“Take me, father!”It was one of many cries Reinaldo Dennes uttered on Thursday night as he lay strapped to a gurney inside a Texas death chamber while prison officials struggled, for more than an hour, to carry out his execution.Rev Dr Jeff Hood, Dennes’s spiritual adviser, stood by his side, his hand resting on the condemned man’s shoulder throughout the lethal injection, a procedure that witnesses agreed went terribly wrong.“The energy that was coming off of him was just such horror and terror and pain, it was overwhelming,” Hood said on Friday morning.Dennes’s was the 15th execution Hood has witnessed. A prominent advocate against capital punishment, the reverend regularly serves as a spiritual leader for people on death row across the US, offering guidance in the prisoners’ final months – and at times, holding them in their final minutes. Thirteen of those executions were lethal injections.Dennes’s procedure, Hood said, was the worst lethal injection he’s witnessed – by far.Before Thursday, Dennes, 70, had spent three decades on death row, sentenced to capital punishment for the 1996 murder of Janos Szucs, a diamond dealer. In the weeks leading up to his scheduled killing, Dennes was at peace, said Hood.“He was borderline euphoric about dying – he was so excited about getting out of prison and meeting God,” Hood said. “In the waiting cell, he said: ‘Don’t be sad. This is great. I’m going home.’”After nearby church bells rang at 6pm, officials escorted witnesses into the Huntsville unit, a Texas prison opened in 1849. In typical Texas executions, witnesses would be brought into the death chamber soon after, after the prisoner was strapped down and an intravenous line was established. But on Thursday, they were left waiting. And waiting.Reinaldo Dennes, a death row inmate for a deadly robbery that killed one and wounded another, is shown walking in the 263rd district criminal court in Houston on 14 August. Photograph: Houston Chronicle/Hearst Newspapers/Getty ImagesHood said he knew something was wrong. Officials, he presumed, were probably having difficulties establishing the IV line to administer pentobarbital, a lethal sedative. Executioners across the country have had similar struggles, including the botched, failed execution of Christa Pike in Tennessee in September.After roughly 30 minutes, the witnesses were brought into the execution room. Hood saw IV lines had been placed into Dennes’s neck and foot.Hood lay his hand on Dennes’s shoulder, he recalled. He told Dennes how much he loved him and thanked him for their friendship. In his final remarks, Dennes said he was “extremely blessed”, according to the Associated Press’s account, and that he hoped his family members “get to know this great gift and great grace of God the father”.The reverend recalled that Dennes signaled he was ready to proceed, calling out: “Go, warden!”The pentobarbital started to flow at 6.52pm, according to a prison spokesperson.Officials have said the drug should quickly render people unconscious. Hood previously witnessed three lethal injections in Texas and said those procedures had occurred “without a hitch”.This was different.Dennes’s body began to heave under Hood’s hand, he said.“He’s still shifting, he’s still moving, he’s pulling on the leather straps, and I can feel his shoulder pushing into my palm,” Hood said. Dennes, he said, felt like a “bucking bronco”.Dennes cried out, “My leg, my leg! … [It’s] killing me,” yelling that it felt as if he was on fire, according to Hood.‘He was tortured to death. It reminded me of waterboarding – just consistently pushing someone to the limit.’ Photograph: Eric Gay/APFor several minutes, Dennes’s cries continued, shouting, “Fuck! Fuck!” and “Shit!”, Hood said. The fact that he was able to utter any words after a minute was extremely distressing, Hood said, and it was soon clear that he was begging for it to end.“I don’t think this is normal,” Dennes said, according to Hood. “Take me, father! Don’t let me suffer like this.”Hood said his hand stayed on Dennes’s shoulder as Dennes repeatedly made clear he knew the execution wasn’t going according to procedure.Dennes eventually made several loud groans, followed by the kind of snoring sound that typically happens at the start of a lethal injection, Hood said. Dennes’s breaths got quieter, then eventually stopped.The execution came to an end at 7.07pm, 63 minutes after Dennes had first been strapped down, according to the AP. One minute later, a physician formally pronounced him dead.“He was tortured to death. It reminded me of waterboarding – just consistently pushing someone to the limit,” Hood said. “They were going to do whatever it takes to carry out this execution.”Amanda Hernandez, spokesperson for the Texas department of criminal justice, has told reporters the execution had followed the state’s procedures, saying staff placed IVs in Dennes’s foot and neck after repeatedly struggling to find suitable veins.Hernandez, the AP reported, further suggested that Dennes may have been faking his pain, noting he was complaining about his leg, which was not a direct injection site.“To say Reinaldo was putting on theatrics is absolutely disturbing and disgusting,” said Hood. “Reinaldo was completely at peace when I came into that chamber. He was a very contemplative guy who was remorseful for what he did and ready to move on from this life. There is no reason he would have immediately just turned on these theatrics.” Hood also scoffed at the notion that Dennes would not have experienced pain in his leg because the injection site was in his foot: “Has Amanda Hernandez ever had pentobarbital injected in her? How does she know?”“After 30 seconds, he shouldn’t have been able to respond at all,” Hood added.Hood said Hernandez and Bobby Lumpkin, executive director of the department, should resign, following in the footsteps of Tennessee’s prison chief who stepped down after Pike’s botched execution.Rev Dr Jeff Hood walking out of the Texas state penitentiary in Huntsville, Texas. Photograph: Execution Intervention Project“We want to be able to trust what the government says, but these statements [that it was not a botched execution] are simply not believable,” Hood said. “As far as they’re concerned, it was a successful execution because he’s dead.”Hernandez said in an email that the department “denies any claim of the execution being ‘botched’.“The overall process took about an hour, which is not atypical,” she wrote, saying the agency “took its time to ensure the IVs were inserted into viable veins”. She said Dennes had complained of pain before the drugs were administered.The reports of Hood’s botched execution have prompted renewed calls for a moratorium on lethal injections.Supporters of the death penalty, Hood said, must grapple with the reality of what happens in execution chambers.“To have your hand on somebody and not being able to do anything except stay, there is a horror that I feel,” he said. “But that should be something that everybody feels. If the state is going to kill people, then everybody should have to deal with that proximity. How many people would be for the death penalty if they had to engage in these moments when these guys look at you and say, ‘Help me,’ and there’s absolutely nothing you can do?”
Witness recounts a botched execution in Texas: ‘Just such horror and terror and pain’
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Theguardian →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.