Why McDonald's chicken nuggets might NOT be that bad for you: Dietitians reveal how they compare with supposedly healthier alternatives - from chicken goujons to tofu nuggets

Why McDonald's chicken nuggets might NOT be that bad for you: Dietitians reveal how they compare with supposedly healthier alternatives - from chicken goujons to tofu nuggets

Few foods are more synonymous with unhealthy eating than the humble McDonald's chicken nugget.Greasy, salty, heavily processed and supposedly made from the less appetising parts of a chicken, they've long been regarded as the epitome of junk food.But nutrition experts, surprisingly, say they may not deserve their terrible reputation.In fact, six McNuggets contain just 261 calories, 1.5g of saturated fat and a substantial 15g of protein – making them a surprisingly reasonable option compared with some seemingly healthier chicken alternatives.And despite their reputation, they're made using chicken breast meat, rather than the skin, bones and other scraps that many people imagine go into them.But would you actually be better off choosing chicken goujons, tenders or grilled chicken slices instead?And what about the increasingly popular plant-based alternatives?Here, dietitians analyse some of the bestselling chicken products on the High Street, revealing which are the healthiest choices – and how they compare with the original McDonald's Chicken McNugget... What's actually in a McDonald's Chicken McNugget? Per six nuggets: 261 calories, 15g protein, 1.5g saturated fat, 0.6g sugar, 1.4g fibre, 0.5g salt.Chicken nuggets have long had a reputation for being made from the least appetising parts of a chicken.That image was reinforced in 2011 when celebrity chef Jamie Oliver showed a group of American children how nuggets could be made by blending chicken scraps, including skin and other parts, into a paste.But McDonald's says its nuggets are made from chicken breast meat, coated in a batter and breadcrumb mixture containing flour, semolina and seasonings.While chicken accounts for just 45 per cent of the finished product, the remainder is largely the coating and other ingredients – not bones and skin.And despite being fried, six McNuggets contain just 1.5g of saturated fat, partly because they're cooked in rapeseed oil, which is relatively low in saturated fat.With 15g of protein and only half a gram of salt, they're not necessarily the nutritional villains many people imagine. ... so how do they compare to the nugget alternatives? Sainsbury's Breaded Chicken GoujonsPer four goujons: 365 calories, 23.3g protein, 3.1g saturated fat, 3.1g sugar, less than 0.5g fibre, 0.7g salt.Chicken goujons are long, thin strips of chicken breast meat coated in breadcrumbs and pre-fried – making them less processed than some chicken nuggets, but potentially higher in fat and calories.Indeed, a portion of these goujons contains 104 more calories and more than twice the saturated fat of six McDonald's nuggets.There's also significantly more sugar and considerably less bowel-friendly fibre.The advantage is the protein content – more than 50 per cent higher than a six-nugget serving – which may help keep hunger at bay for longer.Dietitian Sophie Medlin, of CityDietitians, advises checking the packaging for how the chicken has been prepared.'A lot of the options will be pre-fried before you put them in the oven or the air fryer,' she says.This means that even when cooked without adding oil at home, the coating may already contain substantial amounts of fat.And while goujons are often made from whole strips of chicken breast, that doesn't automatically make them healthier than nuggets.Tesco's Southern Fried Chicken TendersPer fillet: 348 calories, 27.1g protein, 1.2g saturated fat, 0.3g sugar, 1.7g fibre, 1.1g salt.Chicken tenders are typically made from the tenderloin, a strip of meat found underneath the breast.Tesco's version contains 71 per cent chicken, making it a particularly protein-rich option.One serving provides almost twice the protein of six McDonald's nuggets, with slightly less saturated fat.However, it also contains 87 more calories.And there's a significant downside: salt.At 1.1g per serving, the tender contains more than twice as much salt as six McNuggets – almost a fifth of the maximum 6g daily intake recommended for adults.So while tenders may be a good choice for someone seeking more protein, they're not necessarily the best option for those trying to reduce their salt intake.McDonald's Chicken SelectsPer three strips: 336 calories, 23g protein, 1.6g saturated fat, 1.4g fibre, 1.6g salt.Chicken Selects are McDonald's answer to tenders and are made from strips of chicken breast.Compared with six McNuggets, a three-strip portion contains 75 more calories but around 50 per cent more protein.The saturated fat content is remarkably similar, too.For anyone looking for a more substantial, protein-rich meal, Selects may therefore seem the obvious winner.However, the salt content tells a different story.Three Chicken Selects contain 1.6g of salt – more than three times as much as six nuggets, and over a quarter of an adult's recommended daily maximum.So while Selects offer more protein, the humble McNugget may actually be the better choice for those watching their salt intake.Wasabi Chicken Katsu FilletsPer fillet: 435 calories, 26.2g protein, 1.8g saturated fat, 1.3g sugar, 0g fibre, 1.4g salt.Chicken katsu is traditionally prepared by flattening chicken breast, coating it in panko breadcrumbs and frying it until crisp.Panko breadcrumbs have a lighter, flakier texture than conventional breadcrumbs, although the amount of oil absorbed depends on how the chicken is prepared and cooked.At 435 calories, Wasabi's chicken katsu fillet is the most calorific option in this comparison.It contains 174 more calories than six McNuggets, although it also provides significantly more protein.Ms Medlin says what accompanies the chicken is important when judging the nutritional value of a meal.'Serving with rice, vegetables, and broth makes it a more nutritionally complete meal as opposed to chicken goujons, which might be served with chips.'However, the katsu fillet itself contains no fibre, while its 1.4g of salt is nearly three times the amount in six McNuggets.La Vie Tofu NuggetsPer five nuggets: 264 calories, 13g protein, 1.7g saturated fat, 3.1g fibre, 0.5g sugar, 1g salt.For those trying to eat less meat, tofu nuggets might seem like an obvious healthier alternative.And there are some nutritional advantages.Five La Vie tofu nuggets contain roughly the same calories and saturated fat as six McNuggets, but more than twice the fibre – around the amount found in a banana.They contain slightly less protein, however, and twice as much salt.Ms Medlin says tofu itself is a nutritious ingredient.'It's got plant protein and minerals – but once tofu is turned into a nugget, just like chicken, it will then massively depend on the recipe as to how healthy it is.'If heavily battered and fried – it's still high in fat, salt, and calories.'In other words, switching from chicken to tofu doesn't automatically guarantee a healthier meal.READ MORE: What's the healthiest meal to order at McDonald's?

Original Source

Read the full article at Dailymail →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.