Representative Image (AI-generated)Two Missouri homeowners who had paid off a property loan found themselves unable to complete a $272,500 home sale after the original sellers refused to release a lien on the property. The sellers claimed that money was still owed, but the homeowners maintained that they had completed all payments years earlier. The dispute eventually led to a lawsuit over the failed sale and the sellers' refusal to clear the property's title.On November 17, 2026, the Missouri Court of Appeals upheld a judgment awarding the homeowners $47,500 for tortious interference with a real estate contract. In its opinion in Joseph C Barber and Brenda L Barber v. Kimberly R Weger, the court also affirmed the finding that the $37,325 loan had been fully repaid. The court also remanded the case for the trial court to determine the additional reasonable attorney's fees Kimberly Weger must pay for work after the original judgment and during the appeal, according to the opinion available on Justia.How the property loan and sale dispute beganJoseph and Brenda Barber purchased a property at 4905 West Route F in Clark, Missouri, from Kimberly Weger and her husband, Aubrey, in 2006. They financed part of the purchase through a $37,325 promissory note and signed a deed of trust in favour of the sellers as security for the loan. The deed of trust was recorded in Boone County on November 22, 2006.Under the agreement, the couple had to make monthly payments of $450 from December 2006 through November 2015. A late fee of $25 applied when a payment was not made before the 15th of the month. Brenda later testified that they made the required payments and settled the loan with their final payment in November 2015.In April 2022, the Barbers agreed to sell the property for $272,500, with closing scheduled for May 13. Before the transaction could be completed, they discovered that the deed of trust remained recorded against the property. The Wegers refused to release it, claiming that several payments, particularly those due in 2014 and 2015, had not been received.The sellers also declined to provide a payoff amount. Aubrey told Brenda that she could not sell the property because she did not own it and said he would stop the sale because he wanted the property back. Their son, Ashtin, also told Brenda that he would make sure people knew the couple could not sell it.Why the original sale fell throughThe Barbers hired an attorney, who sent a formal demand in May 2022 asking the Wegers to release the deed of trust and provide the required documentation. The letter included available payment records and money to cover the recording costs. The Barbers also offered to place any disputed balance in escrow so the sale could proceed, but the Wegers continued to refuse to provide a payoff figure or release the lien.The buyers were unwilling to complete the purchase while the deed of trust remained on the property. The Barbers extended the closing date three times and reduced the agreed price to $225,000, but the original sale still failed.They later filed a lawsuit against Kimberly, Aubrey and Ashtin. The claims included a violation of Missouri's law requiring the release of a deed of trust after a secured debt has been paid, as well as tortious interference with a real estate contract. In June 2024, the trial court ordered the deed of trust released. The Barbers subsequently sold the property for $225,000 on September 16, 2024.What the courts decidedDuring the trial, Brenda testified that the loan had been fully paid, supported by bank records for payments made in 2014 and 2015. Kimberly presented records suggesting that only 67 of the 107 required payments had been made. However, some payments shown in the Barbers' bank records were missing from her records.The trial court accepted Brenda's account and ruled in May 2025 that the Wegers had violated the state law governing the release of deeds of trust. It awarded the Barbers $3,732.50 in statutory damages, $28,065.77 in attorney's fees and court costs. It separately awarded them $47,500 for tortious interference with the property sale, while finding in favour of Ashtin on that claim.Kimberly appealed, arguing that the evidence did not establish that the loan was fully paid or that her refusal to release the deed was unjustified. The Court of Appeals rejected both arguments. It found that the trial court was entitled to rely on Brenda's testimony and the supporting bank records. The judges also noted that the sellers had refused to provide a payoff amount despite repeated requests. Evidence showed that their refusal was driven by a desire to prevent the sale and regain an interest in the property, rather than a legitimate claim to unpaid money.The appeals court affirmed the judgment, including the $47,500 award for interference. It also granted the Barbers' request for additional attorney's fees and sent the matter back to the trial court to determine the reasonable amount owed for post-judgment and appellate legal work.
Missouri couple's $272,500 sale blocked by paid-off lien; court upholds $47,500
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Timesofindia →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.