A summit between US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese leader Xi Jinping is unlikely to produce a new Yalta-style division of the world, former US Ambassador Daniel Fried told Kyiv Post, warning that Moscow is seeking great-power recognition and concessions it has failed to secure on the battlefield. In an exclusive interview ahead of Thursday’s trilateral meeting in Shenzhen, Fried, a former assistant secretary of state for European and Eurasian affairs, was asked whether his earlier warnings about a possible “Yalta 2” scenario were becoming reality.JOIN US ON TELEGRAMFollow our coverage of the war on the @Kyivpost_official. “I have some skepticism that anything material, anything substantial, will come out of it,” Fried said. He argued that Trump and Putin were attracted to the image of major powers gathering to shape the world’s future, but questioned whether Xi shared their ambitions. “Putin absolutely wants the great-power image of the Big Three,” Fried said, noting that Russian state media had promoted that narrative. Unlike the 1945 Yalta Conference, when the Allied powers were approaching victory in World War II, today’s leaders face considerable political and strategic constraints, he argued. Fried also questioned whether Beijing would fully embrace Putin’s preferred diplomatic choreography, saying Xi appeared determined to control the summit’s presentation. Other Topics of Interest As Putin joins Trump and Xi in China, commentators question what the summit can deliver beyond recognition while his prized bridge lies damaged. Putin gets offers, Washington gets nothing Fried argued that Putin had already benefited from Washington’s diplomatic approach, even without securing a formal agreement. “So far, Putin has emerged ahead because of the series of US offers and unilateral concessions to Putin,” he said. Fried criticized the Trump administration for repeatedly improving its proposals to Moscow without receiving meaningful concessions in return. “If you’re Putin, sit back and enjoy the show and wait for more offers,” he said. Nevertheless, Fried stressed that Putin’s gains remained largely symbolic. “Putin has not achieved anything except offers and optics. It is reversible, and I hope it’s reversed.” Asked about a planned one-on-one Trump-Putin meeting, Fried warned that the US president could attempt to offer Moscow Ukrainian territory, including Donbas, as part of a peace settlement. But he questioned whether Trump could deliver on such promises. “Ukraine is not going to take orders from Trump,” Fried said. “The Europeans may not take orders from Trump.” He argued that Washington had weakened its negotiating leverage by reducing military support for Kyiv, making it harder to pressure Ukraine into accepting an unfavorable agreement. China could help end the war but has little incentive Asked whether Beijing could help stop Russia’s invasion, Fried offered a direct assessment. “Yes, they can, but it is unlikely that they will.” He argued that Xi benefits from a prolonged conflict that strains Europe and keeps Washington focused on Ukraine rather than the Western Pacific and Taiwan. A decisive Russian defeat, he suggested, would also undermine Beijing’s strategic interests. “He could help, but it’s probably his calculation that he’s better off just helping Russia because the Americans have exacted no price for his doing so,” Fried said. In his assessment, Washington has failed to impose sufficient costs on China for supporting Moscow, leaving Beijing with little incentive to change course. ‘A gift to Putin’: European security on the negotiating table Fried was particularly critical of US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff for allowing broader European security arrangements to become part of negotiations over Russia’s war against Ukraine. “That to me was both a tactical and a strategic mistake,” he said. The veteran diplomat described the move as “a gift to Putin,” arguing that Moscow had been given an opportunity to renegotiate the very security arrangements it had undermined. He pointed to the Charter of Paris, the NATO-Russia Founding Act and the Helsinki Final Act as foundations of the post-Cold War European security order. “Putin blew that up, and there should be some consequence for his having done so instead of just getting to renegotiate things,” Fried said. Russia, he argued, was seeking not only control over Ukraine but also renewed influence over Central and Eastern Europe. “The Russians want to own Ukraine, and they want Central and Eastern Europe to resume its position as a sort of gray zone, if not under their complete control.” Fried dismissed Moscow’s demands for Ukrainian neutrality and changes to NATO’s military posture. “You had a neutral Ukraine in 2013. You invaded anyway,” he said. He acknowledged that European objections had prompted Kushner to moderate some earlier proposals, but warned that Trump could still endorse arrangements favorable to Moscow. Kyiv pushes back against one-sided diplomacy Asked whether Washington had abandoned the principle of making no decisions about Ukraine without Ukraine, Fried questioned whether Trump had ever fully embraced it. “I don’t think Trump ever accepted that principle,” he said. “He seems too enamored of great-power dealings.” Nevertheless, Fried praised Ukrainian negotiators for navigating their difficult relationship with Washington, pushing back against unacceptable proposals while maintaining cooperation with European allies. He criticized what he described as the fundamental imbalance in US diplomacy. “No pressure on Russia, only offers,” Fried said. “I don’t think those tactics are either appropriate or destined to succeed.” Berlin and Shenzhen risk pulling in opposite directions Fried warned that Thursday’s parallel meetings – the trilateral summit in Shenzhen and the Coalition of the Willing gathering in Berlin – could reflect competing approaches to Ukraine’s future. The European-led coalition, he argued, could provide an interim security framework for Ukraine, backed by Western military assistance and economic support. Ultimately, Fried said, Ukraine’s membership in NATO and the European Union remained the preferred long-term solution. He urged Washington to support the Berlin initiative and reject Moscow’s attempts to veto European security guarantees. “Those security arrangements are going to happen whether Russia likes it or not,” Fried said, describing the message he would advise Trump to deliver to Putin. Instead, he warned, the two summits risk moving in opposite directions. “One is a meeting of nations of the free world to back a country under assault by a dictator, and the other risks becoming some sort of great-power condominium at the expense of other countries.” Fried argued that the US should embrace the Coalition of the Willing as part of a future settlement rather than allow great-power diplomacy to undermine it. Colby’s criticism of Ukraine’s deep strikes ‘indefensible’ Fried also sharply criticized US Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby over his remarks questioning the strategic value of Ukraine’s deep strikes inside Russia. As Kyiv Post reported, Colby criticized the “spectacle of deep strikes designed to incur pain on the Russian population,” arguing that such operations had failed to halt Russian advances or bring the war closer to an end. “I have very little good to say about that,” Fried told Kyiv Post. He contrasted Ukraine’s military determination with Cold War-era frustrations in Washington over allies who were not doing enough to defend themselves. Ukraine, Fried argued, was not asking American troops to fight its war but requesting the equipment needed to defend itself. “To complain about Ukraine’s successful and clever deep strikes against legitimate Russian targets makes no sense,” he said. “What is our problem? That Ukraine is fighting too well?” Fried welcomed the pushback from German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius and British officials, arguing that Ukrainian military successes serve American strategic interests. “Ukraine’s success is in America’s interest,” he said. “I don’t like criticizing a member of my own government, but in this case, those remarks were indefensible.”
No ‘Yalta 2’: Veteran US Diplomat Says Weakened Trump and Putin Can’t Force Bad Deal on Ukraine
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Kyivpost →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.