Two AI reviews agreeing is not two reviews: how I learned to test claims before adopting them

One night, two audits, one identical score The evening of 17 May, I finish version 0.4.1 of the Counterpart Toolkit and decide to submit it to two external reviews. I paste the manifesto and the fourteen rules into a ChatGPT-4o session, then paste exactly the same content into a Claude.ai web session. I wait. A few minutes later, both verdicts land. Score 8/10 on one side. Score 8/10 on the other. Near-identical criticisms about the theoretical apparatus — Bourdieu invoked without operational...