The market is changing. What does that mean for agency growth in 2027?

The market is changing. What does that mean for agency growth in 2027?

This Partner Perspective is part of a series brought to you by Vertafore.View series At the beginning of 2026, independent agencies expected a shift in market conditions. In Vertafore’s 2026 Agency Outlook, 42% of agency professionals predicted the insurance market would stabilize, while another quarter expected conditions to vary by line of business. As the year comes to a close, those expectations have largely played out. Carriers have become more competitive in some lines, while underwriting capacity remains tight in others. Premium growth has slowed, but the change hasn’t been uniform across the market. For independent agencies, the shift raises an important question: How much of their growth comes from rising premiums, and how much comes from winning and retaining business? More carrier competition…but not everywhere After several years of hard-market conditions, carriers entered 2026 in a stronger financial position. Improved underwriting profitability gave many insurers greater capacity and more appetite to compete for business. The Big “I” 2026 Market Share Report found that the industry’s overall combined ratio improved from 92% in 2024 to 88% in 2025. That improvement gave carriers more room to pursue growth into 2026. But not every line has benefited equally. Commercial auto, for example, recorded a combined ratio of 101% in 2025, requiring insurers to pay out more in claims and expenses than they collected in premiums. Medical malpractice, international and private crop insurance also reported combined ratios above 100%. Where carriers are competing more aggressively, agents may have more options to find competitive coverage, remarket accounts and win new business. But in lines where underwriting results remain challenging, limited capacity and tighter underwriting standards can still make placements difficult. The result: A market that requires agencies to pay close attention to where carrier appetite is changing and how those changes affect their clients and business opportunities. E&S activity is up even as premium growth slows The excess and surplus (E&S) market offers another example of how insurance conditions have changed this year. At the beginning of 2026, nearly half of respondents in Vertafore’s Agency Outlook expected their E&S placements to remain steady, while another 45% expected to place more E&S business this year. The E&S market remained active in 2026, but growth varied significantly by line of business. According to WSIA’s 2026 midyear report, premiums grew 2.8% across 15 states with surplus lines stamping offices, while item filings increased 16.9%. Property showed an especially sharp contrast: premiums declined 13.7%, even as item filings increased 15.2%. Meanwhile, non-professional liability premiums grew 11.2%. These differences reflect a market where conditions are changing at different speeds. Property pricing has softened in some areas, while liability continues to drive premium growth. And these figures point to an important distinction: Slower premium growth doesn’t necessarily mean less insurance activity. Changes in pricing, coverage mix and the types of risks being placed can affect premium volume even as the number of item filings rises. For agencies, E&S remains an important part of the placement strategy, even as standard carriers become more competitive. The opportunity is to understand where markets are opening up, where specialty coverage remains essential and how to find the right options for clients as conditions change. In 2027, agency growth will depend on performance According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, U.S. P&C direct written premiums increased just 2.3% in the first half of 2026, compared with 6% during the same period in 2025. The years-long hard market certainly created challenges for agencies, but rising premiums also provided a tailwind for agency revenue. An agency could generate higher commission revenue from renewals without necessarily adding new clients or policies. As premium growth slows, that tailwind has weakened. Independent agencies face a new challenge: generating more revenue growth through new business, retention and account expansion. That makes it increasingly important to look beyond topline revenue and understand what is driving the business: New business production shows whether an agency is expanding its client base. Retention reveals whether it is protecting existing relationships, particularly as clients gain more options to shop their coverage. Account expansion reflects opportunities to meet more of a client’s insurance needs. Tracking policy counts alongside premium and commission revenue helps distinguish growth in business volume from changes in pricing. Together, these measures provide a clearer picture of an agency’s underlying performance and opportunities. The independent agency channel enters this next phase from a position of strength. According to the Big “I” report, independent agencies accounted for 62.1% of U.S. property and casualty premiums in 2025. Maintaining that position and growing individual businesses will require agencies to find new ways to compete. Creating more capacity for agency growth in 2027 With the new year just weeks away, agencies primed for growth are those that make the most of their people’s time and expertise. AI is creating new opportunities to do exactly that. By handling time-consuming work such as gathering submission information, comparing policy documents and preparing renewal information, AI can help agencies increase capacity without adding the same level of administrative work. But the value of AI in agency workflows goes beyond saving time. AI can bring together information from across systems, identify changes or issues that need attention, and give insurance professionals the insights they need to make faster, more informed decisions. That creates opportunities to change how work gets done across an agency. Producers can spend more time identifying coverage gaps and pursuing new business. Service teams can focus on complex client needs and strengthening relationships. And agency leaders can use better business intelligence to spot opportunities and make decisions that support growth. Rather than simply doing more work faster, agents, account managers, and CSRs can direct more time and expertise toward the work that creates the most value. As the insurance market enters a new phase and a new year, agencies have an opportunity to take greater control of their growth. The competitive advantage will come from how effectively they combine technology with the relationships, expertise and judgment that have always made independent agencies successful. AI built for independent agencies: See it in action.

Original Source

Read the full article at Insurancejournal →

KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.