Not a monolith: How Israel can rebuild its relationship with the Democratic Party - opinion

Not a monolith: How Israel can rebuild its relationship with the Democratic Party - opinion

NOVEMBER 16, 2026 17:00The relationship between Israel and the Democratic Party is in steady decline. Anyone who remembers the Bill Clinton years – a golden age marked by a close alliance and personal rapport between the American president and Yitzhak Rabin – may find today’s reality hard to recognize. The turning point came with Barack Obama’s arrival at the White House.In Jerusalem, there was criticism over his 2009 Cairo appeasement speech and his retreat from the red line he had drawn for Bashar al-Assad over the use of chemical weapons in Syria in 2013. In Washington, by contrast, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s public campaign against the Iran nuclear deal – and especially his 2015 address to Congress – was viewed as a direct challenge.The tensions continued during the Biden administration. Israel was frustrated when essential munitions were delayed during the war, and the Democrats were angry over Netanyahu’s open support for President Donald Trump’s 2024 campaign.The relationship has now reached a new low after the 2026 elections, in which a significant number of Democratic senators and members of Congress critical of Israel – and sometimes openly hostile to it – were elected. The consequences are already visible: Growing parts of the Democratic Party are questioning its traditional support for Israel.Changing the relationship with the Democratic PartyTo change course, we must begin with a measure of realism. Not everything is within our control. Much of this estrangement stems from deep ideological shifts within the Democratic Party itself: the rise of its progressive wing and the entrenchment of a “woke” political culture that views the world through an oppressor-vs-oppressed lens. Our ability to change the views of those in this ideological hardcore is very limited.US Representative Haley Stevens, a Michigan Democrat and the rival Abdul El-Sayed defeated in the Senate primary, speaks with the media next to Republican US Senate candidate Mike Rogers who she endorsed, after attending the Perfecting Church in Detroit, Michigan, US November 1, 2026. (credit: REUTERS/REBECCA COOK)Second, we must recognize that the Democratic Party is not a monolith. It is a broad, eclectic coalition of groups, each with its own concerns, interests, and language. Israel should stop treating the party as a single bloc and start engaging each community on its own terms:• Jewish Americans: Most Jewish Democrats belong to liberal denominations, especially the Reform movement. Instead of the alienation – and at times insult – they have experienced from Israeli institutions, we should embrace them as an integral part of the Jewish people. A respectful framework for prayer at the Western Wall, along with greater flexibility in recognizing civil and Reform marriages, is essential to rebuilding trust with this pillar of American Jewish support for Israel.• Hispanic Americans: We should build on the wave of support for Israel seen in recent years across Latin America (despite exceptions such as Brazil) to strengthen ties with Hispanic communities in the United States. Hosting delegations, holding community events, and engaging Israelis of Latin American descent as Spanish-speaking advocates for Israel could create a natural and authentic connection.• African Americans: We should emphasize the deep involvement of Jews in the civil rights movement of the 1950s and 1960s, as well as the profound respect in Israel for the legacy of Martin Luther King Jr. At the same time, we should highlight Israel’s long record of assistance to African countries and involve Israelis of Ethiopian descent as goodwill ambassadors.• LGBTQ Americans: Israel – and Tel Aviv in particular – is an island of freedom and safety in the Middle East. The fact that openly gay members of Knesset serve in senior roles, including as speaker of the Knesset, speaks for itself. Alongside presenting Israel’s openness, we should draw attention to the dire situation facing LGBTQ people in Gaza and the West Bank.• Moderates and national security voters: With centrist lawmakers and voters wary of the progressive wing’s more extreme positions, we should speak in terms of strategic interests. We should show how Israel serves as an American “aircraft carrier” in the Middle East: sharing critical intelligence, countering the Iranian axis, and sparing the United States from having to put troops on the ground.• Labor unions: Unions have traditionally been one of the Democratic Party’s strongest pillars. We should renew the historic alliance between Israel’s Histadrut labor federation and American unions, and emphasize industrial and technological partnerships that create tens of thousands of jobs in the United States – particularly through the share of US defense assistance that returns to American industry.• Climate and innovation communities: For those who put the environmental crisis at the top of their agenda, Israel should present itself as a climate-tech and agri-tech leader. Israeli solutions in water desalination, desert agriculture, and renewable energy help the world confront climate change and offer a bridge grounded in shared values and practical cooperation.A task for the next Israeli governmentAbove all, we need to change the way we deal with the Democratic camp as a whole. Ministers should stop making provocative statements aimed for domestic political consumption that amount to poking the other side in the eye. Serious disagreements will remain, but they should be handled privately and with mutual respect – not through public exchanges in the press.The task of repairing Israel’s relationship with the Democratic Party rests first and foremost on the next Israeli government. It must lead the effort, set a different tone, and make bipartisan ties a national priority. But the responsibility does not end there. Every Israeli institution, community, NGO, and public figure with any connection to the United States should ask: What can I do to contribute to this effort, in recognition of its national importance?The Chief Rabbinate and Israel’s wider religious establishment, the Histadrut and other labor organizations, Israelis of Ethiopian and Latin American descent, senior executives and opinion leaders in hi-tech, and LGBTQ community leaders – all can and should play a part. Rebuilding trust will take more than government diplomacy. It will require Israelis across society to help make the case for a relationship that serves both countries.The US-Israel alliance depends on bipartisan support. Restoring trust with the Democratic Party is a strategic imperative of the highest order.The writer is a senior research fellow at the Neaman Institute and an emeritus professor at the Technion-Israel Institute of Technology where he has served in various leadership positions. He also serves as a board member and strategic consultant to some companies and organizations.Follow us on Google

Original Source

Read the full article at Jpost →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.