War Stories By Enter your email to receive alerts for this author. Sign in or create an account to better manage your email preferences. Unsubscribe from email alerts Are you sure you want to unsubscribe from email alerts for Fred Kaplan? Nov 19, 20261:17 PM Vyacheslav Prokofyev/Pool/AFP via Getty Images Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. As expected, nothing important happened at Thursday’s “historic” summit involving Presidents Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and Xi Jinping—the first time the leaders of the United States, Russia, and China have jointly met. But don’t tell that to Trump. He thinks the summit had enormous significance. Shortly after his arrival in Shenzhen, China, where Xi took the unusual step of meeting him at the airport with great fanfare, a reporter asked him what he thought the “headline” coming out of the summit would be. “I think I’ve already gotten that headline. Because the relationship that I have with China is a great one,” Trump replied. He added that Xi “has never gone to the airport to meet somebody. … That’s a big win for us.” And there you have it. Trump is big on theatrics. The problem is that he often mistakes theatrics for reality. Xi’s greeting on the runway—whether a sign of genuine respect or an appeal to Trump’s ego—was a nice gesture. But it forecast nothing about the issues that summitry is meant to address and resolve. Trump doesn’t understand that. To him, everything is about Donald J. Trump—who seems to like him, who doesn’t. All the other world leaders recognize this, and as a result, he’s an easy mark for anyone who wants something from him. The three leaders met at the end of the conference of ASEAN, the 11-member Association of Southeast Asian Nations. Serious big-power summits go on for many hours, sometimes days. The Trump-Putin-Xi summit lasted an hour and a half. That’s hardly enough time to make opening statements and hear the translations. In a post-summit statement, they announced agreement on four items: reform of the United Nations (no specifics), an increase in oil production (not exactly forward-thinking), further dialogue on reducing nuclear risk (no requirement to reduce their own nuclear arsenals), and sovereign immunity from international courts (an expression of shared contempt for international law). In other words, there was no commitment to take action, or even to hold systematic talks, on anything. Putin and Xi got something out of the event. Xi played host to an international conference, then got to sit as an equal with the world’s two largest nuclear powers. By simply attending the conference, Putin ended his pariah status, which has plagued him since he invaded Ukraine nearly five years ago, and then got to sit as an equal with the world’s two largest economic powers. Trump, on the other hand, got nothing. He made the rookie’s mistake—after being president for six years—of setting high expectations in advance, hoping to discuss nuclear arms reduction and an end to the wars in Ukraine and Iran. Putin and Xi had no interest in any of those subjects. Xi wants to continue building up his nuclear weapons until China’s arsenal is as large as those of the U.S. and Russia. Putin announced that, after Ukraine’s bombing of the Crimea bridge, he is halting all negotiations about that war (no big deal, as those negotiations have never been serious). Xi didn’t want to talk about Ukraine either, as he has long been providing Russia with weapons technology and buying its oil. Nor did Xi or Putin want to talk about the Iran war, as one or the other or both have been helping Tehran with trade, weapons, and intelligence. Trump came to the summit with no outlined agenda and—after the failure of his massive bombing campaign in Iran and the crushing defeat of his party in the midterm elections—very little leverage. He was reduced to addressing each of the two dictators as “my friend,” even saying, “It’s an honor to be with Vladimir” and, to Xi, “it’s an honor to be with you, Mr. President.” Trump no doubt boarded the plane back to Washington beaming and pumped up, his status as world leader reaffirmed by his mere presence at the Big Three’s table, free to ignore—even to dismiss with a sneer—his recent repudiation in a democratic election, an imposition that his good friends Vladimir and Xi don’t need to put up with. Many presidents in Trump’s position—lame ducks whose party just lost control of Congress—have turned their focus toward foreign policy, where they enjoy more leeway. But at least most of them had productive goals in mind. Trump hasn’t articulated any, and as long as he has Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff as his global emissaries, he’s not likely to accomplish any, even if he did. How will he do the reboot? Will he flex his muscles and resume the bombing of Iran, realizing that he can’t cajole the Islamic Republic’s leaders to sign an agreement to his liking? Will he abandon Kyiv with an even more emphatic shrug, the better to help his friend Vladimir restore his sphere of influence? (Addressing the fear of Europeans that the trilateral summit might replicate the 1945 Yalta treaty, which divided up the continent for the subsequent Cold War, Putin said, “As far as a new Yalta goes, what was so bad about Yalta?”) Will he do the same for his friend Xi by hardening his indifference toward the fate of Taiwan? The Yalta treaty formalized the positions of the Allied armies—the U.S., Britain, and Russia—at the end of World War II. Putin and Xi approached this meeting as another opportunity to reap, and to some extent share, the benefits of a world where American influence has declined. Trump is accelerating that decline. His fawning in Shenzhen further dramatized the trend, and, what’s worse, he clearly doesn’t see what’s going on. China Donald Trump Foreign Policy Iran Russia Vladimir Putin War Ukraine Xi Jinping
Trump Made a Rookie Mistake at His “Historic” Summit With Putin and Xi
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Slate →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.