Xreal Aura Review: It’s Almost Time to Turn the Page on VR Headsets… Almost

Xreal Aura Review: It’s Almost Time to Turn the Page on VR Headsets… Almost

I wasn’t an early adopter of VR, but I wasn’t exactly late, either. I’ve been using or writing about VR headsets since the dawn of the Quest 2, and in that timespan, things done changed. That change has been good and bad. Thanks in large part to the unfathomable sums that Meta has poured into the space, VR has an ecosystem. It has affordable hardware, a bevy of games, and that glow-up has dragged Apple and Samsung into the XR space. Despite that very obvious growth, things haven’t looked so propulsive as of late, though. Meta’s all but pulled the plug on the metaverse and lots of studios responsible for making VR games; Apple’s Vision Pro feels more on the ropes than ever and is even more expensive than when it was first released; and Samsung’s Galaxy XR… I mean. Remember Samsung Galaxy XR? It’s still around, though if an XR headset falls in a dusty factory and there’s no one around to clean up the glass… is it really broken? From that vantage, things might look bad, but it betrays another perspective. A smaller one, filled with pucks, glasses, and the likes of Google and Xreal’s Aura. Xreal Aura The Xreal Aura glasses are exciting for the future of XR hardware, but have limited games and some quirky controls. The compute power is more than enough Software is fairly fluid and fine-tuned Lightweight and easy to carry around Display is decent Limited field of view Too much business, not enough play Hand and eye tracking are shaky sometimes A new face-worn future For all the debate over whether to saddle XR hardware with a compute puck, and all the work that’s gone into avoiding that form factor, the conclusion looks fairly plain right now. The assumption, if we’re to read into the decisions by companies like Xreal and Meta, is that people want XR hardware tethered to compute pucks, and not only that, but they’ll pay a fairly large sum of money to own one. That circuitous conclusion has arrived in the form of Xreal and Google’s Aura, a $1,279 pair of XR smart glasses with (you guessed it) a compute puck that does all of the heavy lifting. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo While the form factor has shifted from a bulky and enclosed wireless headset, the general ideas are still the same. With the Aura smart glasses on your face and Google’s Android XR platform glued to your eyeballs, you’re meant to do any number of things—watch things, play things, and everyone’s favorite, work on things. We all love work… right? Thanks to Google and its ecosystem of apps, the possibilities of what you can do with the Xreal Aura are actually pretty wide, but before I tell you what all of those experiences are like, let’s start from square one. First, we eat with our eyes. Seeing is believing © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo If you’re at all into XR, the first experience of putting on the Aura will likely be kind of exciting. For a form factor that’s so small, the screen feels surprisingly high-res. Xreal lists the resolution as 1,920 x 1,200 pixels per eye (1200p). On paper, that looks worse than headsets like the Quest 3S, which cost significantly less than the Aura, but in practice, the display of the Aura looks a bit sharper than the Quest 3S because those pixels are concentrated into a tighter area. The result is a virtual screen that doesn’t quite rise to Vision Pro levels of resolution but still feels fairly premium compared to other video glasses I’ve used and headsets like the Quest 3 and 3S. There’s some blurring and artifacts around the edges of windows, but watching movies feels fairly satisfying—I watched about 30 minutes of Quentin Tarantino’s The Hateful Eight on Tubi and an indeterminate amount of YouTube. There’s not a ton of dynamic range in the color, but there’s enough brightness to make the virtual display versatile in a number of settings. That being said, the concentration of pixels on the Aura is both a pro and a con. It’s a pro because sharp = good (duh, no one wants a blurry screen), but a con because it means the field of view (FOV) for the Aura is narrower. For context, the Aura FOV is about 70 degrees compared to the Quest 3S’ 96-degree FOV. The home menu on the Xreal Aura. © James Pero / Gizmodo The FOV is the second thing most people clock when they first put the Aura on. It’s tighter than I would like. I wouldn’t say it’s deal-breaking, but for reasons I’ll get into later on, it may be the biggest perceivable flaw of the Aura, and possibly the whole tethered XR glasses form factor as it stands. Once you see things, you have to interact with them, which is where the UI comes in. Controlling these XR glasses is very visionOS-like. The Xreal Aura employ a mix of hand and eye tracking, which feels intuitive. To select things, you pinch; for quick actions, you face your palm toward your face and then pinch. From there, you can glide your hand over what you want to do—bring up the home menu, manage your open apps, or go back. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo In my experience, the UI is decent, but not perfect. Hand and eye tracking are fairly accurate at registering where I’m pinching and what I want to do, but sometimes they falter a bit, missing my gestures by a hair, or thinking that I’m still pinching my finger when I’ve actually let go. They also get noticeably worse in low lighting, even if that’s to be expected. Sometimes they’re even finicky in bright lighting. I encountered quite a bit of frustration trying to navigate menus while using them on my couch at night, though in Xreal and Google’s defense, I do keep my apartment pretty, shall we say, vibey—lamps, no overheads. I guess the good news is, if you encounter problems with hand-tracking, you can actually use the front side of the aforementioned compute puck as a touchpad, which is far more accurate and responsive. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo In one way, that feels thoughtful and nice, but in other ways, it’s a little bit of a cop out. Hand and eye tracking are still the most futuristic and (theoretically) seamless way to navigate the Xreal Aura, and I think I speak for most people when I say that I would prefer them to work well all the time, especially when Xreal and Google position the Aura as a compute platform that you might want to use on a plane or other confined space—places not known for their ample lighting. Finally, there is, of course, Gemini. To activate Gemini, you simply press and hold the home button on the top-right of the smart glasses and then lob your commands at it. While this can be useful for adding stuff to your calendar, setting reminders, or searching the web quickly, it’s not super helpful for controlling the UI in the glasses. Gemini can’t, for example, close all your tabs or adjust the tint of the lenses. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo Gemini can, however, take in visual information using the on-device cameras, similar to Samsung and Google’s smart glasses. I personally didn’t find that to be super useful in my testing, but I guess if you wanted to parse a bit of code or something on a laptop screen while you’re also spatial computing with Aura, it could come in handy? Ultimately, controlling the Xreal Aura is really just beginner stuff. It’s what you do with those controls that you really want to know, and on that end, there are quite a few possibilities. A bit behind on gaming When I think about XR experiences, the first thing that comes to mind is gaming. If you’ve dabbled in VR/XR, you’re probably the same, and luckily Xreal and Google seem to acknowledge that common interest—for the most part. Let me start by getting one thing clear: Android XR and the Google Play Store do not offer anywhere near the catalog of Meta and its Quest Store. From the best I can tell, there only a few dozens of native XR/VR games available on the Play Store, while the Meta Quest Store has several hundred. It’s an unfair comparison in some ways since Meta has been doing this for over a decade, but if you’re spending upwards of $1,000 on an XR device, fairness doesn’t count for much. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo Still, it’s not a total desert. For testing purposes, I chose games that leverage XR the most as opposed to 2D games, and the results were a bit hit or miss. One game that I skated to immediately was Asteroid, which was a bizarre experience. In this narrative game, you’re tasked with—and I’m not joking—locating Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver DK Metcalf, after he’s been stranded on an asteroid. To do that, you’ll need to look around your environment and pick stuff up, but also (unfortunately) talk to an AI deepfake of DK Metcalf using the Aura’s microphone.The conceit of the whole thing is bizarre, to say the least, but instead of critiquing the game, I’m going to focus on what it’s like to play it on the Aura. First of all, the game heavily employs hand and eye tracking, since you’ll have to teleport around on an asteroid and look for clues. That experience can sometimes be frustrating given the variability in accuracy of those controls, but it’s not unplayable or anything. I would just prepare yourself for some misinputs. What is borderline infuriating, though, is the fact that sometimes AI Metcalf responds to your queries, and the Aura glasses can hear the responses he gives you, sending the AI on a blood-boiling feedback loop of talking to itself. I would recommend turning the volume down a bit to avoid this, or just not playing it at all. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo While the experience is meant to be immersive, with a 180-degree view of your virtual asteroid playground, it may feel slightly less enveloping if you’re used to playing these kinds of games on a VR headset. The reason? That FOV I mentioned earlier, which confines your view to an extent. Again, it’s not deal-breaking, but I do wish I could see more of my surroundings, since moving the screen around to adjust your view isn’t always the most fluid experience. In a few ways, Asteroid showcases the abilities and potential of the Aura, but it also highlights its pain points. Another fully XR experience that I played a great deal of was Chess Club from the developer Odders Lab. It’s exactly what you’d expect from the name—immersive chess. I played quite a few rounds against a computer and generally enjoyed the experience. I know it’s silly since chess isn’t exactly a game that’s hard to come by in the real world, and I enjoy, you know, interacting with a real human being, but it was still pretty fun. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo You’re able to pick pieces up and set them down on the board like you would IRL and even slap down on a timer next to the set if you’re playing a timed match. I did encounter the same frustration with hand and eye tracking at times. While playing on the couch at night, the Xreal Aura had a hard time seeing my hand movements and knowing when I was letting go or grabbing pieces. When I played during the day, it was smoother, but not perfect. Also, I hit my cat in the head a few times trying to move pieces around the board because you can’t see your surroundings at all while the game’s environments are running, so my apologies to him if he’s reading this. Chess Club © James Pero / Gizmodo It’s an entirely over-engineered way of playing chess, but I could see it being fun on a plane if you don’t mind waving your hands around like a dumbass in front of strangers. Maybe I’m biased as a person who loves chess, but this game was actually sticky for me—or at least it didn’t actively make me want to take the Aura off. I did try some 2D games as well, like Typoman, which is a side-scrolling platformer where you roll around as a hero made out of the letters h-e-r-o. The game itself is neat—a nice little puzzle-based platformer—but playing with hand tracking alone was (again) a bit frustrating. It was hard to jump and move at the same time, causing me to give up prematurely. The good news is, you can use a game controller if you so choose. Xreal is offering its own first-party gamepad, made in partnership with GameSir, but you can use pretty much any Bluetooth controller, like an Xbox one, for example. This definitely makes the experience less annoying, though it raises some questions of why you’re in XR glasses to begin with. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo I could say the same about 2D games in general, to be honest, which was gnawing at me a bit while using the Aura. The Play Store is full of 2D games that you can download and play on the Aura as you might expect, but overall, Android XR feels limited in its immersive experiences. There are games like Demeo, a tabletop RPG, Walkabout Mini Golf, and Asteroid, which I mentioned, but the true XR experiences feel few and far between compared to Meta’s. I’m not sure how long it will take for that to change, or if it ever will, but as it stands right now, Android XR has some catching up to do. Who knows, maybe Meta’s rollercoaster will finally compel VR developers to jump ship. Oh great… Google Docs © James Pero / Gizmodo If there’s one thing that’s apparent inside the Aura, it’s that Xreal and Google are making productivity a priority. Outside of gaming, there are Google productivity apps all over the Android XR experience. You’ve got Google Docs, Google Sheets, and, hell, you’ve even got Google Maps. Thanks to the Android XR backbone, Aura is positioning itself as a spatial computing platform, which, in the case of XR glasses, manifests itself in a few ways. For one, you can just pull open any of the natively supported apps I just mentioned and use them in a multi-window experience—this is computing that happens entirely on the Aura platform. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo From a technical perspective, the whole thing is pretty smooth. Apps are fast, the windows are nice and big and fairly easy to resize and position in your view—you just pinch and drag. You can even hook up a Bluetooth keyboard if you want to type, which I tried, and it definitely made the experience feel more complete. And if you don’t want to compute on the puck, you can connect a PC remotely through PC Connect and use the Aura glasses as a mirror, though this app is still in beta. Unfortunately, I wasn’t able to get this experience to work properly via PC, and I’ve reached out to Xreal for some troubleshooting. On the one hand, the spatial computing experience is an impressive technical feat and a success for Google, which clearly sees value in the idea of XR productivity. On the other hand, it feels a little… strange? There are some cases where I think you’d want to do computing this way, but I think they’re pretty niche. On a plane, for example, it would actually be nice to be able to forgo the laptop and save your tray table while having a sizable screen in front of your eyeballs at a moment’s notice. I guess, theoretically, in any situation where you might be pressed for space, the Aura makes sense. Outside of that, though, I’m just not certain people are going to want to compute this way on a regular basis. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo As functional and smooth as it is, you still have to wear glasses on your nose, which weighs on you even if they are fairly lightweight. The experience just isn’t as fluid or as ingrained as flipping open a laptop and putting it before your unburdened face. I think I speak for most people when I say, we already hate working, and any minor burden on that often life-draining experience feels unnecessary at best and, at worst, like a small form of masochism. There really is nothing about using Google Sheets, or managing your Google Calendar, or getting bombarded with distracting messages from Slack that feels inherently better in XR. I apologize to anyone out there who finds lots of value in the XR productivity experience—maybe I just don’t get it—but I also feel confident in saying that for most people, in most situations, the productivity side of the Aura feels entirely skippable. Are you not entertained? Though immersive gaming can feel limited, watching stuff is not. There are apps for Prime Video, HBO Max, Tubi, Pluto, and more. I pretty much covered what it’s like to watch stuff on the Aura—it’s not the highest resolution, but it’s fairly sharp and bright—but immersive content is its own thing. If you’re into 3D content, there are options like the NBA app, which doesn’t do live games in 3D (those are 2D only), but does give you 3D highlights. I watched quite a few, and the experience is fun, though not something I’d be rushing to buy a pair of glasses to watch all the time. Then again, I’m not the biggest NBA fan. I’m more of a football/hockey guy, so 3D Buffalo Bills highlights might hit different for me. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo Outside of the NBA, you can also go to the YouTube app for more 3D experiences—there are a lot. I watched quite a few (some 180-degree content and some 360-degree content, including a blood-curdling Cat in the Hat horror experience that I tapped on by accident). The results were mixed. Frankly, some YouTube VR experiences just look very grainy on the Aura, and the limited FOV really gets in the way of feeling immersed. Plus, because you get a lot more light leakage by virtue of the fact that these are glasses and not a headset, it can break the illusion. For people who haven’t seen an immersive XR experience before, it might be fine, but for those of us who have been using VR headsets, watching this type of content, the Aura feel like a bit of a downgrade. Google Photos on the Xreal Aura. © James Pero / Gizmodo I know I just talked a lot of smack about native Google apps in the Aura, but if there’s one Google app that I think does make sense in XR, it’s Google Photos. With Google Photos in the Aura glasses, you can look at your pictures and videos on a big screen, but also convert them to spatial content by pulling them open and pinching “Go immersive.” It doesn’t work well for all pictures and videos, but it does work on some, and it can be kind of fun for the proverbial trip down memory lane. I don’t know how sticky the experience is, but for someone who’s just getting acquainted with the abilities of XR, it’ll probably keep their attention for a while. The puck is no problem © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo When I first started to hear rumblings about XR hardware attached to a compute puck, I was skeptical. Who the hell wants to walk around with a hot piece of metal hooked to a wire on your head? I’m willing to admit that my skepticism was overblown. Using a tethered pair of XR glasses is just generally better than using a full-on XR/VR headset. It’s smaller, lighter on your face, cooler temperature-wise, and it does the vast majority of things that headsets do without all that bulk. From a hardware/form factor point of view, the Aura glasses feel like the future. Not only is the puck fairly small and sleek, but it’s quite powerful, too. While having three or four windows open simultaneously and streaming video at the same time, the Aura didn’t stutter or throttle at all. The puck did get a little hot at times, but not enough to make me worried, and the only time that it overheated was when my cat decided to sit on top of it while I was playing XR chess. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo The Aura is an impressive package, and it’s complemented by hardware that feels fairly comfortable, though it does start to wear on my nose after longer periods of use. The glasses themselves weigh 95g, for context. Compare that to a Quest 3S, which weighs 514g, and the selling point of tethered XR hardware really comes into view. There are nice touches beyond just the weight and form factor, too, like the inclusion of electrochromic lenses, which allow you to press a button on the side of the glasses to adjust the tint on command. It’s handy and is kind of magical to watch. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo The sound is also worth praising, with open-ear speakers that are tuned by Bose. They sound pretty good and help with immersion when you’re gaming or watching a movie. There’s not a ton of bass, of course, but you get a decent representation across the frequency range, and dialogue feels audible. Volume is also sufficient, though there’s quite a bit of sound bleed, so you might end up annoying people around you at max levels. Another nice touch is spatial audio, which anchors the sound to the front of you, so turning your head side to side will make it seem as though sound is pouring into that ear. It’s a subtle thing, but it definitely adds to the immersion. Also, the battery life is surprisingly long. Xreal says you’ll get three to four hours with a single charge of the compute puck, and in my testing, the battery dropped from 100% to 84% after an hour of watching a movie and playing XR chess. The whole thing feels like a performant, well-balanced, and complete package, and to me at least, further proof that VR headsets, with all their bulk, are not the future. A mixed bag of mixed reality Sometimes, when I use the Aura, I get it completely. The ability to do most of what VR/XR headsets do in a package that feels like a fraction of the footprint is amazing. You get a little bit of the Vision Pro and a little bit of the Quest without having to saddle your dome in a whole computer. It’s a technological feat. Where the Aura loses me is its platform, however. Android XR, though it has the resources of Google behind it, is still relatively new to the arena, and it doesn’t quite have the same catalog of games as Meta and its Quest headsets—true XR games are limited to what feels like a handful, whereas Meta offers hundreds. © Raymond Wong / Gizmodo To compensate for that, Google seems to be focusing on productivity a bit more, pushing its own first-party apps like Gmail, Google Docs, Google Sheets, etc., but if there’s one way to take the fun out of new technology, it’s positioning it as another way to cram spreadsheets into your eyeballs. Not only is it not fun, but I just don’t find it to be that useful, either. There are also some issues with refinement. While hand and eye-tracking are solid, I’d like to see it honed in even more so that I don’t have to pinch and hope that I’ve hit the mark. These may seem like fixable things, and in theory they are, but Xreal and Google have tough competition coming up. Meta’s VR Glasses offer an almost one-to-one experience, but they’ll have a few distinct advantages. For one, Meta’s VR Glasses have a luxurious 5K micro OLED display—I’ve seen it for myself, and it felt like a leap ahead of what Xreal offers. Meta also has a huge catalog of games, all of which it plans to offer on its upcoming XR glasses. There’s a chance that the bar for XR glasses might get raised, and soon, so while you may be excited to try out Xreal’s Aura, waiting until Meta has its say feels like the responsible thing to do. For now, however, we have a taste of just what the XR world has in store for our face-worn future.

Original Source

Read the full article at Gizmodo →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.