November 23, 2026 — 5:00amMost AFL clubs want the father-son rule scrapped if it forms part of sweeping changes they believe are needed in a reimagining of the entire player movement industry of drafts, free agency, academies and talent pathways.All 19 clubs, including incoming club Tasmania, were polled by this masthead on a wide range of issues about player movement and development.Star Collingwood father-son players Nick and Josh Daicos.Artwork: Aresna Villanueva. Photos: Getty Images/AFL PhotosThe club representatives – a mix of chief executives, list managers, recruiters and football managers – spoke on the condition of anonymity in order to speak freely.Clubs are frustrated that the current system has grown organically with annual changes, and would not be the system the AFL would choose if it started from scratch.“The AFL keeps saying the draft is one of the three pillars of competitive balance. It is not,” one senior football figure said. “They have to stop saying that, they look foolish. It has nothing to do with competitive balance any more when the bottom teams can be denied access to the best players because they are tied to NGAs [next-generation academies], northern academies and father-sons.“When the lowest clubs lose free agents to the best clubs and the best clubs keep their draft pick and everyone else is punished with a compensation pick, it is nothing to do with competitive balance or equalisation.”The clubs unanimously backed the idea of hosting an industry-wide forum next year with a view to introducing changes in 2030.The time frame takes account of the fact the next two drafts are heavily compromised by the building of the new Tasmanian club’s list and the AFL commencing negotiations on a new collective bargaining agreement with the players.Nominating 2030 for potential changes to the system would give clubs a strong lead time to prepare.All clubs backed scrapping the rookie list and having one playing list plus a continued provision for category B rookies (for players such as those from Ireland or non-football backgrounds). The clubs said the rookie list was unnecessary as long as the players taken late in the draft – perhaps after the third round – were only on one-year contracts.The clubs were unanimous that free agency needed to be properly reviewed, saying it had not had the effect that was intended when it was introduced in 2012. Free agency was expected to help lower clubs with money to spend bring in quality players. It has had the opposite effect, where the best free agents have been going to the top clubs – for example, Richmond winning a flag and then getting Tom Lynch as a free agent, and the Brisbane Lions winning premierships and still taking Sam Draper (Essendon) and Oscar Allen (West Coast).Recently retired former Sydney and Brisbane Lions list manager Kinnear Beatson echoed the sentiments of the clubs on free agency.“I don’t think free agency has worked as they meant it to. The best free agents have not gone to the low clubs. They have to look at a change there,” Beatson said.“And as an industry, are we doing enough to develop the talent pool with 19 clubs and potentially a 20th club? And that is AFL and AFLW. I think you need to look at those talent pathways in Victoria, WA and SA.”The overwhelming majority of clubs – 15 of the 19 – said change was needed to prevent the sort of side deals that were attached to the free agency moves this off-season of Zak Butters (Port Adelaide to the Western Bulldogs) and Ben King (Gold Coast to Hawthorn).“There is no world in which any club would do the trade the Western Bulldogs did and give up everything they did for what they got back if it wasn’t tied to Butters,” said one list manager. “It was a complete sham, but it was waved through.” A variation of this comment was made by 14 other clubs.Some suggested the top-finishing clubs – possibly the top four or six – be precluded from securing free agents. Several clubs felt that would be unfair if a club spent the year courting a player and agreeing terms but then snuck into the last of the top positions and being prohibited from securing the player.Many felt that any team that finished in the finals and then secured a free agent who drew first-round compensation for the club they left should lose their own first-round draft pick. For instance, Hawthorn wouldn’t have been able to bring in King and keep their first-round draft pick, which they used this year to also trade for Zach Merrett.Fresh start: All eyes will be on Zach Merrett at his new club, Hawthorn.Hawthorn FCThe majority of clubs were sceptical of the new Indigenous rookie list, describing it as a sugar hit that would potentially spike Indigenous numbers at AFL level in the short term but do little to address the underlying problem of neglected development pathways.Eleven of the 19 clubs said the AFL should do away with the father-son rule to try to restore integrity to the draft. But a majority favoured keeping the rule if it was not offset by a broader overhaul of the compromises to the draft from northern academies and/or the next-generation academies.A majority of clubs felt the northern academies had been effective in growing talent, but disliked the inequitable distribution of those players throughout the competition. Seven clubs approved of the academies, six wanted to scrap them, six more felt the academy in NSW was still needed but Queensland now no longer required an academy as participation levels were high there.Sam Draper became a premiership-winning Lion after his switch from the lowly Bombers.AFL PhotosMost clubs felt the AFL used the draft as a game-development tool to avoid having to spend money on talent pathways, which had been neglected throughout the country, especially since COVID.Clubs overwhelmingly wanted the AFL to better fund talent pathways, in particular investing more heavily in Victoria, South Australia and Western Australia.All clubs argued the problem was not the amount spent on the northern academies, or their effectiveness, but the amount spent on the other states’ pathway programs and the equality of access to those players.“The draft is not working anything like it was intended,” said one veteran industry figure.“There are too many compensation picks, too many players excluded from being freely available because they are father-sons or tied to academies.Selected from under the Lions’ noses: Caylen Murray was stunned to become a Sydney Swan.Joe Armao“It makes sense after Tasmania to be able to have a reset and with a lead time to know changes will come in in 2030.”The points system – the draft value index (DVI) – which allocates a points value to draft picks, was vehemently opposed by some clubs, while others thought that, even though it was complicated, the recent changes to the value of points and to limiting how many picks a club could use to match a bid on a father-son or academy player had improved the fairness. A handful of clubs had no strong opinion on the index.This survey was conducted before the national draft, when new scaling of the DVI and rules around father-son and academy players made it harder for them to be matched. This year it meant the Lions lacked the points to match Sydney’s bid on academy player Caylen Murray at pick No.9.Despite the survey taking place before the draft, a majority of clubs said, while they knew the latest changes made it harder to match bids, they still wanted a fresh, broad overview of the draft, academies and player movement.Controversially, with long contracts now commonplace as an inflationary consequence of free agency, all clubs wanted the right to trade players over a certain pay threshold without their consent. All doubted this would get approval, given the AFL Players’ Association’s opposition to it.Clubs unanimously agreed that they should have the right to “pick purchase” – to buy a draft pick from another club using their salary cap space to pay cash. In recent times, salary dumping has been approved – such as gold Coast giving up a good draft pick along with Jack Bowes to Geelong so that the Cats took on all of Bowes’ contract and so gave the Suns salary cap space.Pick purchasing would mean salary cap space could be bought with just a draft pick and no player involved. It would also enable clubs at the bottom of the ladder who, despite having a large amount of salary cap space, have historically been unable to attract the best free agents on big money deals, to use the salary cap instead to buy in more draft picks.“The notion you now pay fair price [for father-sons or academy players] is nonsense. There is no fair price when you finish top four, but you get priority access to a top-four player in the draft, and you conjure a way to satisfy some special formula and points system. The fact is, the club in the bottom four does not get access to that player. That is disadvantaging the bottom-four clubs in a system that is supposed to be the most fundamental tool of equalisation,” one recruiter said.“We deny that club in the bottom four access to one of the best players in the competition just because his dad played at the club, and we still say the draft is about equalisation? We have a salary cap, a soft cap, a fixture – but the No.1 equalisation mechanism is the draft, and we have cooked it.”Keep up to date with the best AFL coverage in the country. Sign up for the Real Footy newsletter.From our partners
The father-son rule is an AFL fan favourite. Here’s why clubs would want it scrapped
Full Article
Original Source
Read the full article at Smh →KhanList aggregates and links to publicly available news content. We do not host full articles from third-party sources. Always verify important information with original sources.