A Knesset debate on Monday confirms warnings that Israel’s military has a budget problem. Israel’s defense requirements are growing, but its budget is struggling to keep pace. Protecting America’s national security interests and meeting the needs of Israel’s Ministry of Defense (MOD) require annual U.S. foreign military financing (FMF) to continue for the foreseeable future. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, however, said he wants FMF to gradually “draw down to zero,” and President Donald Trump stated in early November that it would be cut off by year’s end. Israel is spending an extraordinary 8 percent of its gross domestic product (GDP), or approximately $49 billion, on defense in 2026, according to Ministry of Finance data. That percentage far exceeds what any NATO member spends and is more than double what the United States allots to defense. If U.S. FMF ends this year or next, committee members are worried that Jerusalem will have to find additional funds to procure approximately $25 billion in planned U.S. defense equipment procurements. “Ultimately, the options are to reduce defense expenditure, raise taxes, or increase the debt,” said an Israeli Ministry of Finance official when explaining Israel’s choices if U.S. military assistance ended. America’s Return on Investment The current U.S.-Israel memorandum of understanding (MOU) provides Israel $3.3 billion per year in FMF from fiscal years (FYs) 2019 to 2028, as well as $500 million annually for cooperative missile defense programs. Israel must spend all FMF in the United States by FY 2028, creating American jobs, spurring the economy, and strengthening its defense industrial base. Regardless, FMF has helped Israel become the preeminent military power in the Middle East, improving its ability to take the fight to America’s adversaries in the region, including Iran and its terror proxies. The United States and Israel demonstrated an extraordinary ability during the 40-day war with Iran to conduct combined military operations, with Israel striking thousands of Iranian targets, thereby reducing the burden on the U.S. military. That would have been impossible without aircraft such as the F-35 and F-15 that FMF helped Israel purchase. Israel’s Big Defense Bills and Bigger Uncertainty The Knesset’s provisional Finance Committee meeting discussed the MOU following President Trump’s statement and lamented the lack of clarity regarding future FMF levels and the timeline for any phase out. Formal negotiations to establish a new agreement and new FMF levels started in June, focusing on joint investment in research and development, co-production, and a “transition from aid to a completely reciprocal partnership,” according to an MOD press release. Israel’s economy has grown, and that has helped it increase defense spending. However, a rapid phase-out of FMF could leave Israel less capable of defending interests it shares with America. Israel’s future defense needs include dozens of American-made aircraft, such as Apache attack helicopters, KC-46 refueling aircraft, and additional squadrons of F-15 and F-35 fighters. Israel also plans to replenish and modernize its missile defenses, expand its naval capabilities, and continue to address ground force shortcomings revealed in the October 7 terror attack. How To Get the Next MOU Right Israel is America’s most motivated and capable partner in the Middle East, thanks in part to U.S. assistance. An abrupt FMF phase-out could hurt Israel’s ability to help shoulder the security burden in the region, undermine U.S. interests, and provide a gift to Tehran and its terror proxies. Accordingly, the United States should honor the annual commitments under the current MOU. In addition to codifying deeper cooperation on defense research, development, and production, the next MOU should only phase out FMF as conditions permit, based on evolving threats and military requirements — not conditions-ignoring timelines. Given growing Axis of Aggressors threats, America needs capable allies to help shoulder shared security burdens and counter common adversaries. An examination of Israel’s defense budget realities reveals that an abrupt end to FMF will reduce the capability and capacity of the Israeli military just at the moment Americans need more, not less, help in the Middle East. Justin Leopold-Cohen is a senior research analyst at the Center on Military and Political Power (CMPP) at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD). Bradley Bowman is senior director of CMPP. For more analysis from the authors and CMPP, please subscribe HERE. Follow FDD on X @FDD and @FDD_CMPP. Follow Justin on X @jleopoldcohen and Bradley on X @Brad_L_Bowman. Follow FDD on X @FDD and @FDD_CMPP. FDD is a Washington, DC-based, nonpartisan research institute focusing on national security and foreign policy.
Without U.S. Aid, Israel’s Defense Budget Numbers Don’t Add Up
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Fdd →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.