End of mental health sick notes for young people and private ADHD clinics defunded

End of mental health sick notes for young people and private ADHD clinics defunded

Young people with anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism could find it harder to be signed off work under plans to stop GPs routinely signing sick notes. Labour grandee Alan Milburn criticised what he called an “insane” system whereby under-25s with these conditions are left on benefits for prolonged periods when they could be in work. The former Cabinet minister also took aim at private ADHD and autism clinics, arguing that they should have NHS funding pulled over a “cash for diagnosis” culture. Milburn’s final report into Neets – the under-25s not in education, employment or training – blames the fit notes issued by GPs for leaving young people languishing on benefits. As a result, he recommends that the fit note system for under-25s should be taken away from GPs and handed over to a new Youth Opportunity Service instead. ‘Cash for diagnosis’ The Milburn report says young people accessing the benefits system had become too reliant on private, independent clinics willing to provide diagnoses for ADHD and autism. The system had fuelled the rise of a private market “that is all too willing to provide a positive diagnosis” for ADHD and autism, which is then largely paid for by the NHS, the report said. “The business model is essentially cash for diagnosis, often completely devoid of treatment that might help someone turn that diagnosis into better outcomes,” it stated, calling for “swift action” against such clinics. Alan Milburn launching his final report on Neets (Photo: Stefan Rousseau/PA)Milburn said NHS funding should be “restricted or withdrawn” for private clinics failing to meet standards, and a new payment mechanism based on treatment outcomes rather than diagnoses alone should be introduced. Private clinics now carry out more than half of all NHS-funded ADHD assessments and more than a third of autism assessments, the report found. NHS spending on private ADHD clinics has risen by 252 per cent in three years, with a projected overspend of £164m, it also noted. Milburn’s report also warned that overdiagnosis of conditions such as ADHD and autism could hold young people back: “Used badly, it can become limiting, defining someone by what they cannot do rather than what they could.” End of GP sick notes for under-25s Milburn also wants to end the fit note system for under-25s. Fit notes have become an “entry key to the welfare system” and prevent Neets from starting work careers, the report states. Instead, Milburn proposes that a young person discusses their health problems with the local Youth Opportunity Service. The service will be expected to involve occupational therapists, job coaches and mental health experts in a bid to get them into work. The new service – which Milburn wants up and running across England from 2027 – would still assign one “case co-ordinator” to work with the young person so they can “agree a personalised return-to-work plan”. More than 11 million fit notes were issued in England last year, NHS data show, with 93 per cent of them simply declaring people “not fit for work”. Milburn’s idea is to end a fit note system that “operates in binary terms: fit or unfit”, and provide ongoing engagement with a young person out of work. There would still be some role for GPs, however. Family doctors will still be expected to issue the first fit note, particularly for short-term illness. But the process should be “a trigger for help – not simply a certificate of absence”, says Milburn. Prof Victoria Tzortziou Brown, president of the Royal College of GPs, backed the idea of a far bigger role for work coaches and occupational health experts. “This could help ensure patients receive more tailored, personalised and work-specific support,” she said. GPs were not well-placed to look at “the wider reasons why a young person may be struggling”, she added. Higher bar for anxiety and depression Milburn has strongly suggested he wants a much higher bar before a young person is signed off as sick when it comes to conditions like anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism. “We’ve got to stop assuming that just because a young person has anxiety or ADHD, that they cannot work,” Milburn said at a press conference on Tuesday. Mental ill health had become “one of the defining causes of youth economic inactivity”, he added. The report said that young people with anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism “often end up trapped on benefits”, adding: “Under the new system they would be both expected and enabled to be in work.” Milburn said in September that the current GP fit note system is “insane”, expressing concerns about doctors’ fit note sign-offs for mental health issues after only short consultations. William Yarwood, campaigns director at the TaxPayers’ Alliance said that private clinics “cashing in” on ADHD and autism diagnoses are “one of the vehicles fuelling the explosion in middle-class welfare claims”. Yarwood added: “Ministers must axe funding for failing clinics, clamp down on dubious sick notes and put an end to this once and for all.” Joe Shalam, policy director at the Centre for Social Justice think tank, said clinics were “profiting by preying on the vulnerable”, adding: “The government should move away from a culture of diagnosis-and-done and towards tailored support with a recognition of the positive health outcomes that come with work.” Prof Brown said GPs had seen “increasing numbers” of patients seeking help for ADHD and other neurodevelopmental conditions after receiving a diagnosis from a private provider. She said there should be “clear, consistently applied standards for ADHD assessment, whether it takes place in the NHS or the independent sector”. Andy Burnham’s Government will study Milburn’s recommendations, including the removal of universal credit health element and personal independence payments (PIP) for the under-25s, before deciding how much to enact. But the Prime Minister has strongly suggested he will act on the review. Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden told the Commons on Tuesday that a new youth opportunities unit will be created and report directly to the Prime Minister. Dr Sarah Hughes, chief executive of Mind mental health charity, said stronger employment support “won’t work without an adequate safety net”, adding: “Getting the right financial support is critical while unable to work, whether through sick pay or benefits.”

Original Source

Read the full article at Inews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.