The ‘public trust’ lie is getting people killed

The ‘public trust’ lie is getting people killed

Ask any detective working a violent crime beat or any deputy running a county jail booking desk what happens when politics overrides basic law enforcement cooperation, and you will get an answer that sounds nothing like the talking points coming out of city hall.For years, advocates of “sanctuary” policies and noncooperation mandates have leaned on a single, neatly packaged slogan: When local police work with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, it erodes public trust and stops victims from reporting crimes.It sounds compassionate on a campaign flyer. On the street, it falls apart. First, let’s stop pretending civil immigration violations excuse violent crimes. Advocates love to frame immigration enforcement as a matter of mere “civil infractions” — a paperwork error or a visa overstay. That talking point collapses in the real world. When an individual with a violent criminal history — someone arrested on charges of domestic assault, armed robbery, felony weapons charges, or repeat DUIs — walks free because a county jail refuses to honor an ICE detainer, they are no longer just a civil violator. They are a dangerous criminal thrust right back into the very communities sanctuary politicians claim to protect. How many more U.S. citizens or law-abiding legal immigrants must be assaulted, robbed, or killed at the hands of repeat offenders before local governments stop treating public safety as a political game?Second, the “chilling effect” argument relies on a glaring double standard and ignores federal law that already exists. Local police departments routinely partner with the Drug Enforcement Administration on narcotics task forces, with the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives on gun trafficking, and with the FBI on violent gangs. Nobody suggests that joint operations with the ATF stop gun violence victims from calling 911, or that working with the DEA makes neighborhoods afraid to report drug houses. Law enforcement cooperation is universally recognized as a force multiplier until the federal agency involved is ICE.More importantly, Congress already addressed the witness-fear issue decades ago. Federal law created U Visas and T Visas for undocumented victims of violent crimes and human trafficking who help police and prosecutors, giving them a pathway to legal status and protection from removal. The tools to protect cooperating victims already exist. Shielding violent offenders from ICE under the guise of “protecting victims” doesn’t add protection; it just hands criminals a free pass.Look at the actual numbers, not advocacy polling. There is no clearance-rate data and no empirical proof showing that severing ties with ICE solves more homicides or brings more witnesses forward. The Department of Justice’s own National Crime Victimization Survey shows immigrants report serious violent crime at rates comparable to native-born citizens. Reluctance to talk to police in high-crime neighborhoods is driven by fear of gang retaliation, anti-police sentiment, and a revolving-door justice system, not by whether a county sheriff honors a federal detainer at the jailhouse door.And let’s be honest about what happens when local politicians forbid jail transfers. ICE does not pack up and go home. When a county jail refuses to honor a detainer and releases an offender onto the street, federal agents are forced to leave the controlled, secure environment of the booking facility and conduct at-large arrests inside apartment complexes, neighborhoods, and workplaces. Blocking jail cooperation doesn’t protect immigrant communities. It guarantees higher-profile field operations and puts officers, bystanders, and families at greater risk.Even the legal excuses used to justify these policies don’t hold up under judicial scrutiny. Jurisdictions frequently claim that honoring ICE detainers exposes them to Fourth Amendment lawsuits. Yet, that excuse ignores how easily local agencies can insulate themselves: working directly with federal officers on probable-cause detainers or 287(g) partnerships puts local enforcement squarely on solid constitutional ground.The courts have made this explicitly clear. In City of El Cenizo v. Texas, 890 F.3d 164 (5th Cir. 2018), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit upheld state requirements mandating local compliance with ICE detainer requests and cooperation with federal immigration authorities, explicitly rejecting the argument that honoring federal detainers inherently violates the Fourth Amendment when backed by probable cause of removability. Similarly, federal courts have consistently affirmed the validity of Section 287(g) agreements under the Immigration and Nationality Act, confirming that local officers can legally perform designated immigration enforcement functions under federal supervision.THE ICE SHOCK GLOVE IS NOT THE STORY. WHO’S WEARING IT ISEven sanctuary jurisdictions that claim to make “exceptions” for serious felonies often bury those carve-outs behind narrow conviction thresholds — meaning an offender arrested multiple times for violent offenses walks out the door before a final conviction is ever reached.Make it make sense. You cannot claim to champion community safety while actively handcuffing local law enforcement from removing violent predators. Public trust isn’t destroyed when a dangerous criminal is deported. Public trust is shattered when a victim calls 911, watches police make an arrest, and sees that same suspect back on the block 48 hours later because politicians prioritized ideology over human lives.Scott Mechkowski served more than 24 years in federal immigration enforcement, retiring as deputy field office director for ICE’s Enforcement and Removal Operations in New York City. He was a certified arrest techniques and non-deadly force instructor and served over 30 years in the military. He is a visiting fellow for deportation studies at the Oversight Project.

Original Source

Read the full article at Washingtonexaminer →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.