Pay Dirt Photo illustration by Slate. Photo by Getty Images Plus. Our advice columnists have heard it all over the years—so we’re diving into the Pay Dirt archives to share classic letters with our readers. Submit your own questions about money here. (It’s anonymous!) Dear Pay Dirt, I’ll be getting married in about a year and a half. I have tried to be a good steward of my money, and I’m doing OK. I have paid off half of my mortgage. I own the house myself and purchased it before I met my fiancée. My car is paid off. I have no credit card debt, and I have a decent 401(k) and an emergency account of $150,000. My fiancée, meanwhile, has no savings and a smaller 401(k). She has enjoyed her early years with travel and going out. She had a credit card debt of about $20,000 that I paid off so she could avoid the interest. She has paid that back in the five years we have been together. She now has a part-time job, in addition to a good full-time job, to save for the impending wedding of her dreams which will cost about $65,000. We are splitting that in half, even though I would prefer a much smaller wedding. I brought up the subject of a prenuptial when we talked about marriage and she understood. Now she is not interested in doing that anymore. I’m a little fearful because I have sacrificed a lot to get what I have and I’m worried that if things don’t work out, I will lose my house. Is there anything I can do before marriage to protect my assets? —Nervous in the Northeast Dear Nervous, Your fiancée started making good financial decisions once you met. She’s paid off her debt to you (and accepted your help to avoid compound interest). She is willing to work a second job for her dream wedding. Despite all these financial decisions involving you (you were her lender, and you are the one she is getting married to), you still seem to think of all of these decisions as “hers.” You view each of your two spheres of finances as non-overlapping entities. But you’ll have to start making money decisions together. You don’t get to approach this marriage with a “hers” and “mine” mentality. Even with separate finances, my spouse and I make daily collaborative decisions that affect one another’s balance sheet: where we choose to live, how we divide household expenses, which health insurance is a better deal, and tax considerations as a married filing jointly couple. It varies by state, but if you don’t want your marital home to become marital property, you’ll generally need to get a legal document that sets it aside. Even with such a document, there are still cases where your assets could be at risk for your wife’s debt. There’s no secret magical sauce to protect your assets except a prenup. (Okay, maybe several secret accounts in the Cayman Islands.) Prenuptial agreements exist to clearly divide assets in the case of a marriage dissolving. But not all prenups are iron-clad—a judge could decide that your wife is entitled to a share of your home in divorce (if she’s paying fairly into the mortgage, for example). It could be worth starting a charm offensive if your fiancée is backtracking. Spell out why prenup can be good for both of you and healthy for your relationship. Putting together a prenup will help you discuss and clarify your financial goals in a structured way. Each of you can get legal help to ensure your interests are represented. Since you’re an anxious and meticulous person with money, hopefully, she will see the prenup as a way to calm you and start out on even footing. You agreed to a more expensive wedding for her; she can agree to have a series of conversations about money. If your fiancée is unwilling to get a prenup or do premarital financial counseling, you must consider whether you’re a good match long-term. If you’re constantly stressed about the worst-case scenario and your nest egg, and she’s regularly splurging on a “dream” purchase, will you be happy together? Research has found that money arguments are the second leading cause of divorce. As Amy March from Little Women said in the 2021 film: “Don’t sit there and tell me that marriage isn’t an economic proposition, because it is.” —Lillian Karabaic From: My Fiancée Refuses To Sign On To My One Money Request. (March 28th, 2023). Please keep questions short (<150 words), and don’t submit the same question to multiple columns. We are unable to edit or remove questions after publication. Use pseudonyms to maintain anonymity. Your submission may be used in other Slate advice columns and may be edited for publication. Dear Pay Dirt, I own a one-bedroom condo. My ex and I were on the outs when she got pregnant. There was a chance it could be mine so I didn’t force her to move out. When her son was born, it was pretty obvious to anyone with eyes that he wasn’t mine. The paternity test proved that as well. The other guy left the state and refuses to take my ex’s calls. My ex and I are still living together because I didn’t want to force her out to the streets or back to her abusive family. My ex is still on maternity leave so she and the baby are in the condo all the time. I have been staying with friends on and off, but everyone is getting tired of the situation. My ex refuses to discuss the future. She either ignores me or brushes off the subject. She made a few attempts to reconcile with me that I immediately shut down. She makes a good enough living, but the reality is it is going to be a struggle for her as a single mother. I am willing to let her stay in the condo for year until she gets back on her feet and saves some money. My work has offered me a few temporary projects that require me to be out of the country for several months. But that requires a hard conversation or two and a written lease. I know my ex is stressed out. She just had a baby. Whatever our differences, I do care about her well-being and the baby. We need to have this conversation, but I don’t know how without coming across as a complete bully. Can you help? —Need a Plan Dear Need a Plan, You’re already doing a lot for your ex that’s above and beyond the call of duty. It’s understandable that you want to live in your own condo by yourself. A year is a more than reasonable time for her to find another place to live, and if she saves that money, she should be able to afford a rental. You are right that it will be a struggle for her as a single mother—the early years are a struggle even for people who have partners—but you are giving her a cushion to plan things out without worrying about housing, which is incredibly generous. Begin the conversation by reassuring her that you care about her and want to try to help, but be firm that you both also need to move on from the relationship and that won’t happen as long as you’re still living together and she’s dependent on you for housing. (Needless to say, if for some reason she’s not clear that the relationship is definitively over, that conversation needs to happen first.) Tell her she can stay for the year to save money, but she will need to find somewhere else to live after that—and give her a specific date. You are under no obligation to help her look for a place or plan, but if you’re inclined to, telling her that might soften the blow. Explain that she’ll need to sign a lease agreement even if she’s not paying rent because she’ll still have the same responsibilities another tenant would have in terms of taking care of the apartment and following any rules you’re bound to as the condo owner. (She’s essentially getting a rent abatement.) If she somehow objects to all of that, you may have to remind her of the worst-case scenario, which is that you can legally evict her. Neither of you wants that to happen, so frame it as a problem you’re going to solve together: You’re giving her an extended period of time to figure out her next steps and while you’re gone, she will explore her options. It’s possible that she’ll still be unhappy with what you’re offering her, but in that case, you’re not the person being unreasonable; she is. —Elizabeth Spiers From: My Ex Seems To Have No Real Plan To Ever Move Out Of My Apartment. (March 30th, 2023). Dear Pay Dirt, My longterm girlfriend and I disagree about whether a $30,000 inheritance left to her by her great-aunt should be “her” money or “our” money. She wants to spend a large part (almost a third!) of it on expensive supplies for her hobby. I think that we should save most of it and use some of it on a vacation since we both find traveling extremely romantic. My argument is: 1) I don’t care about her hobby, but we’ll both enjoy a trip abroad; 2) we’ve lived on only my (admittedly low, since it’s academia) income for over a decade, so according to her own rule about entitlement to “her” windfall, shouldn’t she technically have been entitled to none of my wages all these years? Her argument is: 1) she had to put aside her hobby for many years to raise our children (it’s not a safe art form for young kids to be around) and yearns to return to it; 2) she paid entirely in cash for our $950k house at the beginning of our partnership (though my income pays the property taxes and maintenance costs), therefore she alleges that we haven’t actually been living on solely my income because I’ve been saving on rent all these years.I feel resentful of the double standard about control over finances and hurt that she would rather prioritize her own joy over our shared joy. She feels impatient to reconnect with her hobby and hurt that her contributions to our lifestyle are unseen. How do we reconcile our different viewpoints? How should the money be allocated? Is there something that we’re missing? —I’m About to Glass(Blow) a Fuse Dear I’m About to Glass(Blow) a Fuse, I’m afraid your girlfriend is right; it’s her money, not your shared money. Her great-aunt did not leave it to both of you. I also find it odd that you mention that your girlfriend bought the nearly million dollar house you’re living in entirely in cash as if that were not a significant contribution. I don’t know how many years you’ve been together, but has your (by your own admission low) income totaled up to at least a million dollars over the years? That’s how much your girlfriend has already spent, so it’s not just a matter of the rent you’re not paying; it’s the money you didn’t spend to acquire the house, too. If you’re going to keep score regarding who contributes what, then you need to get the math right. If your girlfriend had not spent all of that cash at the beginning of the relationship, she’d presumably have more than enough money for her hobby right now.Also you know that your girlfriend’s hobby is something she cares deeply about and she sacrificed it to raise your kids. Whether you care about it is irrelevant to begin with, but depriving her of something you know will make her happy while, by the way, spending none of your money strikes me as incredibly selfish—and she will resent you for it if you talk her into it. You might be able to drag her on a trip abroad, but it’ll be anything but romantic. —E.S. From: My Girlfriend Is Inheriting A Bunch Of Money, And Wants To Spend It On Herself. (April 17th, 2023). More Advice From Slate I (a married woman) just set up a single male co-worker and a single female friend of mine on a blind date. He’s a sharp guy who’s traveled the world and knows all about fine foods, wines, classical music, designer labels, etc., and she’s a stunningly beautiful and intelligent artist. I really thought they’d make a great couple. Immediately after their date, my friend thought it had gone well and was very excited. On Monday morning, I asked my co-worker, and he said my friend was attractive and a nice person, but he wouldn’t be asking for a second date. Never miss new Slate Advice columns Get the latest from Prudie and our columnists in your inbox each weekday, plus special bonus letters on Saturdays. Advice Dating and Relationships Family Personal Finance
I Spent My 20s Saving While My Fiancée Spent Hers Living It Up. One Thing Would Make This Fair, But She’s Balking.
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Slate →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.