Turns out maybe it was the screens the whole time. A new study published by the Center for Education Policy Research at Harvard, the most comprehensive of its kind to date, found that students at schools with strict smartphone bans during school hours have seen test scores improve—and the stricter the ban, the better the outcomes. The study tracked 3.3 million students in grades three through 10, attending more than 4,600 schools in 49 states across the US, starting with the 2021-22 school year and ending in 2025-26. The study focused on Measures of Academic Progress (MAP) tests, which track achievement from the fall to the spring semester to see how kids are performing. Researchers took the scores from schools with phone bans that were implemented during the tracking period and compared them with schools that continued to allow smartphone use during school hours. The overview of the findings: the phone bans helped. Schools that required students to surrender their phones into lockable pouches found modest improvements during the first year of the restriction, with students showing academic growth the equivalent of restoring two hours per one hour of class time. That growth was also continuous, meaning students continued to show improvement year-over-year as the ban stayed in effect. In total, kids who are subject to smartphone bans saw the equivalent of 1-2 weeks of lost learning restored every academic year, per the study. Notably, those results remained consistent when controlling for other factors. The researchers said the results did not significantly differ across elementary, middle, and high schools, nor did the outcomes meaningfully change across school poverty levels or prior achievement levels. Where the results showed the most promise were in reading and math. The study showed that students who are subjected to phone bans do not experience the same drop-off in reading achievement as those in schools that allow smartphone usage during school hours, where distracted students were shown to be more likely to lose ground in reading levels. Researchers also found early evidence that suggests states that have a mandatory, bell-to-bell ban on smartphone usage may have seen the most improvements in achievement. Students in states with these strict crackdowns on screens showed positive gains in reading and math over the last academic year—though researchers did caution that the results could be reflecting some trends that were happening prior to the phone ban. To that end, there are lots of factors at play when it comes to these restrictions, which are still quite new in most places, and their results. There is also pretty inconsistent enforcement and enactment of the restrictions based on state, school district, and even individual classrooms. The good news is that any sort of intervention, including just relying on kids to not use phones in class, does produce modest improvements. Stricter crackdowns point to better outcomes in aggregate, but it’s still early, and there are a lot of variables to consider before the data, however promising, looks less muddy. Harvard’s team also suggested that there are some external factors that are unaccounted for. For instance, they noted that little is known about how social media bans for teens and children, as some states have pursued, might impact outcomes. There are also questions as to whether these restrictions are affecting kids’ lives in other ways. The researchers recommended that states start tracking things like student participation in extracurricular activities to see if phone and/or social media bans might also be increasing socialization. Similarly, they suggested tracking measures of anxiety and depression to see how the restrictions impact the mental health of students. There’s a lot to still figure out. But it does seem we’re at least starting to move in the direction of undoing some of the damage that we’ve done to younger generations. Maybe the kids will be alright.
Turns Out Taking Phones Out of the Classroom Might Actually Be Good for Students
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Gizmodo →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.