Years after pandemic, fights over Covid mandates and punishments still simmer in Europe

Years after pandemic, fights over Covid mandates and punishments still simmer in Europe

The European Court of Human Rights found France could force employees to get a vaccine or quit working. A dissenting judge asked why patients couldn't be protected through testing or reassignment before taking nurses off the payroll.(CN) — Two French nurses and a firefighter who refused Covid shots went up to 20 months without their regular pay, a penalty Europe’s human rights court upheld Thursday even as one judge asked why France couldn’t protect patients and still let the workers earn a living.Nurses Florence de Haro and Vanessa Quetstroy and firefighter Pierrick Thévenon, who were suspended without pay in 2021 or 2022, asked the European Court of Human Rights to find that France’s vaccine mandate violated their right to private life. De Haro and Thévenon also argued the rules discriminated against them.The majority agreed France had interfered with a private medical decision but gave officials wide latitude during the pandemic. The three worked with vulnerable people, and France relied on expert advice that vaccination could protect workers from severe illness, reduce the risk to patients and keep hospitals and emergency services running, judges said.Employers had to explain how workers could avoid suspension and could let them use paid leave first. Employees could return once they met the requirements. The judges acknowledged how long some had gone unpaid but said none had shown particular hardship. They found no violation of privacy or discrimination protections and declined to hear de Haro’s separate property claim because she had not exhausted her legal options in France.Dissenting Judge Andreas Zünd, however, pointed to an exception in France’s emergency guidance. A vaccinated health worker who tested positive for Covid but had no symptoms could sometimes stay on duty to prevent disruptions to patient care. An unvaccinated colleague who tested negative could still be sent home without pay. In the French-language judgment, Zünd wrote, “Such a consequence required a separate and particularly strong justification.”The Swiss judge said France should have considered regular testing, better protective gear or reassignment. If none of those options made it safe for a worker to stay on the job, he said, officials should have considered a minimum allowance.For Maria Eva Földes, an assistant professor at Erasmus University Rotterdam’s School of Health Policy and Management, that scrutiny was needed for as long as the paychecks were on hold. She said the judges should have asked what France did to reassess the suspensions as conditions changed and what evidence showed that less restrictive measures still couldn’t protect patients. Losing a source of income, she said, called for more than evidence that the vaccine served a public health purpose.France enacted the mandate in August 2021. Workers could stay on the job with a medical exemption or a valid recovery certificate. De Haro, a nurse anesthetist in Marseille, was suspended on Sept. 15, 2021, and returned on Dec. 3 after catching the virus and obtaining a certificate. Quetstroy kept working in Lille until her second certificate expired. Suspended from Aug. 16, 2022, until May 30, 2023, she took several jobs before finding nursing work in Belgium.The majority took that work as evidence that Quetstroy had found a way to earn money. Silvio Sonnati, a labor law scholar at Bocconi University in Milan, said it also showed she could still work as a nurse, though she had to find a job across the border. Italy initially required employers to look for other duties for unvaccinated health workers before suspending them, he said, then dropped the rule. “Suspension should be the last resort, not an automatic consequence,” Sonnati said.Thévenon was suspended on Sept. 15, 2021, and asked to return when wildfires swept through France the following summer. The majority accepted that France had kept the mandate in place with future waves of infection in mind. It also said there was too little evidence to establish his claim that unvaccinated firefighters from abroad had been allowed to help while he sat out. Thévenon said he relied on family support. He returned after France lifted the mandate on May 15, 2023, ending 20 months off the job.Rogier Simons, an assistant professor of health law at Amsterdam UMC, said the ruling went further than earlier cases by accepting a loss of pay lasting up to 20 months while leaving workers to show how badly it had hurt them. “Whilst no one is vaccinated against their will, the pressure is such that freedom of choice is substantially curtailed,” he said.The applicants’ lawyers and the French government did not respond to requests for comment.Catherine Bouissou, a nurse and president of the French health workers’ union Syndicat Liberté Santé, backed Zünd’s dissent and criticized France for leaving suspended workers without income or financial support, unlike many other European countries. Her union is supporting dozens of compensation claims in French courts. “Free and informed consent is a fundamental principle, for patients and health workers alike,” she said.Marielle Zucchello, an employment lawyer and counsel at Flichy Grangé Avocats in Paris, said the ruling largely confirmed the approach French courts had already taken. Workers could still make a case based on serious harm to their own lives or careers, she said, though Thévenon’s outcome showed how hard that could be.All three returned to their jobs. Thursday’s judgment awarded them no back pay. Either side has three months to ask the court’s Grand Chamber for a review, reserved for exceptional cases. The judgment becomes final if neither side asks or if the court turns down a request.Courthouse News reporter Eunseo Hong is based in the Netherlands.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads

Original Source

Read the full article at Courthousenews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.