My Mother-in-Law Is Banning Two Very Important People From Thanksgiving. She Called Them Nobodies!

My Mother-in-Law Is Banning Two Very Important People From Thanksgiving. She Called Them Nobodies!

Care and Feeding They’re family to me. Advice by Enter your email to sign up for Advice. Sign in or create an account to better manage your email preferences. Unsubscribe from email alerts Are you sure you want to unsubscribe from email alerts for Michelle Herman? Being a novelist requires making up problems for your made-up people, then solving them. After writing fiction for decades, I've made up and solved it all. Nov 21, 20268:00 AM Photo illustration by Slate. Photo by Jacob Wackerhausen/Getty Images Plus. Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. Care and Feeding is Slate’s parenting advice column. Have a question for Care and Feeding? Submit it here. Dear Care and Feeding, “Nina,” “Nicole,” and my late sister were inseparable. They lived together, traveled together, and both were there when my sister died. Neither of them has anything in the way of family, so every holiday, for years, they joined us—until now, as my mother has downsized to a retirement village. We live near my in-laws, and I asked if my mom, Nina, and Nicole could come over for Thanksgiving. I offered to pay the costs associated with feeding three additional people, but was told my mother was the only one who was welcome. Nina and Nicole, my mother-in-law said, were “nobodies.” This shook me, as she is always talking about what a good Christian she is. Now my husband and I are arguing. I want to have Thanksgiving at our place with my family, then make a brief appearance at my in-laws’ home. He says that is deliberately rude to his mother and that Nina and Nicole can “deal with” missing one holiday. I asked if he would say that if they were my cousins, and he said that would be different—then they would be family. But Nina and Nicole are basically family to my mom and me. For 20 years, they’ve spent every holiday with us. It is like getting a piece of my sister back. My husband later apologized, but he still insists that he can’t demand that his mom include other guests. I am ready to just send him alone to his mother’s and celebrate separately at home with Nina, Nicole, and my mother. Help! —Friends Are Family Dear Friends, It does seem churlish of your mother-in-law to refuse your request, if you made it far enough in advance and you drew her a complete picture of Nina and Nicole’s role in your family’s life. (And it’s downright ugly that she referred to them as “nobodies.”) Still, it’s her party: If she is one of those people (there are many!) who has a strict definition of what “family” is, and feels strongly that holidays like Thanksgiving are for relatives by blood or marriage only, she is entitled to issue invitations only to those who pass that test. The bad news is that your husband is her son, and it seems he agrees with her. Your question about cousins settled that. And while I believe it’s true that he shouldn’t demand that his mom invite people to her house whom she has made it clear she does not want to include, I suspect that, deep (or maybe not even that deep) down, he thinks she’s right. Because he wouldn’t have to “demand” that she include these two women who have always been included in your mother’s celebrations. He could simply ask. He would do that if he wanted to; he doesn’t. I’m sorry that Thanksgiving has turned into a battleground for you two. Alas, it’s all too common. I wouldn’t want to go to your mother-in-law’s for Thanksgiving either. If I were you, I would definitely host my own Thanksgiving at my own home—and invite everyone, including your in-laws. Your mother-in-law will decline and also be angry about the competing celebration. Consider whether you’re prepared to deal with the fallout from that. As to your husband: Don’t send him to his mother’s. Let him choose. And make sure he knows that this is not only about this Thanksgiving. It’s about what family means to each of you, and how you want to live your lives beyond this moment. It’s a pity you two didn’t give yourselves the chance to work this out before now. But better now than never. —Michelle More Advice From Slate Our 12-year-old plays video games, with Fortnite taking about 80 percent of his gaming time (which we limit). He gets so enraged at the game, foot-stomping and screaming, and is generally unpleasant for five to 10 minutes after each session. I get the frustration, but in our small house his feelings take up considerable energy. Is this typical? Advice Family

Original Source

Read the full article at Slate →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.