In a class action, holders of costly horse carriage license medallions say New York City did not sufficiently review the financial impact of the citywide ban on the Central Park horse-drawn carriage tradition.MANHATTAN (CN) — On the same day New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani officially abolished the city’s horse-drawn carriage industry after 150 years, a coalition of transport worker unions and carriage license holders filed a class action Thursday seeking to overturn the ban.Romanch’s Law, drafted after 18-year-old tourist Romanch Mahajan was fatally thrown from a carriage earlier this year, passed the New York City Council last month with a veto-proof 40-7 majority despite months of protests from drivers.The legislation orders all horse-drawn carriage operations to cease on New York City streets by June 1, 2028, with active licenses expiring May 31, 2028, and no new licenses issued. The city will also pledge back carriage medallions from owners, reportedly covering all 68 carriage medallion licenses.“This industry will come to an end, and we have a responsibility to the workers whose livelihoods depend on it,” Mamdani said while signing the law Thursday. “We will work alongside them to ensure they have the financial support and career opportunities they need to build their next chapter.”But the carriage drivers’ unions — Transport Workers Union of America and its principal NYC Local, Transport Workers Union of Greater New York, Local 100 — claim in their class action that the city has not properly examined economic effect of ending the trade, and fear the bill’s buyback program will not pay out fair compensation for the actual market value of the medallions.“Just compensation should be fixed by an independent valuation of each interest taken, which the city never undertook,” the plaintiffs wrote in the 138-page complaint, filed in New York federal court.The license holders claim that prior to enactment of the ban, the city did not estimate the cost of compensating owners, drivers or stables, or obtain an independent valuation of the carriage licenses or other interests the bill extinguishes.Licenses previously sold for as much as $300,000 to $400,000 each before the citywide ban went into effect, the plaintiffs say.The license holders note they have not recouped their steep investments, while also still paying for horse boarding stables, insurance, farrier, veterinary, feed and vendor contracts.The plaintiffs seek to thaw the city’s freeze on the transfer of licenses or sale of carriage horses, so that license transfers can continue under existing law while the pending class action is litigated.Represented in the Southern District of New York by Advocates for Justice attorney Arthur Schwartz, the court challenge to the citywide ban had been anticipated as soon as the City Council voted for it.“You can regulate businesses, you can adopt reasonable measures to prevent abuses,” Schwartz told Courthouse News last month. “But to take away property for no reason that bears any relationship to the welfare of the public? It’s unconstitutional.”Mamdani said Thursday he will direct his administration to commission a feasibility study examining electric carriages and electric pedal-assist bicycles as potential alternatives for use within Central Park, as well as electric carriages along the park’s perimeter.Council Member Lynn Schulman, chair of the committee on health, called the signing of the bill “an important step toward making New York City safer and more humane.”“Horse-drawn carriages have been part of New York City’s history since before cars, but our city has changed drastically,” the Queens Democrat said. “Our streets and parks have become increasingly chaotic and overcrowded, creating a massive safety risk for all.”President Donald Trump, whose namesake Trump Tower skyscraper is a couple blocks south of Central Park, lamented the demise of the industry and called carriage rides “a quintessential New York experience.”“It was a Great Tradition. Another piece of History that’s gone. It will be missed!” Trump wrote on social media in October.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads
Horse carriage industry bucks back against NYC ban
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.