, only to accidentally discover an ancient statue in one of the old, abandoned dig sites. She decides to keep it a secret and claim the glory for herself. Later, when the statue disappears under suspicious circumstances, Dig transforms into a whodunit​​​​​​​ as Elise and her friends race to recover the artifact before it can disappear into the black market. If the plot I just described sounds more like an action-adventure movie or a TV drama, you're not wrong. Schur and his writers manage to find very little that's particularly funny about the world of archeology. Instead, Dig oscillates between contrived caper and an ensemble comedy where most of the ensemble are poorly defined background actors. That said, there are a few bright spots in this eclectic cast. Image: Peacock Viswanathan is genuinely hilarious as Elise's hot-mess of a friend who's failed at everything in her life and shows up at the dig site seeking a second chance with her ex-boyfriend. The actor brings a chaotic energy to what is otherwise a weirdly buttoned-up comedy​​​​​​​ to the point that I almost wonder if some of her best lines were improvised. Another highlight is Fina Strazza (Paper Girls, Fear Street: Prom Queen) as Patty, an undergrad student with frizzy hair, a bizarre personality, and a tendency to talk about her isolated childhood growing up on a farm. (She's basically Dwight from The Office if he was a cute, awkward young woman instead of a psychotic middle-aged man.) As a diehard Parks fan, I wish I had anything positive to report on what Poehler brings to the table. Dig doesn't have the deep bench of supporting characters that made Parks and Rec so great, but there are a few decent recurring faces. Kayvan Novak (Nandor in What We Do in the Shadows) is charming as the very Greek mayor of the small town where the show takes place, who has a devastating crush on Elise​​​​​​​. Meanwhile, Dropout's Brennan Lee Mulligan has a hilarious guest role as the bumbling fail-son of the rich old man who's been bankrolling the entire dig site. Mulligan's episode in particular, in which the archeologists have to placate an idiotic millionaire in the hopes of getting more funding for their work, feels like a vision of what the show could have been in another timeline where it wasn't bogged down by its serialized drama. Image: Peacock There's a bizarre streak of sadness running through Dig. But unlike the darkly comedic realities of local government bureaucracy that defined Parks and Rec, this story feels grimmer. Everyone in the show realizes to some extent that their life's work is dying. As Elise and her boss Neville repeat over and over, funding is drying up for digs like theirs and the world at large no longer seems to care about ancient Greek pottery. (There are echoes of The Office​​​​​​​ and the existential state of small-town paper sellers in the face of big-box stores and online retailers, but it all feels much less relatable against the sunny backdrop of Greece). I have no idea if this is true and the field of archeology really is in crisis, or if it's something Mike Schur came up with to inject some extra stakes into his story. Either way, I have a feeling that Schur is talking about more than just archeology. Like the archeology field in Dig, the sitcom industry seems to be drying up too. Hollywood is struggling, writers' room jobs are dwindling, and AI is… also bad. There's a nagging sense that the type of entry-level job that gave Schur a pathway to creating shows like Parks and Rec may not exist for much longer. I'm not saying Schur set out to tell a depressing story about the death of his industry, but in a sense that's exactly what happened. And unfortunately, that doesn't exactly make for great TV comedy. All 10 episodes of Dig premiere Nov. 23 on Peacock.

Original Source

Read the full article at Polygon →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.