A Ninth Circuit panel questioned whether DHS regulations prohibiting loud or unusual noise near federal buildings give officers too much discretion to restrict protests.(CN) — On the inside of a federal building in Eugene, Oregon, IRS workers interviewed taxpayers. On the outside, protesters blared megaphones in opposition to the Trump administration’s immigration policies.The government called it a disruption. The protesters called it free speech.A federal judge in Oregon blocked the Trump administration earlier this year from enforcing new regulations that prohibited protesters from making unusual noise at federal buildings that could disrupt workers. But the government was back in court Thursday to ask a Ninth Circuit panel to reverse that order.“The regulatory provision at issue in this case reflects the common sense notion that loud or unusual noise emanating from right outside a federal building can disrupt government operations, just as loud or unusual noise inside the building can,” Department of Justice attorney Brian Springer told a three-judge panel. “These sorts of noise restrictions are long-standing and prevalent throughout the law.”The lower court had found the new regulation on noise was too vague under the Fifth Amendment’s due process clause, but Springer countered that, saying “the Supreme Court, this court and federal courts of appeals across the country have repeatedly and consistently upheld similar provisions against vagueness challenges like the one here, because the language affords fair notice about what conduct is covered.”However, Springer met resistance from all three members of the panel, all Joe Biden appointees, who questioned the government’s citation of related cases in its opening brief, as well as its use of language in the regulations prohibiting unusual noise.“I think anyone would appreciate that the megaphone use at issue here was precisely the type of activity that would be likely to affect people working inside this office building,” Springer told the panel.But the judges also questioned how much discretion federal officers would have to enforce the regulations and whether the regulations could apply in different types of federal buildings.“What if it’s next to a busy street?" U.S. Circuit Judge Jennifer Sung asked. “There’s a traffic jam, someone starts honking, people inside the federal building can hear it, they seem to be affected by a loud or unusual noise. Would that subject them? Would that be a violation?”Springer said the noise has to actually affect the operations of the building.“That’s exactly the question, and you’re not answering it, so I’m really interested in whether the answer is yes or no,” U.S. Circuit Judge Roopali Desai said. “If it could affect the operations of an individual inside the federal building, would it be a violation of this regulation? And if the answer is no, why not?”It depends, Springer said, adding “I think a fleeting honk is very unlikely to violate the regulation.”“It’s loud or unusual noise in areas outside of property that affects persons on the federal property,” Sung continued. “So if I can hear it, and it’s loud, why isn’t that affecting me?”“Your honor, the sorts of affects that the agency is looking for are the ones that we have in this case, where plaintiffs were using —”“But you need something in the regulation that narrows it to those ‘affects,’” Sung interrupted. “What is the plain meaning of ‘affect’? Because normally, I think, in plain meaning, affect has a very broad meaning.”Marianne Dugan, representing the protesters who sued after the regulations were issued, argued that the exchange with the government attorney illustrated why the regulation was facially unconstitutional and could not be narrowed.“You have this word ‘affects,’ which gives almost total discretion to anybody reading it who’s enforcing that rule to say, ‘Your noise is affecting the people in this building,’” said Dugan, an attorney with the Eugene-based Civil Liberties Defense Center. “The district court’s factual findings are not clearly erroneous, its conclusions of law were legally correct and the scope of the injunction is not an abuse of discretion."The regulation has a chilling effect on ordinary people who want to protest at federal buildings, she said. Despite the preliminary injunction, a protester was threatened as recently as Wednesday with a citation, she added.The protesters filed their lawsuit in December 2025, after they were cited and arrested for violating the regulations that went into affect the previous month. They are seeking a permanent injunction of the regulation.The protesters have established regular protests outside of the Eugene federal building, which is next to the office for Department of Homeland Security and Immigration and Customs Enforcement.Subscribe to our free newslettersOur weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.Additional Reads
Trump admin tries to shout down block on federal building noise regulations
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Courthousenews →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.