After last week’s U.S.-Russia-Ukraine talks in Abu Dhabi, President Volodymyr Zelensky said that American negotiators had asked him a hypothetical question: “What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?” Zelensky signaled openness on Kyiv’s side and pointed to Moscow as the obstacle. He is right. Russia would reject such a trade.On its part, Moscow criticized Zelensky for revealing the exchange, declined to confirm it, and restated its long-standing opposition to Ukraine joining the defensive military alliance. At the same time, Moscow reportedly even went so far as to demand that NATO expel Finland as part of any peace deal.Still, the reason why Russia won’t accept such a deal lies in why Russia went to war in the first place. Moscow launched this war to bring Ukraine under its control. Putin laid out the ideological case in a 2021 essay that cast Ukrainian statehood as an artificial construct. Moscow had been trying to keep Ukraine firmly in its orbit long before the full-scale invasion. In 2013, it pressured President Viktor Yanukovych to walk away from a free trade agreement with the European Union. This led Ukrainians to take to the streets and oust him. In 2014, Russia seized Crimea and started the war in Eastern Ukraine, all while Kyiv was still formally nonaligned.But Russia recognizes that if Ukraine were inside NATO, Kyiv would be beyond Russia’s capacity for subjugation. NATO succeeds because no adversary can gamble to face the power of the U.S. military, since any attack on a member state would mean direct conflict with the United States, a risk Moscow is unlikely to take.For Ukraine, membership even without the Donbas ranks among the best outcomes short of outright victory. An American commitment to defend Ukraine is a guarantee of peace for Ukraine and its future generations. That guarantee needs to be functionally bulletproof, however, with American troops stationed in Poland or in Ukraine itself. The promise must carry weight and leave Moscow zero room to probe or provoke.Of course, Ukraine’s accession to NATO would amount to a Western victory and a stronger American position in Europe. That is precisely the European security order that Russia went to war to undermine. And that is why Moscow will reject it.TRUMP SIGNALS NO RETREAT FROM MAGA AGENDA WITH STEPHEN MILLER PROMOTIONFor the same reason, then, it is also the outcome the West should pursue.Russia will accept such an outcome only when it has to, and today it is far from that point. The Kremlin still believes it can outlast Ukraine and its backers, so it will reject any deal that threatens its goals. The task is to change that belief. That requires steady support for Ukraine, with pressure aimed at Moscow instead of Kyiv, an end to cuts to Ukraine’s Starlink access, and sustained weapons deliveries. Only when Russia is weak enough to see the war as unwinnable will it be eager to negotiate in good faith.
Ukraine would trade territory for NATO membership, but Russia wouldn’t agree
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.