Why legal education must teach students how to explain law to common people

Why legal education must teach students how to explain law to common people

I often get asked by my students, “Why must we study literature at a law school?” and my answer usually takes the form of a workshop or a seminar where we discuss all the different ways studying literature helps our critical thinking faculties, our capacity to empathise, our storytelling skills, and our writing skills, among others. While legal education has, for the longest time, relied on structured methodologies to approach writing and communication [the IRAC (Issue, Rule, Application (or Analysis), and Conclusion) method, for instance], and while there is nothing faulty with that approach, it is simply lacking in everything that humanities might teach us.(Sign up for THEdge, The Hindu’s weekly education newsletter.)When it comes to writing and communication, traditional legal pedagogies have fundamentally relied on teaching students legalese, encouraging them to learn and continue to reproduce the archaic phrases that hide behind the excuse of precision, when, in reality, an ordinary citizen finds them confusing or too complicated. The law, therefore, feels inaccessible to the common citizen.The language lawyers use often makes it function like an exclusive club, and legal education often trains young students to join and participate in this club. Law is one area where speech and writing can directly translate into action; words do not simply describe but simultaneously create reality.Join THEdge LinkedIn groupUnlike literature, where words cultivate imagination, build worlds, or move their readers emotionally, words in law actively perform; for instance: a judge sentencing a defendant to five years in prison alters a person’s life and their legal status; or signing a contract transfers property; or swearing an oath binds a witness to truthful testimony. Legal language, therefore, is performative and carries immense power. Hence, it is all the more important to make it comprehensible and accessible to those who may need it.Need for exposure to literatureSo how can modern legal education teach students the ability to communicate the law in a simple, clear, precise, and accessible manner?To communicate the law better, students must first understand the implications of law in the real world. When words hold the power to do, it is not simply a question of clarity, but one of ethics. Exposure to literature allows students to build empathy while also understanding the importance of being empathetic, in a legal context.An AI tool can now draft standard templates or write drafts, but only an empathetic lawyer can sit across from a distressed client and offer practical legal guidance that doesn’t involve simply pulling up statutes sprinkled with legal jargon.A client walking into a lawyer’s office is hardly ever thinking in terms of timelines or facts of the case, instead they arrive with anxiety, anger, hurt, fear, or trauma. Literature and stories can train lawyers to be active listeners and close readers, assessing a situation with empathy, allowing them to identify the stakes and explain to their clients, clearly and precisely, the legal possibilities tied to the situation at hand.The inclusion of humanities in legal education inculcates in students a habit of academic writing, training them to write clearly and argumentatively, with cohesion and brevity. Students learn how to summarise, paraphrase, write literature reviews and structure their arguments; skills which are borrowed easily into understanding and translating legal concepts into simpler, more accessible language, without diluting their meaning or precision.Such exercises in breaking down the complicated and dense legal clauses often also test a student’s own understanding — which can sometimes suffer due to the legal jargon involved. They further carry these learnings from the classroom into roleplay-based experiential setups such as mooting, client-counselling, negotiation exercises and legal aid clinics which have been a crucial part of legal education in the country.“Ignorantia juris non excusat” or “ignorance of the law excuses not” is a fundamental legal principle, and yet a lot of legal principles are written such that they evade the understanding of the common citizen. It is crucial that legal education institutes recognise the importance of teaching their students clear and accessible communication as a core legal competency, rather than a “soft skill”.While legal education has traditionally focused on preparing students to speak to the judges and write for the courtroom, and perhaps their professors, legal pedagogy today must pivot to ensure that students are prepared to speak to individuals who lack a formal legal education. Lawyers shoulder a responsibility to inculcate public trust in law not simply by taking on clients and defending them, but by guaranteeing that the law feels less intimidating to an ordinary citizen.Studying literature and humanities as a part of the legal curriculum prepares them as future lawyers to shoulder this responsibility by allowing them to have the exact tools they need to make law comprehensible to the very people it is meant to protect.(Prof. Mokshada Manchanda is an assistant professor of english at BITS Law School.)

Original Source

Read the full article at Thehindu →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.