Who Everyone in the ‘My Life With the Walter Boys’ Cast Is Dating

Your other favorite show about a gaggle of brothers all in love with the same girl just dropped new episodes on Netflix! In other words, My Life With the Walter Boys is back for season 3, which means the internet can pivot from asking life’s eternal question, “Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah?” to asking life’s other eternal question, “Team Alex or Team Cole?”My Life With the Walter Boys hasn't been on for over a year, so if you need a moment to be nosy and catch up with the cast in real life, we have some updates. Specifically, on who everyone’s dating IRL. Starting with...Nikki Rodriguez (Jackie)Relationship status: Dating! Maybe?Cindy Ord//Getty ImagesFans have been speculating about Nikki and her My Life With the Walter Boys costar Noah LaLonde for well over a year now and still don’t have answers. And listen, at first it seemed like it could just be a collective delusion due to their wild chemistry onscreen...but then Nikki dropped a TikTok video last summer of Noah lifting her up with one arm, which everyone decided was a hard launch.Noah LaLonde (Cole)Relationship status: See above.Cindy Ord//Getty ImagesA little more info while we’re here: Aside from that ^ TikTok ^ which seems more than a little couple-y, Nikki and Noah have attended several red carpet events together that feel a little date night-y (the most recent one being in February 2026!).Michael Kovac//Getty ImagesAxelle/Bauer-Griffin//Getty ImagesGilbert Flores//Getty ImagesAmy Sussman//Getty ImagesMeanwhile, Noah told Teen Vogue of the TikTok moment, “It's funny that people are so presumptuous! I mean, we're all hanging out, ten of us [from the cast]. And [we saw] Lili Reinhart doing it with her co-star. So the first thing that came in our mind was like, ‘Oh, let's do it with our co-star.’ We like to have fun on TikTok.”Hmmm...Ashby Gentry (Alex)Relationship status: TBDCindy Ord//Getty ImagesAshby keeps his relationship status private, sorry to everyone thirsty and curious.Add Cosmopolitan as a preferred source in your Google search results.Use your Google account to add this to your settings.Sarah Rafferty (Katherine)Relationship status: MarriedPool//Getty ImagesSarah is married to a businessman named Santtu Seppälä, and they share two daughters. Here they are casually at Meghan Markle and Prince Harry's royal wedding (reminder, Sarah is friends with Meghan and costarred with her on Suits).Marc Blucas (George)Relationship status: MarriedCharley Gallay//Getty ImagesMarc and his wife, journalist Ryan Haddon, have been married since 2009 and have two kids. They're pretty private, but here's a throwback photo of them in 2008!Corey Fogelmanis (Nathan)Relationship status: Dating!Daniele Venturelli//Getty ImagesThere were rumors that Conan Gray and Corey Fogelmanis were dating when Conan cast Corey in a few of his Wishbone music videos. But during a September 2025 interview with Teen Vogue, Corey revealed that he “has a boyfriend he’s been dating for about five months” (and no, that boyfriend is not Conan). It’s unclear, however, if Corey and his mystery guy are still together.Alisha Newton (Erin)Relationship status: Engaged!Alisha got engaged to her boyfriend Trevor right before season 2 dropped. Cute!!The rest of the cast—including Isaac Arellanes (Isaac), Johnny Link (Will), Connor Stanhope (Danny), Myles Vincent Perez (Lee), Zoë Soul (Hayley), Jaylan Evans (Skylar), Ellie O’Brien (Grace), Mya Lowe (Kiley), and new season 3 addition Naveen Paddock (Eliot)—are either single or haven't opened up about their relationships recently enough for anything to be confirmed!