Thoughts to ponder: The unfinished State of Israel and the need for Esau - opinion

Thoughts to ponder: The unfinished State of Israel and the need for Esau - opinion

NOVEMBER 21, 2026 10:09Before they were enemies, Jacob and Esau were brothers. Before there was deception, exile, hatred, and fear, they shared a single womb.We usually read their story as a struggle to determine which brother would inherit the future. But perhaps that reading is already a concession to tragedy. What if the future was meant to belong to both of them?A Divine plan brokenJacob and Esau were both the sons of Isaac and Rebekah, born into the family from which the Jewish people would emerge.God’s original intention, I believe, was not that one should replace the other, but that each would have his role to play in the emerging nation. Jacob would embody the spiritual genius of Israel; Esau its courage, vitality, and ability to deal with the physical world. One would give the people its soul, the other its strength. Neither could fulfill its purpose alone.But the brothers failed each other. Misunderstanding gave way to deception; deception to resentment; resentment to separation. Esau was driven out of the Jewish story altogether, and eventually became its enemy. What should have been a partnership became a wound. Jewish history has been bleeding from it ever since.ILLUSTRATIVE: Toledo, Spain - Jun 30 2023: Torah scroll, at the Sephardic Museum (Museo Sefardí). Situated at the Synagogue of El Tránsito. (credit: SHUTTERSTOCK)This leads to a possibility so disturbing that we hardly dare consider it. What if the Torah given to Moses at Sinai was already shaped by this disaster? What if it was, in a profound sense, a lesser Torah – not the full expression of God’s original intention, but merely the Torah that could be given to a people from which Esau had been torn away?The Torah of the two brothers, the Ur-Torah, remained unrealized.An army without weaponsDeprived of Esau’s strength, the Jewish people became masters of another kind of power. Especially after the loss of its land and sovereignty, it could no longer defend itself with armies. Instead, it built a powerhouse of the spirit.One glance into the Talmud and we see the result. What an astonishing battlefield! Here the Jewish people fought with arguments instead of swords. No claim was allowed to pass unchallenged; no possibility escaped examination. The courage and ferocity that might have belonged to Esau were transformed into the intellectual religious warfare of Jacob. And this battle continues in the commentaries and sub-commentaries to this very day.This achievement was magnificent. Empires rose and fell. The Jewish people, often powerless in the usual sense, survived them all against all odds. Its enemies disappeared, but the Jewish people remained. It seemed that the soul had conquered history without the help of the body.Yet this astonishing survival also made the Jews an unbearable puzzle to the nations. How could a people without the normal instruments of power refuse to disappear? In this defiance of history lay one of the deepest sources of antisemitism: the outrage provoked not simply by what Jews did, but by the stubborn fact of what they are.And then came the Holocaust. It revealed, with utmost cruelty, what spiritual genius could not accomplish. The soul might survive, but it could not, by itself, protect the bodies of the Jewish people. The belief that Jacob could live forever without Esau was shattered.When the pendulum swung backThe rebirth of the sovereign Jewish state gave the Jewish people back something it had long been denied: the power to defend itself. Esau returned in the form of soldiers, weapons, physical courage, and national sovereignty.That return was necessary, but it was also dangerous. For the old tragedy now threatened to repeat itself in reverse. Where Jewish life had once exalted Jacob at Esau’s expense, the new state sometimes exalted Esau at Jacob’s expense. Strength became a creed.It was all too easy to fall into the illusion against which the Torah had warned: “My power and the might of my hand have gotten me this wealth” (Deuteronomy 8:17).In exile, we had sometimes behaved as though a soul could live without a body. In sovereignty, we began to behave as though a body could live without a soul.Israel has repeatedly faced moments when its survival seemed to hang by a thread. These were not only military crises. They exposed a far deeper question: Can a Jewish state endure on power alone? And if it survives by force while forgetting the spiritual purpose of its existence, what, in the end, has survived?Two halves of one peopleIn our day, something remarkable is beginning to happen. More Jews rooted in Jacob’s world are entering the army without giving up their commitment to Torah. More Jews shaped by Esau’s world are discovering that Jewish spiritual life is not a relic of the past. The brothers are beginning, however awkwardly, to recognize each other.But recognition is not reconciliation. Neither side has yet understood the full magnitude of what is required. Jacob cannot survive without Esau’s strength. Esau cannot give the State of Israel a future without Jacob’s spirit. Each is only half of the people God intended.How are we to heal a wound three thousand years old in the 78 years of Jewish sovereignty? No wonder religious and secular Israelis stumble. We are trying to reverse a catastrophe that has shaped nearly everything we have become.And we must be careful not to misunderstand the task. The answer is not to remove the “Esauness” from Esau. That would simply repeat the original disaster. Instead, it is only the more destructive aspects of Esau that must be removed. We must eliminate the hostility between the brothers, not the distinctiveness of either one.The Torah hidden within the TorahEsau represents far more than military power. He also represents science, art, culture, music, discovery, and the capacity to shape the material world. These are important additions to Jewish life. In fact, they may be indispensable parts of what God originally intended for Israel to become.This does not mean we should grant every cultural fashion the approval of the Torah. Much must still be judged, refined, and sometimes rejected.But by which Torah are we to judge? By the Torah as we have grown accustomed to reading it after centuries of separation? Or by the deeper, original Torah in which Jacob and Esau were meant to stand side by side?Perhaps this is the greatest challenge facing our sages today. Must God intervene with a new revelation? Must there be another Sinai? Or has the Torah we are searching for been concealed all along within the Torah we already possess – waiting to be discovered through a new reading of the Talmud and the great sources of our tradition?Such a discovery would not mean abandoning the Torah but, rather, uncovering a dimension of it that our broken history has prevented us from seeing.The future of Israel will not be decided by whether Jacob defeats Esau or Esau defeats Jacob. Rather, it will be decided by whether they can finally become brothers again.After all, they began their lives in the same womb.May God grant our sages the wisdom – and the courage – to bring them together.■The writer is the author of many books, such as the bestseller Jewish Law as Rebellion. Find his weekly essays at www.cardozoacademy.orgFollow us on Google

Original Source

Read the full article at Jpost →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.