Did AI company tied to Sean Duffy's son-in-law cause FAA shutdown? What we know

Did AI company tied to Sean Duffy's son-in-law cause FAA shutdown? What we know

The claim that Sean Duffy's son-in-law, U.S. Rep.-elect Michael Alfonso, owns or has a stake in Air Space Intelligence, the company behind a new artificial intelligence-powered air traffic management tool for the FAA, is unfounded. The claims spread after the Nov. 13 nationwide ground stop, with some social media posts linking the outage to the company's campaign donation and FAA contract. The FAA denied that ASI's software caused the shutdown. ASI's PAC did give Alfonso's campaign $2,500 — not $12,500, as some posts claimed — before the firm won an FAA contract worth up to $875.95 million. But neither Alfonso nor Duffy has reported a stake in the company. Federal records show that the FAA received 12 offers for the contract. We found no evidence that Alfonso received the contract or that the campaign donation influenced the decision. Alfonso's team told us via email he had no part in awarding the contract and said no laws or House ethics rules were violated. The FAA said in a statement that its contracts go through "a rigorous, competitive process guided by nonpartisan career experts and personnel" and that ASI received this contract following an "innovative challenge with three vendors." Snopes will update this report if additional information surfaces. In mid-November, following a nationwide halt to U.S. flight departures, social media users shared claims about connections between Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy; his son-in-law, U.S. Rep.-elect Michael Alfonso, a Wisconsin Republican; and Air Space Intelligence — the company behind a new artificial intelligence-powered system used by the Federal Aviation Administration. On Nov. 13, the FAA ordered a nationwide ground stop after communications problems affected air traffic control facilities. The incident happened three days after the agency announced the nationwide expansion of an AI-supported traffic management system called SMART, developed by ASI. Some posts claimed Alfonso had financial ties to ASI or received the FAA contract through Duffy, while others linked the company to the shutdown. For instance, one Facebook post (archived) read: On Friday, the FAA grounded every plane in America. The AI air traffic system at the center of it belongs to Air Space Intelligence. In June, Sean Duffy's department gave them an $875 million contract. Before that, the company's PAC donated to Duffy's son-in-law, 26-year-old Michael Alfonso. He just won Duffy's old seat in Congress. Americans deserve answers. Another post (archived) on X stated, "Sean Duffy's son in law owns the AI company responsible for this FAA disaster yall." Versions of the claim circulated on multiple social media platforms, including Reddit, X, Instagram and Facebook. Snopes readers also asked whether Alfonso or Duffy owned ASI, whether Alfonso received a multimillion-dollar FAA contract and whether campaign donations influenced the deal. In short, Air Space Intelligence's PAC did contribute to Alfonso's campaign in March, and the company later received an FAA contract worth up to $875.95 million. However, we found no evidence that Alfonso owned ASI or that the donation influenced the contract award. The FAA also denied that the company's SMART system caused the Nov. 13 shutdown, and rather pointed to problems with its older communications network. Alfonso's team said he had no part in awarding the FAA contract and that the campaign donation broke no laws or ethics rules, adding, "Nobody trades an $875 million federal contract for a $2,500 check." The FAA said in a statement that "each FAA contract goes through a rigorous, competitive process guided by nonpartisan career experts and personnel." We have also reached out to Air Space Intelligence and will update this report if we receive a response. Here's what we know about the rumor: ASI's PAC donated to Alfonso's campaign According to a filing with the Federal Election Commission, Air Space Intelligence's political action committee donated $2,500 to Alfonso's congressional campaign on March 31: (Federal Election Commission) Alfonso's campaign also reported the same contribution: (Federal Election Commission) Some social media posts and articles, however, mentioned a larger sum of $12,500. That likely stemmed from a Raw Story article, which cited that amount, but later issued a correction. News outlets reported on Alfonso's campaign donations even before the FAA shutdown. For instance, in March, ProPublica reported that his campaign received money from lobbyists and companies with interests before the Department of Transportation. Did Alfonso or Duffy have financial ties to ASI? Some social media posts claimed Alfonso owned Air Space Intelligence. Snopes readers also asked whether he invested in the company or benefited financially from its FAA contract. However, we found no evidence supporting these claims. Neither Alfonso nor Duffy was listed among ASI's founders or executives. Alfonso's financial disclosure from April also didn't list any investment in ASI, although it only covered the period until October 2025. Similarly, Duffy's 2026 financial disclosure didn't list ASI among his investments. In a statement to Snopes, Alfonso said, "Family ties don't earn anyone special treatment, and my father-in-law knows better than anyone that I think for myself." His team did not directly answer whether he ever owned shares or had any other financial interest in ASI. Who received the $875M FAA contract? Some social media posts claimed that Duffy awarded a multimillion-dollar FAA contract directly to his son-in-law, sometimes describing it as a no-bid contract. For example, one Bluesky user wrote, "In a surprise to no one, Sean Duffy gave a No Bid contract to his son-in-law to install the AI program into the FAA's system." However, the USAspending.gov database showed the contract was awarded to Air Space Intelligence, not Alfonso: (www.usaspending.gov) The contract began on June 23 and could run for 12 years. Its maximum potential value is $875.95 million, but this does not mean ASI has already received all of that amount. "No laws or House Ethics rules were violated," Alfonso's team told us via email, adding that "By law, PACs can give up to $5,000 per election. Nobody trades an $875 million federal contract for a $2,500 check." According to federal records, the FAA received 12 offers before awarding the contract to ASI. The records classified the award as competitive, although they did not identify the other bidders or explain how ASI was selected. Bloomberg reported "the startup beat out larger competitors Palantir Technologies Inc. and Thales SA." The FAA said in a statement that: "each FAA contract goes through a rigorous, competitive process guided by nonpartisan career experts and personnel. The FAA awarded the contract to Air Space Intelligence (ASI) following an innovative challenge with three vendors who demonstrated the highest levels of reliability, operational performance, and efficiency." The agency did not say whether Duffy was personally involved in the decision, or whether there was any potential conflict of interest involving him or Alfonso. The FAA announced its search for a company to develop the system in September 2025, months before ASI's PAC donated to Alfonso's campaign, and announced ASI as the winner in June. We found no public evidence that the donation influenced the contract award. Alfonso's team said he had no part in awarding the FAA contract, pointing out that he was a congressional candidate at the time, and not a government official. In a statement to Snopes, Alfonso also said, "I can't be bought," adding that he would consider each bill separately, including any future FAA funding requests, and "vote based on what's best for Wisconsin." What caused the Nov. 13 FAA shutdown? The FAA said its new AI system, SMART, did not cause the nationwide flight shutdown on Nov. 13. During a news briefing the next day, Duffy explained it "is a system that's not tied into or connected to the systems that went down yesterday. It's a tool that gives a prompt to one of our flight managers that they can accept or deny, but it's just better information flowing to them," summarizing that "SMART had zero impact on the occurrences yesterday." Similarly, ASI wrote on X on Nov. 13 that the "current ground stop is not based on or a result of the SMART system, any product of ASI or our integration with FAA and ATC." According to a Nov. 15 statement, the issue involved the FAA's older communications network. The agency identified two possible locations connected to the problem: a site in Arkansas, where contractor L3Harris was installing a new router, and another in Texas. L3Harris confirmed in a news release it was cooperating with the FAA's investigation. As of this writing, the exact cause of the shutdown was still under investigation.

Original Source

Read the full article at Snopes →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.