Zuru quizzed over size of Lego wording on boxes

Zuru quizzed over size of Lego wording on boxes

Lawyers for Zuru say the toy company's use of the Lego trademark on packaging is to compare two brands, rather than make shoppers think they're buying Lego.It's the second day of Lego's appeal of a 2025 Court of Appeal decision, which said Zuru - owned by New Zealand rich-listers Mat and Nick Mowbray - hadn't infringed the global toy giant's trademark on a box of toy bricks.The heart of the dispute centres on a simple phrase that had been printed on packaging of Zuru's Max Build More brick building kits: "LEGO® BRICK COMPATIBLE".Zuru's lawyer Julian Miles KC told the Supreme Court that Zuru was using comparative advertising, rather than telling consumers this was a Lego product."It is literally just a comparison of the two marks, and can never be a suggestion that when they open up a Max box... they are expecting it to be Lego, which is where a classic trademark infringement would occur."Miles said that Parliament had permitted comparative advertising when it passed the Trade Marks Act in 2002, which has a section allowing the use of a registered trademark, so long as the ad follows honest commercial practices, and does not take unfair advantage of, or damage the brand's reputation.Miles said comparative advertising "worked for the consumer"."So long as the advertising is accurate, so long as it's passing on information that is valuable and helpful to the consumer, that is what comparative advertising is all about."He referred to the Court of Appeal's decision in his arguments, including that the use of the phrase, "LEGO BRICK COMPATIBLE", was descriptive.Lego was being used as an adjective in the phrase, Miles said, and was describing the type of brick.One of Lego's key arguments in court on Tuesday was that Zuru was leveraging Lego's brand by using its trademark on packaging, boosting Zuru's own reputation in the process and undermining the integrity of Lego's brand.Chief Justice Helen Winkelmann questioned Miles on the way the Lego comparison had been written in large letters on the box."You could just have a situation in plain black text, this is compatible with - a list of products it's compatible with - and that doesn't look like it's use of a trademark, it just looks like it's a piece of information being provided."Justice Neil Campbell said it wasn't that Zuru couldn't mention Lego anywhere, but that the brand name was "four times bigger" than information underneath, and would be the first thing a shopper sees.Miles said Zuru was factually stating the toy bricks worked with Lego, when other brands didn't - the sentence didn't erode the distinctiveness of Lego's brand or dent its reputation.This case has made its way through all of the lower courts over a number of years.Following objections by Lego to Zuru's initial use in 2018, Zuru brought a case to the High Court in 2021 to keep using the phrase 'LEGO BRICK COMPATIBLE' on its packaging.In 2023, the High Court agreed Zuru had infringed Lego's trademark, whereas the Court of Appeal ruled that it hadn't.The court has reserved its decision.

Original Source

Read the full article at Rnz →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.