The head of a documentary crew and a cameraman were given access to the campsite where Tom Phillips' children were found before the forensic examination had been completed, a review has revealed.The trip was made after Dame Julie Christie and the cameraman had spent up to 30 minutes at the scene where Phillips died, after his body had been removed - but before all forensic examination had been completed.The review says the officers in charge of both scenes were aware that granting such access was "inconsistent with best practice" and formally challenged the decision to permit access "however access was approved with communication emphasising that the agreement with the documentary crew was approved at a senior level".It was earlier revealed a film crew from Dunedin-founded NHNZ Productions had been following the hunt for Phillips and his children for more than a year, gaining exclusive access to the investigation. The documentary would be streamed on Netflix. The documentary is being produced by Dame Julie.In April, RNZ obtained a series of documents released by police under the Official Information Act (OIA) in relation to the documentary.Following the release, NZ Police executive director media and communications Cass Carter said police were reviewing the processes around the management of the documentary.The review, by Detective Inspector Shaun Vickers assisted by media consultant Gavin Ellis, was released on Friday.The review said police entered into a formal agreement with the documentary crew to create The Marokopa Project.Filmmakers for the documentary.RNZ / Mark PapaliiGovernance was managed nationally by the Director of director of media and strategic communications Juli Clausen, with district level governance and engagement led by the officer in charge Detective Senior Sergeant Andrew Saunders.The review said the agreement did not automatically compromise investigative integrity, but it "created conditions where integrity required active protection"."Decisions about access to crime scenes, evidence, specialist squads, and covert operations required heightened scrutiny to avoid exposing sensitive tactics or influencing investigative phases."Investigators raised concerns during contested access decisions, prompting escalation to senior district leadership."It also found that the documentary arrangement "complicated perceptions of media fairness".The shooting sceneThe review details how Dame Julie and a cameraman were granted access to the shooting scene on Te Anga Rd on 9 September, the day after the shooting.Phillips' body had been removed, but not all forensic examination had been completed.Dame Julie and a cameraman were allowed to attend and film from an area that had been "forensically processed".They were accompanied by the officer in charge of the scene."At the time of access, key elements of the scene remained in situ, including the ATV and police vehicles."Forensic evidence was present and visible within the scene at this time."Tom Phillips.SuppliedDame Julie remained at the scene under police escort for about 25-30 minutes while the cameraman captured "exclusive footage".The access to the scene was authorised by the Acting District Commander.Dame Julie and the cameraman then went to the 'Pines' campsite where the children had been found the day before.The review says they were authorised to enter the campsite and film by Saunders."At the time of access, the forensic examination had not been completed, and key elements of the scene remained in situ."Both officers in charge of the respective scenes formally challenged the decisions to allow the access.The proposalThe review says Police Commissioner Richard Chambers spoke with Christie and Karen Rutherford about the proposal."The Commissioner said he thought the proposal could serve as an artefact of Police work, allowing the public to see the efforts undertaken by Operation Curly staff to locate and safely return the Phillips children that were largely invisible to the public."However, beyond his "initial expression of support," prior to the agreement being signed, Chambers involvement was "very limited"."He was not involved in decision-making or kept informed of access given to the documentary crew. Nor was he aware his early support for the documentary crew was being referenced at various stagesto help ensure the documentary progressed."His only involvement with the crew was being filmed, but not interviewed, when he visited during the drone phase.Governance and management of the agreement was led at a national level by Clausen, the review said.Both Clausen and Saunders operated with oversight from their respective supervisors, the review said.An aerial shot of Tom Phillips' campsite.Dean Purcell/New Zealand Herald via Getty ImagesThe comms planThe communications plan for the investigation, dubbed Op Curly, was created in March 2025 by Clausen.The review identified a "lack of awareness and implementation" of the plan across the investigation."Several individuals indicated they were either unaware of the plan's existence or the most current version of the plan."The plan did not have a defined governance framework, or a set review cycle or update schedule. It also did not "clearly identify or expand on" documentary related risks including expectations andparameters.In relation to conflicts of interest the review did not find any evidence that Police decision-making or operational activity was influenced by the presence of the film crew. However, there were severalpotential and perceived conflicts of interest including mainstream media no granted equivalent access.Police respondFollowing the release of the review, executive director of media and communications Cass Carter said the review had given police "an opportunity to pause, look at works well already and where we can do better"."While the documentary did not compromise investigative integrity, we know there was a perceived conflict, and it did create conditions where integrity required protection."The review found there was strategic planning and consistency of messaging, but there should have been robust governance and oversight, clearer access controls, and structured escalation pathways tosafeguard investigative integrity."I can assure people, right from the start, there were strict settings in place to protect the children and sensitive police operational information."While the documentary did not compromise investigative integrity, we know there was a perceived conflict, and it did create conditions where integrity required protection. Some staff had reservations which they raised at the time."One of the campsites.Supplied/NZ PoliceCarter said police's relationship with media was also "called into question"."That relationship is vital to the work we do every day. The media supports our ability to reach communities and get important safety messages and reassurance out to them."We agree that some of our decisions around the documentary meant we did not serve media in the way we should have. Police has a long history of cooperating on documentaries or programmes involving ongoing investigations, and we don't want to stop that. They offer unique and interesting insights into Police work and transparency around our work, which enables communities to have trust and confidence in their Police."Carter said police "just need to do better in how we manage these agreements"."I believe the documentary crew also acted with the best intent in all their dealings with our staff. However, we should have had better processes in place for both our staff and the crew, so they could have better navigated those instances where there was uncertainty."Carter said the "learnings and recommendations" from the review would be implemented over the next 12 months.
Doco crew let into Tom Phillips' camp before forensics finished
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Rnz →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.