Analysis - In June, Qiulae Wong walked into a television studio and made a case to RNZ's Guyon Espiner that her Opportunity party could be the kingmaker at this year's election.At that time - it was only six months ago - Opportunity was polling around 2 percent and considered a long-shot for Parliament. It was frankly a bit of a line call to feature her as a guest on the programme, 30 with Guyon Espiner.But Wong's rise did not happen in isolation. Over the same roughly four month period, the Green Party climbed to its record 13.3 percent of the party vote on election night. And Labour's vote ebbed away, landing at a soggy 29.3 percent of the provisional vote.In short: over the course of the campaign period, Labour appears to have handed three to five points from its column to a combination of Opportunity and the Green Party. Even if it wrenches its way into government, the party has some hard questions to ponder about the broadness of its appeal.The second biggest loserLabour's result appears, on the face of it, oddly in-between. It improved its vote from 2023 - up about 2.5 points - and it won more support than any other party.But hold on, National slumped by almost 9 points. Shouldn't it have got more of that? ACT, NZ First, Opportunity and the Greens all improved their vote by proportionally more than Labour.When you look across the seven neighbourhood types in RNZ's booth-by-booth analysis, the pattern is clear. National lost 8 points or more in all of them - its electorate seat life raft was its only redemption. Labour, though, could do no better than a 5.2 point improvement in any one of them, and it was a meagre 0.2 to 1.4 up in three of them. This was all from a very low base of support in 2023, too.The neighborhood that most stands out in our analysis as a problem for Labour is 'middle New Zealand'. It's a voting bloc of almost mythical status in campaign politics. It is large: roughly a quarter of the population in our analysis. It's neither particularly old, nor particularly young. Home ownership rates are close to the national norm, incomes are a fraction below and just over half (57 percent) are families with children.It is not a singular bloc a party can command with one policy, unless you're in the midst of something like a global pandemic. To win big with this group of voters, a party needs broad appeal.Labour did win this group, and slightly outperformed its overall result with around 30 percent compared to National's 28.3 percent. But this was only 1.4 points better than it did with this group in 2023.NZ First and ACT picked up 5.5 points between them in middle New Zealand. The Greens and Opportunity combined picked up 6.9 points.Two paths, one argumentThese numbers expose the guts of the debate that will now ensue within Labour. The smaller parties extracted greater gains in these neighbourhoods with sharper, more radical ideas about how to respond to the omnicrisis bearing down on society.On the left and right wings of Labour there is ammunition here to argue the party failed to fire because it was too timid. It ceded the very popular wealth tax policy to the Greens. It more or less matched National with a measured fiscal plan.Take Trident, in Whakatāne, one of the 515 'middle New Zealand' neighbourhoods in our analysis. Here, of the 1904 votes cast, Labour got 37.2 percent of the vote, which sounds fine but was a nine point decline on 2023. Te Pāti Māori also fell from 11 to 3.5 percent here. The Green vote more than trebled, from 4.7 to 17.4 percent.In Trident, incomes are below the national median, the birth rate and population as a whole are both flat. More than four out of 10 in the community are Māori, a proportion that is growing. The Green vote here was likely up partially in response to the strategic vote splitting call from Te Pāti Māori, but the decline in support for Labour signals something distinctive about how it is resonating with this community.Labour leader Chris Hipkins may argue the party would have been worse off if it had campaigned on a more radical platform. For any votes it may have picked up in places like Trident, it would have lost more to New Zealanders scarred by radical reforms of the past, or worried about people turning on each other and the fabled 'Kiwi way' falling apart. National probably lost some support as a result of flashpoints like pay equity and the Treaty Principles Bill. Hipkins appears to have believed many of those voters did not want to layer discord on top of discord with reactionary responses.Hipkins could also argue that actually, there was stuff in his party's platform that spoke to voters keen on meaningful change. A capital gains tax is hardly a policy you'd write into a boiler plate 'small target campaign' for the New Zealand Labour Party. And it did have a clutch of eye-catching ideas to address the cost of living. It might simply have failed to get these policies across with potential supporters.The case for the moderatesPerhaps these sorts of ideas did land with the 113 neighbourhoods we described as 'young renters, few children', where Labour was up by 5.1 points. Voters in these neighbourhoods are slightly younger than in Middle New Zealand, they have higher household incomes (median $101,000), higher rates of fulltime work, but low rates of home ownership. At the very least, they do not appear to have been put off in big numbers by the idea Labour is too radical, or profligate.Two specific booths, one in Auckland and one in Wellington, crystalise the delicate balancing act for Labour in these neighbourhoods, weighed against places like Trident.In Mount Eden North East, which is within the Epsom electorate, National lost eight points. A little of that vote went to ACT and NZ First, which climbed a point each. Labour's party vote increased by 3.6 points while the Greens went down 2.5.Similarly, in Newtown North, National lost 3.1 points, ACT and NZ First stood still and the Green Party was down 5.3 points. Labour was up 6.5 points to 38.9 percent in this neighbourhood.These are not wealthy areas - personal income is either side of the national median in each of them, and people renting here pay about $200 per week more than the national median.They're younger, but also have a significantly higher proportion of post-school educated people.Labour's moderates might argue that these voters are typically aspirational and open-minded so could be put off by a wealth tax or a lot of government spending. Its more radical voices though, could point to how well the Green Party and Opportunity did with these voters. The Greens got a third of the vote in Newtown North, and Opportunity 10 percent. In Mount Eden North East, the Greens got almost a fifth and Opportunity 12.5 percent. Why shouldn't Labour get more of that vote?Who wins the argument over Labour's future?How this argument breaks down within Labour will have a lot to do with where it lands on its leadership. Firstly: is the party leadership a question to be answered? Until it is clear that Hipkins has no path to the prime ministership, everything is on hold.If the special votes and negotiations that follow put an end to that idea, does Hipkins want to carry on? If he does, are there challengers? Who are they, and what factions do they represent?Labour's constitution requires a leadership vote within three months of the election so these questions will be answered at some point this summer.The caucus has first crack at it - a candidate who can command two-thirds support gets the job. If no one can get to that level, it goes to an electoral college process where party members and unions get a say. It's possible the more left-leaning among the membership would welcome such a process more so than moderates.One side, the more radically inclined, will want to chase what appears to be a growing group of frustrated voters, hungry for change. The other, more moderate, will be worried about might happen if it does.MethodologyRNZ's Farah Hancock conducted the data analysis that informs this piece. It grouped Stats NZ's SA2 areas into seven types using 13 measures from the 2023 Census including age, home ownership, income, education, work, household make-up, social housing and population density. We tested between four and 12 types and repeated the grouping hundreds of times on resampled data. The seven neighbourhood types reappeared consistently, and the main vote findings held when neighbourhoods on the edge between two neighbourhood types were left out.We named each type after what most sets it apart from the New Zealand average, such as a high share of young adults, older residents or families with children. Votes are those cast at voting places, linked to the neighbourhood the voting place is in.Neighbourhoods with fewer than 100 residents, such as city centres, industrial areas and airports, were not given a type, because their census figures are unreliable. Votes cast there are included in national totals but not in the figures for any neighbourhood. Votes with no location, such as mobile and hospital voting were treated the same way. Combined these represent about 2.7 percent of the vote.2017, 2020 and 2023 figures are the official count, and 2026 the preliminary count. Special and overseas votes are not included in any year, because they can't be tied to a place. One voting place in Mt Roskill (Blockhouse Bay Primary School) is left out because of a probable error in its 2026 preliminary result.
Voting data shows Labour misfired with ‘Middle NZ’ - a reckoning for the party lies in wait
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Rnz →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.