THE HAGUE, Netherlands (CN) — More than 700,000 Rohingya fled Myanmar for Bangladesh in 2017, and on Thursday the world court ruled the campaign that drove them from their homes was genocide.The Gambia asked the International Court of Justice, the United Nations’ highest court, to hold Myanmar responsible under the 1948 Genocide Convention and order it to repair the harm. The West African country could bring the case from thousands of miles away because every country party to the treaty has a legal interest in seeing it enforced. The court decides whether countries breached international law. Criminal charges against individuals are handled separately.By a 9–6 vote, judges found Myanmar intended to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya, a mostly Muslim ethnic minority, in northern Rakhine State. They found that Myanmar killed members of the group, caused serious physical and psychological harm and imposed measures intended to prevent births, including restrictions on marriage and childbirth.A Rohingya man stretches his arms out for food distributed by local volunteers, with bags of puffed rice stuffed into his vest at Kutupalong, Bangladesh, on Sept. 9, 2017. (AP Photo/Bernat Armangue)Myanmar said its forces were responding to insurgent attacks. But troops burned Rohingya villages and fired on people already fleeing toward Bangladesh. “The systematic nature of these actions further indicates a reasonable inference that Myanmar acted with genocidal intent,” the judges wrote. Looking at the evidence as a whole, the majority found no other reasonable explanation.The court split the same way over Myanmar’s failure to prevent genocide by civilians acting alongside its forces. Judges could not conclusively establish those civilians’ intent but found Myanmar knew or should have known of the danger and had the means to intervene. “On the other hand, the obligation to prevent genocide does not allow a state that is in a position to act in the face of a serious risk of genocide to remain idle and gamble that the risk might not ultimately materialize,” the judges wrote.Alex Whiting, a professor of practice specializing in international criminal law at Harvard Law School, called the court’s first finding that a state had committed genocide a victory for international law at a time when it was under attack. “It is most significant for the thousands of victims of the genocide found by the court, and the focus should be on them today,” he said.What the violence was meant to doLong before the exodus, Myanmar restricted where Rohingya could travel and shut many out of citizenship. After Rohingya insurgents attacked police and military posts in 2016 and 2017, security forces swept through villages in western Myanmar. At Min Gyi, also known as Tula Toli, troops cornered villagers on a riverbank and opened fire. For those who made it to the shore, the only way out was to swim.The six dissenting judges agreed Myanmar’s forces committed grave abuses. They saw two other reasonable explanations for the violence: Troops might have been trying to drive the Rohingya out or punish whole communities to deter support for insurgents. Either explanation, they said, was enough to defeat the genocide finding.The insurgent attacks helped explain where and when the troops moved in. What could they explain about the way the troops fought?Vaios Koutroulis, a professor of public international law at the Université libre de Bruxelles, said systematic violations of the laws of war could point to a purpose beyond military necessity. “The fact that the operations pursue such military objectives does not mean that they cannot simultaneously pursue the genocidal objective of destroying in whole or in part a protected group,” he said.Court Vice President Julia Sebutinde challenged the majority’s handling of the evidence itself. In a separate dissent, she questioned the weight it gave witness accounts and investigative reports and warned that its approach risked shifting the burden of proof.Even if the judges agreed on what the evidence showed, one question would remain, said Raphaël van Steenberghe, a professor of international law and senior research associate at Belgium’s UCLouvain. If forced displacement could explain all the evidence, would that alone rule out genocidal intent, or would the two aims also have to be incompatible?“In my view, the key test is whether the proposed alternative reasonable inference may explain the totality of the evidence before the court,” he said.What Myanmar owes the RohingyaThe same six dissenters opposed requiring Myanmar to give guarantees against a repeat. The court ordered Myanmar to investigate suspects, help displaced Rohingya return safely and voluntarily, restore or replace lost property, help find the missing and provide rehabilitation. Myanmar must protect Rohingya from discrimination in access to citizenship, though judges stopped short of ordering citizenship for all.Neither country’s representatives responded to requests for comment.“For the Rohingya specifically, this was textbook strategic litigation: A case brought as part of a campaign to bring about broader change,” said Michael Ramsden, a law professor and associate dean for research at the Chinese University of Hong Kong.He said the judgment gave governments leverage to press for citizenship rights and safe return and gave survivors judicial recognition after years of having their accounts dismissed.Joseph Powderly, an associate professor of public international law at Leiden University, saw the court asserting its authority at a time when governments were questioning it.“The court has issued historic judgments in the past, but in my view, this constitutes a new ‘Nicaragua’ moment,” he said. He thought the reasoning could strengthen South Africa’s genocide case against Israel over Gaza.Rohingya refugees stand on their capsized boat before being rescued in the waters off West Aceh, Indonesia, Thursday, March 21, 2024. (AP Photo/Reza Saifullah)For survivors waiting to return, an earlier order offered a measure of how hard compliance could be to secure. Myanmar had already breached a court order to preserve evidence, said Mohammad Pizuar Hossain, a lecturer and doctoral researcher studying atrocity impunity at Monash University’s Faculty of Law. “Nevertheless, the central challenge remains the gap between judicial recognition and practical implementation,” he said.The genocide finding is binding and cannot be appealed. Myanmar has two years to tell the court what it has done to repair the harm and what it proposes to pay for losses those measures cannot remedy. The judges will then decide how much is owed and how the Rohingya should receive it.Courthouse News reporter Eunseo Hong is based in the Netherlands.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads
World court finds Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.