The question that could unravel Burnham’s benefits reforms

The question that could unravel Burnham’s benefits reforms

Assistant editor of The Spectator magazine and author of Fighting for Life When Alan Milburn was trying to sell his health reforms as a minister in the Blair government, he told a gathering of senior doctors that the NHS was “drinking in the last chance saloon”. This became a famous quote, but was nonetheless subject to a round of broken telephones as it made its way through the health service. By the time it reached a regional briefing that Milburn’s wife, a doctor, found herself at, the civil servant leading the session told the audience: “You’ve got to understand that what the secretary of state is really after here is to really change the NHS because the NHS is engaged in a gunfight at the OK Corral.” Milburn and Andy Burnham will find themselves in that gunfight at the OK Corral over the benefit reforms that they are announcing this week. The long-trailed proposed reforms to tackle the million young people not in education, employment or training (Neets) have largely been framed by the Prime Minister as being compassionate, long-term investment in getting people into decent jobs. But they are also confronting and involve a level of tough love that is going to unsettle a good few Labour MPs – perhaps even Burnham himself. Milburn’s proposals might initially land well, with Labour MPs largely supportive of the principle of helping the young. The gunfight will come when the detail starts to emerge over the next year or so of legislating. Burnham has been very clear that he does not want to approve crude cuts that bring the welfare bill down while causing real hardship at the same time. That’s his way of selling the reforms to the Labour Party, which is always instinctively anxious about welfare. But his Work and Pensions Secretary, Pat McFadden, has more of a bad cop persona in this, giving interviews where he insists that having a disability “doesn’t always rule out work” and that “there will be people in the future who will not get what they would get today”.Milburn’s proposals will include removing the health element of universal credit (UC) for under-25s in favour of a “youth allowance”, which will be at the basic rate of UC. The personal independence payment would also be scrapped for this group of young people, with a new “additional cost allowance” to cover the cost of living with a more limited range of conditions. Milder cases of depression, anxiety, autism or ADHD won’t be considered sufficient reason to stay away from employment. So the group of people whose health issues or neurodiversity mean they get help from the state will shrink significantly. That in itself is likely to provoke really difficult and painful political debate once the detail starts being set out in the legislation, with Labour MPs all having different views on where to set the bar. Burnham has never given the impression up to this point that he’s been any different to his colleagues when it comes to reacting to individual case studies where someone is losing out, and it is not clear yet whether he has the stomach to face down both unhappy young people and anxious Labour MPs. He might be lulled into a false sense of security by the reaction on the very well-rolled pitch to what Milburn suggests this week, only to find that at some point next year, he and McFadden are holding a lot of meetings with anxious backbenchers because they’ve decided that, say, moderate depression is a condition that can be reasonably managed in a workplace and therefore someone suffering from it shouldn’t get extra health benefits to stay out of work. We’ve been here before many times on welfare reform, particularly around the delicate matter of health and disability. Many of today’s Labour MPs were cutting their political teeth in the 2010s when the Conservative-led government was struggling to maintain support for disability benefit assessments that had been started by Labour but which had become mired in controversy over the way they ruled certain people fit for work on the basis of arbitrary tests involving picking up empty cardboard boxes. Those work capability assessments were particularly bad at taking into account relapsing and remitting conditions, which include mental illness but also many other health problems such as post-viral fatigue, postural tachycardia syndrome and functional neurological disorder. It was difficult then for the architects of the tests and the assessors to work out what was a reasonable expectation and what someone really could sustainably manage in work over a long period of time. It is still difficult now, and that difficulty is something Labour backbenchers are already highly attuned to. Milburn has been clear that his reforms will take a long time to come to fruition, and that’s where much of the debate has been focused: can young people really wait that long? But they’ll be waiting even longer if, as may still be the case, Burnham finds he cannot get those changes past his MPs in any meaningful way. By the time this gunfight at the OK Corral falls silent, the reforms may have too many holes in them to function.

Original Source

Read the full article at Inews →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.