AdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENTGuest EssayNov. 17, 2026, 11:00 a.m. ETCredit...Aleksey Kondratyev for The New York TimesThomas B. EdsallMr. Edsall contributes a weekly essay from Washington on politics, demographics and inequality.After the Democratic Party’s decisive midterm win, a hard-edge debate broke out among the victors over which strategies and ideologies — moderate versus progressive — mattered most in shaping the outcome.Both the center and the left are asserting their superiority in order to claim the right to determine the policies that the new House and Senate majorities should pursue over the next two years, not to mention the agenda that the Democrats’ 2028 presidential nominee should run on.These post-election debates are inevitable in a two-party system, especially when the winning side has pieced together an exceptionally large coalition encompassing intensely competitive factions.Joseph Geevarghese, executive director of Bernie Sanders’s political organization Our Revolution, declared in a statement on Nov. 4 that the election was a categorical affirmation of the left: “The blue wave was powered by a progressive wave. We are the center of gravity in this party, and we intend to drive the agenda.”“We organized to win,” Geevarghese added. “Now we organize to make Democrats deliver.”Four-square in Geevarghese’s corner, David Sirota, founder and editor in chief of the left-leaning news outlet The Lever, wrote on X:America just registered the largest pro-change, anti-oligarch election in modern history, and yet the Corporate Democrats whose formula was thoroughly rejected by voters are now demanding Democrats ignore their mandate and continue to do incrementalism.Not so fast, countered Matt Bennett, a co-founder and the executive vice president for public affairs at Third Way, a centrist Democratic think tank: “There’s simply no doubt about it: moderates made the majorities, and they cruised to victory in tough places, while farther left candidates did less well in easier races.”While Democrats on the party’s progressive wing did well two weeks ago, including Senators-elect Abdul El-Sayed, Peggy Flanagan and Troy Jackson, the reality is that moderate Democrats outperformed their co-partisans on the left.On Thursday, Lakshya Jain, one of the most impressive members of the next generation of election analysts, wrote “Do Moderates Still Have an Electability Advantage?” Jain’s take:Moderation does seem to systematically advantage a Democratic candidate by as many as three percentage points. This advantage absolutely helped Democrats build their majority: In races like the Mississippi and Alaska Senate contests … a three-point swing would probably have resulted in a Republican hold.Jain compared the performance levels of members of different Democratic caucuses to show consistent outperformances for members and PAC-endorsed candidates of such moderate groups as the Blue Dogs and New Democrats.Members and endorsees of such left-leaning groups as the Congressional Progressive Caucus, Democratic Socialists of America and Justice Democrats didn’t do as well.Jeff Maurer, of the I Might Be Wrong newsletter, published an analysis on Nov. 4 showing that in the competitive Senate races won by Democrats, the candidates endorsed by Bernie Sanders did less well compared with Kamala Harris’s 2024 margins than those who were not endorsed.There were other signs that the voters were less progressive than they appeared to be.On Feb. 17, Jain published “The Trans Rights Backlash Is Real,” with the subhead, “The Democratic Party Is Bouncing Back. The Trans Rights Movement Is Not.”Jain wrote then, “52 percent of voters now support legislation requiring trans people to use bathrooms corresponding with their biological sex, while just 33 percent oppose such a bill.” An even larger share of the electorate, 60 percent, supported laws to “require transgender K-12 athletes to compete with their birth sex” while 25 percent opposed such legislation.More important, while the results from this month’s midterms were not unanimous, voters in many states approved restrictions on tax increases, expanded property tax exemptions and, to give one telling example, raised to two-thirds the size of the vote in the state legislature required in Iowa to increase levies.“America is currently witnessing a vast and growing tax revolt,” Vox declared last Wednesday. “Even this historically Democratic voting public mostly rejected ‘tax-and-spend’ liberalism at the ballot box.”The Wall Street Journal’s Aaron Zitner did not hold back Sunday in his article “The Centrist Forces Working to Tame the Far Left on Capitol Hill”:The Democrats’ new House and Senate majorities are built on centrist candidates who won House districts and states that only two years ago voted for President Trump. That will make moderates the most powerful force in the next Congress and a likely check on the party’s most left-wing impulses.Citing comments at last week’s Majority Democrats conference in Denver, Zitner described a collection of relatively liberal unifying goals, includinga ban on stock trading by House and Senate members … and reversing cuts to Medicaid and Affordable Care Act subsidies that Trump and the Republican-led Congress approved. A higher federal minimum wage and a bill to ease labor union organizing also arose as top priorities.One sign of the power of centrists, he continued,comes from the New Democrat Coalition, the party’s moderate caucus in the House. The group says it will have 142 members next year, up from 114 now, meaning it will include more than half of all Democratic House members and will be a formidable voice on legislation.While the centrist wing of the Democratic Party generally agrees with the progressive wing on restoring health care subsidies and fighting back against the viler depredations of the Trump administration, Medicare for all is a bridge too far.Medicare for all is not, however, a bridge too far for the American people, further confounding things — and ideological formations.In a Sept. 16-21 survey, KFF Health Tracking Polls asked, “Do you favor or oppose having a national health plan, sometimes called Medicare for all, in which all Americans would get their insurance from a single government plan?”A decisive majority supported Medicare for all, at 66 percent (32 percent strongly, 34 percent “somewhat favor”) and 34 percent opposed (19 percent “strongly,” 15 percent “somewhat”).Eighty-four percent of Democrats favored (52 percent strongly and 32 percent somewhat) while 16 percent opposed (4 percent strongly, 12 percent somewhat. Independents were 72 percent in favor (31 strongly, 41 somewhat) while 28 percent opposed (12 strongly and 16 somewhat).Thirty-four percent of Republicans favored Medicare for all (9 percent strongly, 25 somewhat) and 66 percent of Republicans were opposed (48 strongly, 18 somewhat).While Democratic factions are duking it out over who deserves credit for their victory, there is little doubt they both should thank President Trump — his corruption, his failed policies and his weakening economy — for the size and scope of their victory.In his post-election analysis, “2026 U.S. Midterm Elections: Some Preliminary Considerations,” Herbert Kitschelt, a Duke political scientist and an expert in right-wing populism both here and abroad, argued that Trump fits a broad profile:Right-wing populists have never engaged in critical policies to increase security of jobs and incomes of broad swaths of wage earners or in explicitly redistributive measures to bolster the fortunes of the economically weak.They do not embrace inclusive public pension, health care or income support programs and refrain from raising progressive taxes or extending social insurance benefits to poor people beyond their actuarial entitlements based on contributions. They do not increase educational opportunities for the worse-off or make health care more universal.While in opposition, Kitschelt continued, “radical right populist parties can paper over their lack of capacity and willingness to address any of these issues. But once in power, the chickens come home to roost.”Trump, according to Kitschelt, fits “a stylized sequential pattern” in whichright-wing authoritarians begin to restrict civil liberties, intimidate mass media and selectively oppress opposition as soon as they gain office. But as long as economies perform relatively well, such measures become publicly salient and generate resistance only among limited politically involved publics, particularly in intellectual circles of metropolitan areas.Populist leaders, including Trump, have not only shown little interest in policies that actually benefit core working-class supporters but have instead backed tariffs, tax and spending cuts and criminal levels of self-enrichment that worsen conditions.“As populist incumbents begin to manipulate the allocation of economic resources and create a crony capitalist economy,” Kitschelt wrote, “public disaffection grows.”At that point, authoritarian leadership begins to run into serious opposition:As these grievances intensify, they will crystallize around an outcry against corruption and self-enrichment by regime incumbents and their kinship fabrics and friends. The patrimonial transformation of economy and state into a self-dealing apparatus of a plutocratic network becomes the catalyst of mobilization.The election revealed another crucial restraint on Trump: the unexpected strength of the American political system.In an interview with the European Center for Populism Studies, Frances Lee, a political scientist at Princeton, argued that the contest revealed “significant institutional resilience against efforts to stack the deck in favor of one party or another.”“A key source of that resilience,” she added, “is the decentralization of the U.S. electoral system. The party in power had no mechanism through which it could change the rules of the game nationwide.”Lee did not downplay the Trump administration’s concerted efforts to undermine the system:There has been considerable pressure on civil society since the administration took office in 2025. We have seen federal funding used as leverage to induce compliance among civil society organizations, universities and researchers, as well as immigration enforcement used to suppress debate on college campuses. These actions and the pressure exerted by the administration are troubling. Due process has not been respected, and the rule of law has been disregarded in numerous ways.But, Lee continued,The question is whether these actions actually have the power to tilt the electoral playing field in favor of the governing party. Here, I think the case is much weaker.When the administration pressures news organizations and threatens them through the Federal Communications Commission, there remains a wide range of media beyond its regulatory reach, including social media and online discussion.Civil society, in Lee’s view, “remains vibrant. Numerous organizations oppose the administration, and many states are governed by Democrats, the party opposing the president. So, there is still a free-for-all in public debate. Political discourse is not controlled in any meaningful sense.”In other words, an almost invisible fabric of dispersed bureaucratic powers, an expanding and largely unregulated system of communication and the strength of the Democratic Party at the state level have so far stood the test under adverse circumstances.Finally, Lee pointed out that polarization is a constraint on populist leaders: “No leader has demonstrated an ability to achieve overwhelming popularity in U.S. politics during the polarized era.”Fareed Zakaria, to my mind an undervalued columnist, has put his finger on one of the strengths of the besieged Democratic Party.On Friday in his column “The Anti-Democratic Party Won — and Shows the Way Forward,” Zakaria argued that at a time of public distain of both Democrats and Republicans, Democrats have wisely become “an anti-party party.”He wrote that one month before the electionthe Pew Research Center asked Americans their views of the two parties. Sixty-one percent viewed the Republicans unfavorably, and 58 percent had the same negative view of Democrats.This dissatisfaction with the two main political parties has been growing in recent decades, and the number of independents has been climbing — reaching 45 percent of U.S. adults in 2025, according to Gallup. So how, amid this growing alienation, did the Democrats pull off a landslide?The Democratic Partyfought this midterm with a motley crew of mavericks. Many openly criticized the Democratic Party itself. Axios did an analysis of campaign ads from Aug. 24 to Sept. 22 in recent election years and found that this year 47 Democratic-aligned ads criticized their own party or both parties, up from just 14 during that span in 2018.Candidates were all over the map, “from pro-life and pro-oil and gas on the one hand to Medicare for all and anti-ICE on the other. It turns out that loosening ideological conformity allowed Democrats to be more authentic and more responsive to their local constituencies.”An anti-party party, from this vantage point, Zakaria contended,does not need to be incoherent. It should instead be an organization that is stronger at the bottom and looser at the top. Power should flow from the grass roots, not from the bigwigs in Washington issuing diktats.When Democrats “speak the language of cultural leftism — on asylum, trans women in sports or diversity, equity and inclusion — that dynamic is reversed. They are speaking as the elites — often down to the masses, who must be instructed in how to be virtuous.”The 2026 election, according to Zakaria,was a Democratic wave, not a liberal one. Many of the candidates who won big were moderates. Many of the ballot initiatives that prevailed were conservative. Polling suggests that on many key issues — illegal immigration, crime, major social issues — Americans are still center-right. But it might well have been an election to reward the Democrats’ anti-establishment style: a big tent and a practical organization that reflects the diversity of this country.I don’t agree 100 percent, but I do in the main. Perhaps the most important issue for Democrats is that no wing or faction can or should silence intraparty competitors.Jennifer Victor, a political scientist at George Mason, has some thoughts that strangely resonate with Zakaria’s analysis:I think of political parties as giant, organic masses made up of various components. We never truly know what’s in the mass, but elections give us a snapshot.A party that wins elections on the scale that Democrats won last week is not only a large coalition, but it’s a diverse one. The Democratic Party that won over voters in Mississippi is not necessarily the same Democratic Party that won over voters in Minnesota. The fact that all those candidates won under the same party label gives party leaders a difficult task.Without putting too much of a kumbaya feel to it, I’d put it this way: A democratic political party should provide its voters a means of expression and avoid serving as a force of repression.Thomas B. Edsall has been a contributor to the Times Opinion section since 2011. His essays on strategic and demographic trends in American politics appear every Tuesday. He previously covered politics for The Washington Post. Related ContentAdvertisementSKIP ADVERTISEMENT
The Something-for-Everyone Midterms Are Confusing
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Nytimes →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.