Five European Countries Plan to Deport Migrants to Rwanda

Five European Countries Plan to Deport Migrants to Rwanda

AdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENTGermany, Austria, the Netherlands, Greece and Denmark are seeking to establish a hub for rejected asylum seekers. Here’s what to know about their effort.Ministers from the Five Country Group, which includes Austria, Germany, Denmark, the Netherlands and Greece, after a meeting on immigration and integration in Copenhagen in September.Credit...Liselotte Sabroe/Ritzau Scanpix, via Agence France-Presse — Getty ImagesNov. 16, 2026Updated 11:19 a.m. ETFive European countries announced a plan on Monday that would send rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda, an experiment that comes as governments across the continent toughen their stances on migration.The joint push from Germany, Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands and Greece was pitched as a way to handle migrants who had no right to stay in Europe but who, for one reason or another, could not or would not return to their home countries.The project, which is not yet finalized, shows how European leaders’ stance on migration has hardened since the arrivals of 2015-16, when countries like Germany admitted more than a million asylum seekers. With far-right groups like the Alternative for Germany rising in popularity, centrist leaders have gradually taken a less welcoming stance.“For me, today marks a crucial step toward a new migration system,” Mette Frederiksen, the prime minister of Denmark, said at a news conference on Monday.The pilot project is expected to start on a small scale, with perhaps 100 or 200 deportees. Critics are already worried both about the idea of sending people to a nation to which they have no connection, and about the risk that human rights will not be sufficiently protected in Rwanda.Why Rwanda?The country has a history of courting migration-related deals.Britain developed a plan to send asylum seekers there in 2022, though judges in London ultimately ruled the effort unlawful and it was later abandoned. The United States has recently deported people to Rwanda.ImageThe Hope Hostel in Kigali, Rwanda, was set to house people deported from Britain before that plan was scrapped.Credit...Guillem Sartorio/Agence France-Presse — Getty ImagesThis is not Europe’s first experiment in funneling migrants toward third countries. Italy tried to set up an asylum processing hub in Albania, though that plan has run into legal challenges.The five countries involved in this plan argue that it is different from previous efforts. For one thing, it will focus on migrants who have exhausted their legal avenues for staying in Europe, rather than on migrants who are just starting asylum claims. The European Union recently set out a legal framework for third-country return hubs, and this one will be operated along those lines.But the decision has raised eyebrows.Critics object to the choice of destination.For some, the choice of Rwanda is concerning. The nation often ranks low on human rights measures, especially when it comes to free speech. It has also faced sanctions from the United States and criticism from Europe, which have accused it of supporting a rebel militia in the Democratic Republic of Congo.“Its human rights record is very, very dodgy,” said Toni Haastrup, professor and chair in global politics at the University of Manchester.Mélissa Camara, a member of European Parliament, objects to return hubs as a concept, saying they did not do enough to guarantee human rights. On Monday, she called the Rwanda plan “an agreement of shame, a grave moral failing.”Will this time be different?The nations leading the charge insist that human rights will be protected. And they say that deporting people to Rwanda could bring big benefits, including discouraging future immigrants.And Rwanda’s history of negotiating deals of this kind makes it easier to work with, said Alberto‑Horst Neidhardt, head of the migration program at the European Policy Center, a think tank.“It meets some of the basic criteria,” he said. “Plus, there’s a precedent, so the taboo has been broken.”Of course, attempts to put migrant centers in third countries have run into roadblocks. The British plan involving Rwanda did not compulsorily deport anyone, and cost Britain nearly $1 billion before it tanked.Supporters say the new five-country program will meet a need.“They don’t have a legal ground to be here,” Morten Bodskov, Denmark’s minister for immigration and integration, told reporters last month, speaking of the migrants being targeted. “The return hub model is an answer to that.”The European Union has indicated that the program has the bloc’s support.The project has come after “careful preparatory work, including with regard to ensuring the respect for human rights,” Markus Lammert, a spokesman for the E.U. executive, said on Monday.Jeanna Smialek is the Brussels bureau chief for The Times.Koba Ryckewaert is a reporter and researcher for The Times based in Brussels.Related ContentAdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Original Source

Read the full article at Nytimes →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.