Ukraine - NATO Membership for Donbas?

Ukraine - NATO Membership for Donbas?

I think most Ukrainians are trying to make sense of suggestions from US peace negotiators Kushner and Witkoff: that if Ukraine gives up the remaining territory it controls in Donbas to Russia, it will be given NATO membership, or at least NATO-like Article VI and V guarantees. But at face value, these NATO, or NATO-like, guarantees suggest that, if this deal is accepted and then Russia goes back on it and attacks Ukraine again, the US and NATO will come to its defense. Can Trump deliver NATO allies on this, and would Moscow abide by any such agreement?JOIN US ON TELEGRAMFollow our coverage of the war on the @Kyivpost_official. Meanwhile, after doing everything it can to keep Europe out of Ukraine peace talks over the past 18 months, the Trump administration now seems to be pushing Moscow to allow Europe to the negotiating table on Ukraine and the wider European security setting. On this latter note, though, Kushner and Witkoff seem to be playing to Moscow’s talking points that any peace in Ukraine needs to be linked to a broader deal to rewrite the European security architecture. But then Russia apparently restated at the Abu Dhabi talks its maximalist demands: that NATO withdraw to its 1997 force deployments, which would mean NATO troops pulling back from much of Eastern Europe, and also from Finland and Sweden. So the question is why, having made these maximalist demands, would Moscow accept any deal which would extend NATO membership to much of Ukraine – it gets more NATO on its border when it has argued that the full-scale invasion was to push back on NATO enlargement? Other Topics of Interest Joe Biden reveals in his memoir that he rejected a transition request from Donald Trump to hold direct talks with Vladimir Putin, in order to prevent “capitulation at Ukraine’s expense.” What do Kushner and Witkoff know that no one else does? Probably nothing – and probably much less than nothing. Zelensky likely thinks this is all a ruse to outflank Ukraine – make Ukraine appear as being unreasonable, to give Trump an excuse to pull support from Ukraine and push then for US-Russia normalization, and big $$ deals for the Trump clan. In response, he failed to reject the offer. But rather he argued that such a fundamental decision, if NATO membership was really on the table for giving up territory, would need to be put to the Ukrainian people in a referendum. That’s playing for more time. I actually think that if NATO membership was really part of any deal – in exchange for an end to the war – but required Ukraine to withdraw from Donbas, most Ukrainians would agree. After five years of war, most Ukrainians are desperate for peace and would see NATO membership as offering a chance of security. But would the US and NATO members really agree to any such deal when they have been stalling and balking at any such option for the duration of this war (and long before) – largely because they have not been prepared to go to war with Russia for Ukraine? I just don’t think so. And can Trump be trusted to offer NATO membership to Ukraine, and to provide the assurance that the US would come to Ukraine’s defense if attacked by Russia, when most of his current term in office has been spent undermining NATO? At this stage, I don’t think Europe is confident that the US, under Trump, would come to its defense if attacked by Russia, let alone jump in then to defend Ukraine. It makes me think that Trump’s game plan now is to bring Europe into peace talks and saddle Europe with the security backstop for Ukraine, while the US opts out and, in fact, steps back from Ukraine – allowing Trump to focus on the normalization of US-Russia relations and doing big economic deals with Russia. The reality, though, is that no NATO Article IV or V-like guarantees are worth the paper they are written on without the inclusion of the US. Ukraine is never going to buy that – stepping back, indeed giving away its frontline Donbas defenses for a weak security guarantee from Europe. Remember here that without the US, Europe likely could barely defend itself from a Russian attack, let alone actually stepping in to defend Ukraine. Russia just cannot be trusted. It might argue the need for a whole new security architecture in Europe, but there was nothing wrong with the prior architecture – the Budapest Memorandum from 1994, then the NATO-Russia Founding Act from 1997 until Russia literally decided to drive tanks through those in first invading Georgia in 2008, then Ukraine from April 2014 onwards with the annexation of Crimea. Arguably, you could also include the Russian invasion of Moldova and the capture of land in Transnistria in the early 1990s. I would argue that the problem in Europe is not NATO expansion; it’s Russia’s track record of aggression, not abiding by prior treaties, and invading other countries, which has encouraged so many European countries to seek security within NATO. So we are left here with the question: what the heck are Kushner and Witkoff up to, on behalf of Trump, and why should Ukraine or any of their supposed European allies trust them? If I were the Ukrainian, I would not. This is probably why Zelensky is seeking further clarification on the apparent NATO offer and wants to see the fine details of any proposed deal in writing. See the original in the author’s @tashecon blog here. The views expressed in this opinion article are the author’s and not necessarily those of Kyiv Post. Timothy Ash Timothy Ash is a London-based senior emerging markets sovereign strategist for Bluebay Asset Management Company.

Original Source

Read the full article at Kyivpost →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.