Lawless Politicians Ban ICE Then Complain When It Moves Criminal Aliens Elsewhere

Lawless Politicians Ban ICE Then Complain When It Moves Criminal Aliens Elsewhere

Last week, The New York Times reported that Immigration and Customs Enforcement has stopped listing detainees with final orders of removal on its public online locator. The activists had a word ready for it. “Disappeared.” By the next day it was everywhere. I spent my career in immigration enforcement and retired as a deputy field office director in New York. Nobody has disappeared. ICE knows where every person in its custody is, and every detainee can pick up a phone and call a family member or a lawyer. The people taken off the public site are not waiting on a hearing. They already have final orders of removal. Their cases are over. That locator was never the law, either. ICE put it online in 2010 as a courtesy. No statute requires it. A courtesy only lasts as long as nobody turns it into a weapon against the officers doing the job. But the locator isn’t the real story. The real story is the politicians who spent years building this chaos and now want ICE to take the blame for it. Start with the transfers. Every time a detainee is moved from New Jersey or Maryland to Louisiana, somebody holds a press conference about people shipped a thousand miles from home. Ask why. In 2021, Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker signed a law forcing county jails to end their contracts with ICE. By early 2022, ICE had moved the last detainees held in Illinois to jails in other states. In 2021, Maryland’s legislature overrode a veto to push ICE out of local jails. Maryland now has no long-term immigration detention center, and a Capital News Service analysis of ICE’s own records found that three in four people ICE detained after arrests in Maryland were held in Texas, Louisiana, or Mississippi. New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy signed his own ban on immigration detention contracts in 2021. A federal appeals court struck it down last year. ICE holds people where it has beds. Throw ICE out of your jails and the detainees don’t stay in your state. They go where there’s space. Then the same officials who threw ICE out stand at a podium and complain about the flights. Then there’s the language. Since January 2025, “arrested” has been swapped out for “kidnapped,” “abducted,” and now “disappeared.” Those words are picked on purpose. Look at Los Angeles. In June 2025, a woman claimed masked men grabbed her and pressured her to sign removal papers. Activists held a press conference. Her daughter started a GoFundMe. Mayor Karen Bass pushed the story on social media. It was staged. Last month the woman pleaded guilty to a federal conspiracy charge, and prosecutors said she did it for sympathy and donations. First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli said the “kidnapping” rhetoric was being “recklessly peddled by politicians.” He was right. Look at Newark, New Jersey. Martin Soto’s wife told the country that ICE “kidnapped” her husband on a diaper run. The Kearny police report says local police arrested him for assault on Feb. 1, and it lists the victim as “Ms. Soto.” ICE took custody of him at the county jail the next day. That story helped fuel a purported hunger strike that the Department of Homeland Security says did not occur, and it drew crowds to the gates of Delaney Hall. What followed was chaos outside a federal detention facility. Barricades built from traffic cones and trash cans. People trying to block ICE vehicles. An Associated Press photographer hit in the knee by a wooden beam. In all, more than 80 people were arrested. Gov. Mikie Sherrill finally sent in the state police, and her stated reason said everything. She did not want to give ICE a “pretext to expand operations” in New Jersey. Troopers moved in, made arrests, and cleared the area. Then the left turned on her. Activists called her a “one term governor.” Within days the state police handed the scene to Newark, and Mayor Ras Baraka lifted the curfew and began pulling his own officers back, saying it was not his police department’s job “to secure a private facility.” That same week, he said the city would expand its lawsuit and seek to close Delaney Hall. That isn’t leadership. That’s acting. You don’t see crowds blocking the gates night after night outside detention centers in Louisiana or Texas. You see it in Newark, in Portland, and in Broadview outside Chicago. Every one of those is in a sanctuary state, where elected officials have spent years telling the public that ICE is the enemy. That’s not a coincidence. Democrat lawmakers make a habit of “oversight” visits to these facilities. I have yet to see one end with any recommendation other than shutting the place down or abolishing ICE. “ICE is hiding people” is just the newest talking point in the same campaign. And the Times played its part. Writing about a woman with a 2013 final order of removal, the paper told its readers, “Her disappearance was no accident.” She called her family within days. ICE knew where she was the whole time. When I worked in New York, I had to answer the Times’ coverage of our agency more than once. The slant hasn’t changed. The officers I served with enforce laws that Congress wrote. When a governor, a mayor, or a newspaper calls a lawful arrest a kidnapping, they are telling people those officers are criminals and that stopping them is justified. That is how officers get hurt. If these leaders want detainees held closer to home, they can let ICE back into their jails. If they want order outside Delaney Hall, they can enforce the law there themselves. ICE didn’t create this mess. The politicians did. It’s time they owned it. Scott Mechkowski is a retired deputy field office director for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Enforcement and Removal Operations, in the New York Field Office, with more than 24 years in federal immigration enforcement and over three decades of military service. He is a visiting fellow for deportation studies at the Oversight Project Bill Essayliborder crisisCaliforniaCongressDelaney HallDeportationsICEillegal aliensIllegal ImmigrationImmigration and Customs EnforcementJ.B. PritzkerKaren BassMartin SotoMarylandmass deportationsMikie SherrillNew JerseyNew York TimesPhil MurphyRas Baraka

Original Source

Read the full article at Thefederalist →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.