Used car dealer gets green light for judicial review

Used car dealer gets green light for judicial review

WILDMAN...we were seeking an injunction but the judge never granted the injunction (Photo: Naphtali Junior) ATTORNEY Hugh Wildman is upbeat after Justice Sonya Wint-Blair granted leave for a judicial review of the decision by the Jamaica Trade Board and the Ministry of Industry and Commerce to impose a mandatory warranty policy on used car dealers. Wint-Blair’s decision, which was made on Wednesday afternoon in the Civil Division of the Supreme Court, cleared the way for Wildman to file documents supporting the arguments of his client Lynvalle Hamilton, who is owner of Auto Channel Limited. Hamilton is challenging the policy as a business owner and as the president of the Used Car Dealers Association. “She granted leave to apply for judicial review to quash the decision of the Trade Board and the Ministry of Industry of Commerce to institute a policy that the importers of used motor vehicles have to grant special warranty to their customers, which we contend is in breach of Section 15 of the Sale of Goods Act,” Wildman told the Jamaica Observer. The attorney said that the judge has given him 14 days to file the necessary papers to make the claim on behalf of Hamilton. “We were seeking an injunction, but the judge never granted the injunction. She said damages would be adequate remedy,” he explained. The Attorney General’s Chambers represent the Trade Board and the Ministry of Industry and Commerce in the matter. Hamilton has argued that it was important for him to head to the court to seek to block the Trade Board’s warranty policy from taking any further effect because it proved a setback to his businesses. According to Hamilton, other players in the used motor vehicle industry are running scared and even though they are not happy with the policy, they refused to team up with him due to fear they might become targets. “With this policy in particular, the Trade Board compels us to give a certain warranty and that is not consistent with the law, the Sale of Goods Act. This clearly gives us the right to choose the warranty that we want to give to the customer,” Hamilton told the Observer. He said that the customers can rely on his expertise, and that of other players in the business, to get warranty, but the Trade Board’s policy forces them to give warranty on every occasion and outlines a particular warranty that they are to give. HAMILTON…they are acting as if they are a law unto themselves as is the case with many agencies and entities in Jamaica (Photo: Naphtali Junior) “They are acting as if they are a law unto themselves, as is the case with many agencies and entities in Jamaica. This has to be challenged,” declared Hamilton. He claimed that because of his refusal to comply with the policy, his certification was blocked, and expressed fear that certification was being used as a weapon against used car dealers. “It is ruining business. This is my livelihood. This is an abuse of power. The other players in the industry are afraid because, listen, not everybody will stand up to the Government in situations like this. You have to stand up for your rights and also get the Government to abide by the law,” he argued. “The Government can’t make the laws and then want to be a law unto themselves, and that’s what they are doing now. The dealers, although they know it is wrong, they still comply just to keep their business going,” Hamilton lamented. In September, Wildman told the Observer that the warranty policy was proving difficult for players in the industry to adhere to and charged that it was illegal. “The Sale of Goods Act is what governs the buying and selling of goods. When they import motor vehicles from abroad and they are going to sell it to the customer, the customer examines the vehicle before to see whether or not they wish to buy it. Whatever warranty is given to them by the dealer, that is it,” argued Wildman. The warranty policy on motor vehicle imports was published in Jamaica Gazette dated April 1, 2014. It states that all certified motor vehicle dealers must ensure that the warranty provided on motor vehicles imported and sold by them is not materially less than that offered by the manufacturer. The Gazette also states that all certified used motor vehicle dealers and brokers must provide warranties in accordance with guidelines determined by the vehicles’ age and odometer reading. The warranty covers vehicle parts such as the engine, transmission, differential, steering gear, drive chain, front end, major electronic components, including computers, air conditioning system, general electric system, and suspension system.

Original Source

Read the full article at Jamaicaobserver →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.