Why Robert Pattinson is an odd choice for James Bond: How the actor's fame, Batman casting, and box office success mean he's followed a different path to the role than his predecessors

Why Robert Pattinson is an odd choice for James Bond: How the actor's fame, Batman casting, and box office success mean he's followed a different path to the role than his predecessors

Robert Pattinson has shocked film fans after taking the coveted role of James Bond in a last–minute casting coup.Beating established favourites Jack Lowden, Callum Turner and Josh O'Connor to the punch, Pattinson's surprise success has left many fans wondering if he is right for the role.Now, new analysis by film expert Stephen Follows suggests that the Twilight star really is an exceptionally odd choice to take up the 007 mantle.According to the expert, Pattinson's fame, Batman casting, and box office success mean he's followed a very different path to the role than his predecessors.In fact, out of seven tests for a possible Bond candidate, the only thing Pattinson passes on is his age.However, as detailed in a new analysis, Mr Follows says casting such an unusual 007 might be just the thing this beloved franchise needs.The film expert told the Daily Mail: 'Yes, he's a break from the mould, and the biggest one in the history of the series.'I think that's good news. The last time they cast someone nobody thought was right for Bond, we got Casino Royale.' New analysis suggests that Twilight star Robert Pattinson really is an exceptionally odd choice to take up the 007 mantle Film expert Stephen Follows created a 'Bond Detector' to see how much films look like a traditional Bond flick. However, only one of Pattinson's starring roles resembles a film from this classic spy franchise Why Robert Pattinson is an unusual choice for BondTV experience: Bond used to recruit from TV. Pattinson has never made a single episode.Fame: In the year before each of them was cast, Variety named the future Bond on between 0 and 3 pages. It named Pattinson on 17.Leading roles: Connery had led 1 film, Lazenby 0, Moore 8, Dalton 6, Brosnan 8 and Craig 10. Pattinson has led 24. Box office: The films Brosnan had led before Bond took $124m in the US, and Craig's took $33m worldwide. Pattinson's have taken $6.8bn.Hits: None of the six had been the first–named star of a film in the US top 20 for its year. Pattinson has, with The Batman.Other franchises: The first four had never been in a franchise film. Brosnan had made one and Craig two. Pattinson has made seven.Source: Stephen Follows When pundits and film critics were placing their bets for Daniel Craig's long–expected replacement, Pattinson was not even considered a contender.In fact, in April earlier this year, Mr Follows compared 460 different actors to see who best fit the established Bond mould.Out of the 460 actors ranked, Mr Pattinson scraped in at just 391st, while Callum Turner looked like the most likely pick.But this wasn't just an oversight, as renewed analysis suggests that he really is an odd choice.In a new study, Mr Follows devised seven tests that help determine whether an actor would be a good Bond candidate: age, television appearances, fame, leading roles, box office success, number of hits, and appearances in other franchises.Mr Follows says: 'I tested him against seven things the earlier Bonds had in common on the day they got the job. He matches only one of them – his age.'He's 40. The six before him – Connery, Lazenby, Moore, Dalton, Brosnan, Craig –were 31, 29, 44, 40, 41 and 37. So he's right in the middle.'However, on every other metric, Pattinson is nothing like the other Bonds from previous films.Most significantly, he is simply far too famous to fit with the traditional Bond casting pattern.The original plan for casting Bond, dating all the way back to 1961, was always to cast a relatively unknown actor in the role, a rule which has held for 65 years. Out of all the current working actors who could take on the Bond role, Mr Pattinson's films don't even rank in the top 15 for Bond–likeness Does Robert Pattinson match any of the classic Bond characteristics? Nationality: Every actor to play Bond has been British, Pattinson included.Age: The six Bonds before Pattinson were 31, 29, 44, 40, 41 and 37 at the time of casting, respectively. At 40, Pattinson is right in the middle. 'In the year before each of them was cast, the trade paper Variety named the future Bond on between zero and three pages. It named Pattinson on 17,' says Mr Follows.Likewise, none of the six previous Bonds had been the first–named star of a film in the US top 20 for its year.The closest was Pierce Brosnan, whose biggest breakthrough at the time was being third–billed in Mrs Doubtfire.By the time they were cast, Connery had led one film, Lazenby none, Moore eight, Dalton six, Brosnan eight and Craig 10, while Pattinson has already led 24.Meanwhile, the films Pattinson has led have taken £5.18billion ($6.8billion), while Pierce Brosnan, the next most successful Bond, had grossed just £94.4million ($124million) in today's money adjusted for inflation.However, possibly the biggest mark against Pattinson's 007 candidacy is the fact that he has starred in several massive franchises already.Mr Follows says: 'The first four Bonds had never been in a franchise film. Brosnan had made one and Craig two.'But Pattinson has been in seven major franchises, including two that are currently ongoing.Pattinson is due to appear as Batman in the upcoming The Batman: Part II in early 2028 and as the villain Scytale in Dune: Part Three this December.More strikingly, Mr Follows says that Pattinson's earlier projects don't even resemble Bond films. This could be alarming news for Bond fans, because established franchises typically lose revenue when they change to a new actor (illustrated) Mr Follows built a 'Bond Detector' which scans through movies to see when they visually resemble Bond films, featuring car chases, boats, aircraft, explosions and gunfire, and ran it over 13,487 films.'Of the 29 Pattinson films I could score, only one lands among the Bond films, and that's Tenet,' he explains.'Bond isn't a close–up part. In the typical Bond film, 41 per cent of shots are close–ups. In the typical Pattinson film, it's 59 per cent.'Put together, all of these points make Pattinson an exceptionally unlikely choice for his Majesty's new top spy.However, that might not be a total disaster for the franchise.For a start, although the original Bonds weren't superstars, this could reflect the fact that there simply weren't many British stars to choose from.From 1980 to 2004, a British actor led just seven per cent of the 20 biggest films at the US box office each year, whereas between 2005 and 2024, British leading men starred in a fifth of the 20 biggest films each year.Mr Follows' data shows that sequels typically make less money than earlier films when the franchise changes leading actor, especially when that actor is unknown. However, four of the five new Bonds out–grossed the film before them after accounting for inflation. This suggests Pattinson's star power could help breathe life into this 60–year–old franchise Out of the 436 times that a film series changed leads in the data set, only 26 per cent of sequels made more money than their predecessors.In this respect, the Bond franchise is something of an outlier, as four of the five new Bonds out–grossed the film before them after accounting for inflation.Additionally, Bond has been in a similar situation before after Craig was cast in the starring role.When it was announced that Craig – whose biggest role at the time was in the crime thriller Layer Cake – was cast, multiple protest websites and petitions were launched calling for him to be recast.Upset fans criticised his blonde hair, height, and rugged looks, arguing that he did not fit into the typical Bond archetype.However, Craig's first film, Casino Royale, is now revered as one of the best Bond films ever made, and his five films are the highest–grossing in the franchise's history.Mr Follows says: 'Fans who doubt a casting on day one are usually wrong. In 39 film and TV castings where fans doubted the actor at the announcement, the doubters were wrong 29 times and right three times.'Pattinson has been through it twice already, for Twilight and for Batman.'So, while he might not be the traditional choice, the data suggests there is a good chance Robert Pattinson could breathe some new life into the 60–year–old Bond institution.

Original Source

Read the full article at Dailymail →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.