None of your business, Illinois

None of your business, Illinois

A unanimous federal appeals court panel revived a challenge Wednesday to an Illinois law that makes charities survey their leaders about race, sexual orientation, and gender identity, then post the totals online. The Seventh Circuit ruled only that the challengers have standing to be heard. That’s a procedural win.The state has no compelling reason to catalog the ethnicity or sexual orientation of the people who run or fund private charities. Illinois targets directors and officers rather than donors, but the same First Amendment logic protects both. I’m a husband, a father of three sons, a taxpayer, and a longtime volunteer, and I’d put it in terms Illinois can follow: It’s none of your business.Senate Bill 2930 took effect Jan. 1, 2025. Charities reporting $1 million or more in grants to other charities must collect demographic data from their directors and officers, covering race, ethnicity, gender, gender identity, disability, veteran status, and sexual orientation, and post the totals online for at least three years. Individuals may decline to answer. The sponsor said the goal was to “highlight and elevate leadership diversity, equity and inclusion throughout Illinois.” Alabama tried a version of this in 1958. Its attorney general demanded the NAACP’s membership lists, saying the state wanted to check a corporate registration. The Supreme Court unanimously rejected the demand, after the NAACP showed that exposure had cost members “economic reprisal, loss of employment, threat of physical coercion.”In 2021, the court ruled 6-3 in Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Bonta that California couldn’t demand major-donor lists from charities, because “each governmental demand for disclosure brings with it an additional risk of chill.” The conservative challengers presented evidence of bomb threats, stalking, and violence against their supporters.Illinois will answer that its data is aggregated and nobody has to respond. Fair points, and they distinguish the NAACP’s case. They leave a gap. A director who declines a survey from the board chair has told the board something, and on a small board a single answer can point to a person. The Seventh Circuit noted that when a law tells officers and directors to act, “they typically comply,” and found it unlikely that every officer would decline.Maryland has required large nonprofit groups to report how many board members are women since 2019. That’s a head count. Illinois wants race, sexual orientation, and gender identity. The Justice Department joined the suit on equal protection grounds, and the challengers argue the reporting pressures charities to weigh identity when choosing leaders.I earned my Eagle Scout badge in 1986 and later served as a Scoutmaster. Volunteer recruiting works like this: You take whoever shows up willing to run a campout. In Boy Scouts of America v. Dale, the court ruled 5-4 that New Jersey couldn’t force the Scouts to reinstate an assistant scoutmaster, holding that compelled inclusion of an unwanted leader can violate a group’s freedom of association. I’ve coached for more than a decade and served on a youth rugby club’s board since its inception. Coaches know what a published scoreboard does to behavior.The classic case for disclosure is a line from Louis Brandeis, who wrote that sunlight is said to be “the best of disinfectants.” He wrote it in 1913 about bankers controlling other people’s money. Transparency about money makes sense. I’ve spent three decades in investment management, and conflicts of interest live in the money. A volunteer’s sexual orientation creates none.FORGET TRUMP’S DIPLOMATIC MIRAGE — ABDANAN JUST PROVED IRANIANS WILL DECIDE THEIR OWN FATEThree fixes would do. Illinois should repeal the mandate or make posting voluntary. The district court, now back in charge, should apply the exacting scrutiny the Supreme Court used in Bonta. And if the state wants demographic data, it can fund an anonymous survey itself rather than deputizing every charity board.Edmund Burke called love of “the little platoon we belong to in society” the first principle of public affections. Charities, rugby clubs and Scout troops are those platoons. Gordon Gekko told Bud Fox that information is the most valuable commodity, and Illinois wants to stockpile ours. A free society asks citizens to serve one another and leave their personal lives to themselves. Illinois should drop the survey. If it won’t, the courts should make it.Jay Rogers is a financial professional with more than 30 years of experience in private equity, private credit, hedge funds, and wealth management. He writes about issues in finance, constitutional law, national security, human nature, and public policy.

Original Source

Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.