Ukraine Should Recognize Kosova

Ukraine Should Recognize Kosova

This past August, President Volodymyr Zelensky stated that Ukraine’s position on Kosova, namely, not recognizing it, remains unchanged. What was striking about this is that the statement was made in Belgrade, the capital of Serbia, one of Russia’s closest allies. Kosova, in turn, has maintained its position on Ukraine as well: one of support. We have condemned Moscow’s aggression, aligned with US and EU sanctions, sheltered Ukrainian journalists, and contributed military assistance and training.JOIN US ON TELEGRAMFollow our coverage of the war on the @Kyivpost_official. Many parallels can be drawn between Kosova and Ukraine. The conflict in Ukraine is the first major war in Europe since Kosova. Both countries face a neighbor making dubious appeals to history from many centuries ago to justify claims over their territory today. Kosova and Ukraine also share a history of the international community backing them, at different moments and under different circumstances, in remarkable shows of international unity. In a strange turn of events, there has been a kind of zigzagging. Zelensky has moved closer to Serbia, a country that has repeatedly refused to sanction Russia even after the October parliamentary elections changed the leadership, while Russia itself has repeatedly invoked the example of Kosova. In his speech after the annexation of Crimea, Putin went back a thousand years to justify Russia’s claims. He also mentioned Kosova: “Our Western partners created the Kosovo precedent with their own hands – in a very similar situation, as they agreed themselves – and then they shrieked and cried when Crimeans used that same right.” Other Topics of Interest German Chancellor says there could be relaxation of Russian sanctions in exchange for progress in peace talks with Ukraine. Putin is not concerned with abiding by international law. His invocation of Kosova is instead an attempt to discredit the West. He accuses the West of wanting to humiliate Russia, while arguing that it has itself created a precedent of lawlessness. Kosova is no stranger to ruffling feathers with its recognition. It declared independence in 2008, after most European borders had already been settled through the post-World War II order, the collapse of the Soviet Union and the breakup of Yugoslavia. Today, more than 120 countries have recognized it, and from the beginning it has enjoyed the support of key Western allies, including the United States, Britain, Germany, Italy, and France. The mistake is to treat all claims to self-determination as though they were legally and politically interchangeable. They are not. Recognition of Kosova does not create an automatic rule for every territorial dispute elsewhere. Each case must be judged on its own history, its own facts and, crucially, what the countries involved actually did. Kosova’s independence was neither hasty nor reckless. It was the result of a prolonged struggle: apartheid and repression of ethnic Albanians in the former Yugoslavia, followed by war, ethnic cleansing, and genocide after Serbia had already committed genocide in Bosnia and embarked on a campaign to do the same in Kosova. It also involved heavy negotiations mediated by the West. Serbia had ample opportunity to negotiate, both before the NATO intervention in 1999 and before the declaration of independence in 2008. In the spring of 1999, all 19 NATO members were united in the decision to bomb a European country: Milosevic’s Yugoslavia. That speaks to how grave the situation was, especially considering that nowadays 19 countries struggle to agree on a joint press release. Formal multi-year talks on Kosova’s final status began in late 2005 under UN Special Envoy Martti Ahtisaari. Ahtisaari ultimately proposed supervised independence with an unprecedented level of protection for minorities. The International Court of Justice later concluded in its 2010 advisory opinion that Kosova’s declaration of independence did not violate international law. In September 2012, the international supervision of independence was terminated. Kosova is not Putin’s precedent. And that is precisely why Kosova matters to this argument. International law does not require pretending that fundamentally different cases are the same. To recognize those differences is not hypocrisy. It is what law is supposed to do. The same argument of lawlessness is used by newly ousted Serbian President Vucic: that Kosova’s independence violates international law, even when it does not. There is a grotesque contradiction in invoking international law while, more than 25 years later, families in Kosova are still searching for people killed during the war and for mass graves whose locations Serbia refuses to disclose. This summer, I visited Zubin Potok, a mountainous region in Kosova where human remains are being unearthed at a site deep in the woods, believed to hold civilians abducted and forcibly disappeared during the war. Among those whose remains were identified at the site are intellectuals, doctors, professors and human rights activists, abducted on April 19, 1999. More than 25 years after the war, families are still searching for the remains of murdered civilians. So much for international law. Most importantly, Kosova and Ukraine do not only share elements of the past and present. They also share a future orientation. Both want to join the European Union and NATO. To recognize Kosova would be to make that future direction stronger. For Ukraine to recognize Kosova would be to call Putin’s bluff. Recognition would reject Putin’s claim that Kosova is proof that the democracies of the West are lawless. It would reject his attempt to collapse different cases into one convenient argument. A border changed by the tanks of a superpower is not the same as a status reached after the liberation war, international administration and diplomacy. Conquest is not self-determination. Annexation is not independence. Referendum ballot boxes should not be carried by soldiers of a neighboring country, as Russian soldiers did in Crimea. Self-determination is the self-determination of a people, an act of liberation in pursuit of equality and freedom, emancipatory democracy and real independence, not the expansion or extension of another state in pursuit of its hegemonic aspirations. This matters not only for Ukraine, but for every country that fears recognizing Kosova because of what it might mean for its own territorial disputes. President Zelensky should recognize Kosova not as a favor to us, but because doing so would strengthen the very international order Ukraine has spent years defending, an order in which history is not a license for conquest, borders are not changed by force, and smaller countries are not denied their future by larger ones. Crimea is Ukraine. And Kosova is Kosova. The views expressed in this opinion article are the author’s and not necessarily those of Kyiv Post.

Original Source

Read the full article at Kyivpost →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.