Representative Image (AI-generated)A property sale in Vermont eventually turned into a complicated legal dispute involving an unfinished pond, timber removed from private land, unpaid construction work and an alleged assault. What began as a business arrangement between two men expanded into a lawsuit involving a subcontractor, competing financial claims and allegations of extortion. After a jury awarded money to all three parties on different claims, the case reached the state's highest court.The Vermont Supreme Court, in its November 13, 2026, decision in Lamson v. Goode, available on Justia, upheld the lower court's judgment in all respects. The ruling preserved awards of $15,100 for civil extortion in favour of subcontractor Chase Locke, $7,500 for breach of contract in favour of Gregory Lamson and $5,000 for assault in favour of James Goode. The court also upheld the decision to deny attorney's fees to both Lamson and Goode under Vermont's Prompt Pay Act.A land sale led to a dispute over pond constructionThe dispute began in 2015, when Lamson sold 42 acres of land in Royalton, Vermont, to Goode. Following the sale, Goode hired Lamson to construct a pond on another property he owned. Lamson subcontracted Locke to clear-cut the land for the proposed pond. Separately, Lamson also hired Locke to cut timber on his own property. However, disagreements developed over payments, the completion of the pond project and the use of equipment. Lamson eventually filed a lawsuit against both men in 2017.He accused Goode of breaching their construction agreement by preventing him from completing the pond and refusing to pay him. He also alleged that Goode had wrongfully used his tractor and prevented him from accessing a crane and other personal belongings left at the Royalton property. Against Locke, Lamson brought claims involving breach of contract and conversion, alleging that the subcontractor had sold timber and firewood from his property.The defendants also filed counterclaims. Goode accused Lamson of assault, among other allegations, while Locke claimed that Lamson had failed to pay him for logging work and threatened to make false police reports to obtain money and property.Jury awarded money on three separate claimsFollowing a jury trial, the court entered judgment in favour of Lamson on his breach-of-contract claim against Goode, awarding him $7,500, along with $8,149.32 in prejudgment interest. However, Goode also received $5,000 on his assault claim, while Locke was awarded $15,100 on his civil extortion claim. The extortion allegations centred on claims that Lamson had repeatedly threatened to report Locke to the police and his parole officer unless he handed over money and valuable property, including a storage locker. Locke argued that the threats were intended to obtain something from him through coercion.Lamson challenged the legal basis for the civil extortion claim, arguing that Vermont's criminal extortion law did not create a separate civil right to sue. The trial court initially agreed but later reconsidered its decision and allowed the claim to go before the jury. Both Lamson and Goode also sought attorney's fees under Vermont's Prompt Pay Act, which provides for fees when a party substantially prevails in a payment dispute involving construction work. The trial court denied both requests, finding that neither had achieved a sufficiently decisive victory.Why the Vermont Supreme Court upheld the awardsLamson and Goode appealed different parts of the judgment. Goode argued that he should have received attorney's fees because Lamson had not established a violation of the Prompt Pay Act. Lamson also sought fees and challenged Locke's $15,100 extortion award. The Supreme Court concluded that deciding whether a party substantially prevailed was within the trial court's discretion. It found that neither Lamson nor Goode had achieved the kind of comparative victory necessary to qualify for attorney's fees.On the extortion issue, the justices found that Vermont precedent allowed the recovery of money or property transferred under economic duress. The jury had been instructed to award Locke the value of money or property he had handed over to Lamson, making the award consistent with restitution principles. The justices therefore upheld the $15,100 award without deciding whether Vermont law recognises a separate civil cause of action for extortion. The court also noted that Lamson had failed to preserve his challenge to the amount of damages through a timely post-trial motion and had not ordered a transcript of the relevant trial testimony.On November 13, 2026, the Vermont Supreme Court affirmed the judgment in its entirety. The decision left all three monetary awards intact and denied both parties' requests for attorney's fees.
Vermont pond and timber feud: Court upholds $27,600 in extortion, assault awards
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Timesofindia →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.